When a researcher asks a participant to lie still in a dark, quiet MRI scanner for ten minutes and "rest," they are making a bold assumption: that the participant will remain in a stable, wakeful state. In reality, the "resting state" is a misnomer. Within minutes, most subjects begin to drift across a spectrum of vigilance, ranging from alert focus to drowsy daydreaming and even light sleep.
This drift is not just a minor distraction; it is a fundamental driver of the neural signals we measure. Daniel J. Lurie and Aaron Kucyi argue in Questions and controversies in the study of time-varying functional connectivity in resting fMRI that these fluctuations in arousal are primary drivers of observed changes in brain connectivity. If we don't account for them, we risk mistaking a sleepy participant for a patient with a neurological disorder.
The Global Signal as a Proxy for Arousal
For years, neuroscientists debated the meaning of the "global signal"—a brain-wide fluctuation in activity seen in almost all fMRI scans. Some dismissed it as noise, while others saw it as meaningful neural coordination. Xiao Liu and Jeff H. Duyn provided a breakthrough in Subcortical evidence for a contribution of arousal to fMRI studies of brain activity.
By comparing human fMRI with macaque electrophysiology, they showed that massive, brain-wide spikes in cortical activity co-occur with deactivations in deep-brain arousal centers. Essentially, when your "internal thermostat" for alertness drops, the cortex reacts with a massive signal surge. Without modeling this relationship, researchers might map these spikes as stable functional networks when they are actually transient "arousal events."
The Risk of Misdiagnosis
The stakes for understanding these fluctuations are highest in clinical and developmental research. If drowsiness alters the "flicker" of brain connectivity, it can easily be confused with pathological signatures.
- Mental Health: Zening Fu found that in large populations of children, drowsiness can manifest as neural patterns that mimic biomarkers for psychopathology or low cognitive scores Cognitive and psychiatric relevance of dynamic functional connectivity states in a large (N > 10,000) children population.
- Chronic Pain and Depression: Studies by Yiheng Tu and Hossein Dini suggest that because drowsiness mimics the connectivity patterns of chronic pain or major depression, failing to monitor wakefulness makes it difficult to isolate the true disease-specific signatures Dynamic Functional Connectivity Predicts Treatment Response to Electroconvulsive Therapy in Major Depressive Disorder.
- Aging: Even simple behavioral choices, like whether a subject has their eyes open or closed, can introduce more variance into the data than their biological sex Convergent transcriptomic and neuroimaging signature of Autism Spectrum Disorder.
The Developmental Baseline Problem
The challenge is even more acute in pediatric neuroimaging. Wei Gao and colleagues have extensively mapped how the brain's "wiring diagram" matures in the first two years of life Temporal and Spatial Evolution of Brain Network Topology during the First Two Years of Life. However, because infants can usually only be scanned while asleep, a "baseline" problem arises.
As Weiyan Yin notes in Charting brain functional development from birth to 6 years of age, we must find ways to harmonize data across different states of consciousness. If an infant is scanned during REM sleep and an adult is scanned while awake, are the differences we see due to development or simply the state of the brain at that moment? Masoud Seraji emphasizes that without concurrent EEG to distinguish sleep stages, longitudinal data contains uncontrolled variability that can obscure the true trajectory of brain maturation Spatial development of brain networks during the first six postnatal months.
Toward Vigilance-Aware Neuroimaging
If arousal is such a powerful confounder, how do we fix it? The field is moving toward "vigilance-aware" analysis, treating physiological state as a variable to be measured rather than ignored.
One approach is to use the fMRI data itself as a thermometer for alertness. Maryam Falahpour and Thomas T. Liu developed a template-based method that matches real-time brain activity against spatial maps of drowsiness, allowing researchers to predict vigilance fluctuations without needing extra equipment Template-based prediction of vigilance fluctuations in resting-state fMRI.
Another method involves using peripheral markers. Jiahui Wang demonstrated that heart rate variability (HRV) can identify "sleepy" data points. By excluding these segments, the test-retest reliability of brain connectivity measures improves significantly Improving the Test-Retest Reliability of Resting State fMRI by Removing the Impact of Sleep.
Ultimately, the goal is to treat physiological states like drowsiness as nuisance variables—much like we currently treat head motion. By accounting for the "flicker" of arousal, we can finally see the stable neural architecture beneath.