Zoledronic acid augments the radiosensitivity of cancer cells through perturbing S- and M-phase cyclins and p21CIP1 expression

Chi Du, Yuyi Wang, Haijun Li, Yi Huang, Ou Jiang, Yanjie You, Feng LuoOncology 2017 · DOI

Abstract

Radiotherapy and adjuvant chemotherapy have become the standard treatments for multiple types of cancer. Although cancer cells are usually sensitive to radiotherapy, metastasis and local failure still occur mainly due to developed resistance to radiotherapy. Thus, it is critical to improve therapeutics for cancer treatment. The present study demonstrated that third-generation bisphosphonate zoledronic acid (ZOL), even at a low concentration, augments the radiosensitivity of cancer cells exposed to ionizing radiation (IR) by inducing S-phase arrest and subsequently promoting apoptosis. This function of ZOL was associated with elevated levels of cyclin A and cyclin B in the S and M phases, as well as decreased p21<sup>CIP1</sup> expression. In addition, ZOL also inhibited the malignant invasiveness of cancer cells. Notably, these effects could be enhanced concurrently with IR. The present data indicated that combined treatment with ZOL plus IR may be a novel technique to augment the radiosensitivity of cancer cells.

The Challenge of Radioresistance

Radiotherapy remains a cornerstone of oncology, yet its efficacy is frequently undermined by radioresistance. Cancer cells often develop survival mechanisms that allow them to withstand high-energy radiation, resulting in local recurrence and distant metastasis. To address this, researchers are exploring "radiosensitizers"—agents that can be administered alongside radiation to amplify its lethal effects on tumors without increasing toxicity to healthy tissues.

While Zoledronic acid (ZOL) is clinically established for treating bone loss, its potential as a radiosensitizer and the underlying molecular mechanisms have not been fully elucidated until now.

Methodology

The study utilized two human nasopharyngeal carcinoma cell lines, HNE-1 and CNE-2, to evaluate the synergistic effects of ZOL and ionizing radiation (IR). The researchers employed a multi-faceted experimental approach:

  • MTT Assay: To assess baseline toxicity and growth inhibition.
  • Clonogenic Survival Assay: The definitive test for radiosensitivity, measuring a cell's ability to proliferate into a colony post-irradiation.
  • Flow Cytometry: To analyze cell cycle distribution and identify phase-specific arrests.
  • Transwell Invasion Assay: To evaluate the impact on metastatic potential.
  • Western Blotting: To quantify regulatory proteins including Cyclins A, B, D1, E, and inhibitors p21 and p27.

Key Insights: The "S-Phase Trap"

A pivotal discovery of this research is that ZOL induces S-phase arrest. Cells are most vulnerable to radiation damage during specific phases of the cell cycle. By "trapping" cells in the S-phase, ZOL ensures a higher proportion of the tumor population is in a state susceptible to IR-induced death.

Figure 5: Flow cytometry analysis of HNE-1 cells showing a significant increase in the S-phase population and sub-G1 (apoptotic) cells when ZOL is combined with ionizing radiation (IR).

This sensitization is linked to a specific molecular signature: an increase in Cyclin A and B (regulators of S and M phases) and a decrease in the cell cycle inhibitor p21<sup>CIP1</sup>. This protein imbalance likely drives cells into a prolonged progression state that ultimately triggers apoptosis.

Key Results

Enhanced Radiosensitivity

Pre-treatment with a low dose of ZOL (2 µM) significantly reduced the surviving fraction of cancer cells across radiation doses ranging from 2 to 6 Gy. The clonogenic assay visually confirmed that the combination of ZOL and IR was far more effective at preventing colony formation than radiation alone.

Figure 6: Clonogenic survival assay demonstrating that ZOL treatment significantly enhances the lethal effect of 4 Gy ionizing radiation (IR) compared to radiation alone.

Inhibition of Invasion

The study also found that the combination treatment was exceptionally effective at blocking cancer cell invasion. The number of cells migrating through the basement membrane in Transwell assays dropped by approximately 70-80% in the combination group, suggesting that ZOL may help prevent metastasis even if the primary tumor is not completely eradicated by radiation.

Limitations and Future Directions

While these in vitro results are promising, several steps remain before clinical application:

  • In Vivo Validation: The findings must be confirmed in animal models to account for the complex tumor microenvironment and systemic drug metabolism.
  • Broader Cancer Types: Future research should investigate if this radiosensitizing effect extends to other malignancies, such as lung or breast cancer.
  • Pathway Mapping: While changes in cyclins and p21 were identified, the precise upstream signaling pathways (potentially involving Ras or Rho proteins) require further mapping.
  • Clinical Optimization: Determining the ideal timing for ZOL administration relative to radiotherapy will be crucial for maximizing the "S-phase trap" in patients.

Summary updated

Abstract

Radiotherapy and adjuvant chemotherapy have become the standard treatments for multiple types of cancer. Although cancer cells are usually sensitive to radiotherapy, metastasis and local failure still occur mainly due to developed resistance to radiotherapy. Thus, it is critical to improve therapeutics for cancer treatment. The present study demonstrated that third-generation bisphosphonate zoledronic acid (ZOL), even at a low concentration, augments the radiosensitivity of cancer cells exposed to ionizing radiation (IR) by inducing S-phase arrest and subsequently promoting apoptosis. This function of ZOL was associated with elevated levels of cyclin A and cyclin B in the S and M phases, as well as decreased p21<sup>CIP1</sup> expression. In addition, ZOL also inhibited malignant the invasiveness of cancer cells. Notably, these effects could be enhanced concurrently with IR. The present data indicated that combined treatment with ZOL plus IR may be a novel technique to augment the radiosensitivity of cancer cells.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{du2017zoledronic,
  author = {Chi Du and Yuyi Wang and Haijun Li and Yi Huang and Ou Jiang and Yanjie You and Feng Luo},
  title = {{Zoledronic acid augments the radiosensitivity of cancer cells through perturbing S- and M-phase cyclins and p21CIP1 expression}},
  booktitle = {Oncology},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3892/ol.2017.6710},
}
Figure