Zircon ages and Hf isotopic compositions of plutonic rocks from the Central Tianshan (Xinjiang, northwest China) and their significance for early to mid-Palaeozoic crustal evolution

Yuruo Shi, Ping Jian, Alfred Kröner, Bor‐ming Jahn, Dunyi Liu, Wei Zhang, Huadóng MaInternational Geology Review 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the early to mid-Palaeozoic crustal evolution of the Central Tianshan region in China by analyzing zircon ages and Hf isotopic compositions of plutonic rocks. The findings reveal distinct magmatic episodes, suggesting a complex interplay of juvenile crustal growth from mantle sources and reworking of an ancient Precambrian crust, culminating in lower crustal delamination during the Late Devonian.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The tectonic history and crustal evolution of the Central Tianshan region, a key component of the Central Asian Orogenic Belt, have been a subject of debate. Previous interpretations often relied on assumptions of continuous subduction and arc formation. This paper aims to provide a more detailed understanding of the early to mid-Palaeozoic crustal evolution by integrating new geochronological and isotopic data, specifically addressing how the continental crust grew and was modified during this critical period. The authors seek to resolve conflicting models regarding the dominant tectonic processes (e.g., accretionary vs. extensional) and the nature of magmatism in this region.

Methods

The study employs standard but robust geological and geochemical techniques:

  • Zircon U–Pb dating: Performed using SHRIMP II and LA-ICP-MS instruments to determine the crystallization ages of the plutonic rocks. This is a well-established method for precise geochronology.
  • Hf-in-zircon isotopic analysis: Conducted using a multi-collector ICP-MS to measure the Hf isotopic composition (εHf(t)) of zircons. This technique provides insights into the source of the magmas, distinguishing between juvenile mantle-derived material and older, reworked crust.
  • Whole-rock major and trace element analysis: Carried out using XRF and ICP-MS to characterize the chemical composition of the rocks, helping to classify them (e.g., calc-alkaline, adakitic, shoshonitic) and infer their petrogenetic processes.
  • Geochemical modeling: Used to calculate crustal model ages (TDM1 and TDM2) and interpret the isotopic signatures in the context of crustal growth and evolution.

Datasets

The study utilizes newly collected samples from two localities in the Chinese Central Tianshan (Baluntai and Sangshuyuanzi) and one from the northern margin of the Chinese South Tianshan. These samples were analyzed for their zircon ages and Hf isotopic compositions. The authors also extensively review and integrate published zircon age data and whole-rock Nd–Sr isotopic compositions from previous studies in the region to build a comprehensive picture of crustal evolution.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Precambrian Basement: The presence of abundant Precambrian xenocrystic zircons in younger granitoids strongly suggests an underlying, ancient Precambrian continental basement in the Central Tianshan. This challenges models that focus solely on Phanerozoic accretion.
  • Episodic Magmatism: The early to mid-Palaeozoic period was characterized by at least three distinct magmatic episodes, indicating a dynamic and episodic crustal evolution rather than a continuous process.
  • Dual Source Magmatism: Early Ordovician magmatism shows a mix of positive and negative εHf(t) values, indicating both juvenile mantle input and reworking of older crust. This highlights a complex interplay of processes.
  • Geodynamic Transition: A significant shift occurred between the Late Ordovician–Silurian (ca. 458–442 Ma) and a later sub-episode (ca. 434–425 Ma). The former shows predominantly crustal sources (negative εHf(t)), while the latter clearly indicates a juvenile, mantle-derived source (positive εHf(t)).
  • Late Devonian Delamination: The undeformed, adakite-like granites of the Late Devonian are interpreted as a result of lower crustal delamination, a process often associated with over-thickened crust.

Key Results

  • Early Ordovician (ca. 475–473 Ma): Plutonic rocks show a range of zircon εHf(t) values from +0.3 to +9.5 (juvenile) and -6.0 to -12.9 (crustal), indicating mixed sources.
  • Late Ordovician–Silurian (ca. 458–425 Ma): Two sub-episodes are identified: an earlier one (ca. 458–442 Ma) with predominantly crustal sources (εHf(t) -6.3 to -13.1) and a later one (ca. 434–425 Ma) with juvenile sources (εHf(t) +2.6 to +8.9).
  • Early Devonian (ca. 410–404 Ma): Rocks exhibit near-zero εHf(t) values (-1.4 to +3.5), suggesting a balanced contribution from mantle and crust.
  • Mid-Devonian (ca. 393 Ma): Plutons show distinctly negative εHf(t) values (-11.2 to -14.8), pointing to derivation from ancient crust.
  • Late Devonian (ca. 368–361 Ma): Undeformed, adakite-like granites have negative whole-rock εNd(t) values (-2.4 to -5.3), interpreted as crustal inheritance.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that further detailed work is needed to fully constrain the magma sources of the widespread ca. 419–393 Ma granitoids in the Chinese Central Tianshan, Yili Block, and Chinese South Tianshan. While the study provides a robust framework for understanding the early to mid-Palaeozoic evolution, the precise mechanisms and timing of mantle-crust interaction and delamination could benefit from more detailed isotopic investigations and integration with geophysical data. The authors also suggest that the proposed Precambrian basement and its connection to the Tarim Block warrant further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present new zircon ages and Hf-in-zircon isotopic data for plutonic rocks and review the crustal evolution of the Chinese Central Tianshan (Xinjiang, northwest China) in the early to mid-Palaeozoic. The Early Ordovician (ca. 475–473 Ma) granitoid rocks have zircon εHf(t) values either positive (+0.3 to +9.5) or negative (−6.0 to −12.9). This suggests significant addition of juvenile material to, and coeval crustal reworking of, the pre-existing continental crust that is fingerprinted by numerous Precambrian zircon xenocrysts. The Late Ordovician–Silurian (ca. 458–425 Ma) rocks can be assigned to two sub-episodes of magmatism: zircon from rocks of an earlier event (ca. 458–442 Ma) has negative zircon εHf(t) values (−6.3 to −13.1), indicating a predominantly crustal source; zircon from later events (ca. 434–425 Ma) has positive zircon εHf(t) values (+2.6 to +8.9) that reveal a predominantly juvenile magma source. The Early Devonian (ca. 410–404 Ma) rocks have near-zero zircon εHf(t) values, either slightly negative or positive (−1.4 to +3.5), whereas the Mid-Devonian rocks (ca. 393 Ma) have negative values (−11.2 to −14.8). The Late Devonian (ca. 368–361 Ma) granites are undeformed and are chemically similar to adakite but have relatively low negative whole-rock εNd(t)values (−2.4 to −5.3). We interpret the Early Ordovician to Mid-Devonian magmatic event to reflect combined juvenile crustal growth and crustal reworking processes via episodic mafic underplating and mantle–crust interaction. The Late Devonian episode may signify delamination of the over-thickened Chinese Central Tianshan crust.
BibTeX
@article{shi2014zircon,
  author = {Yuruo Shi and Ping Jian and Alfred Kröner and Bor‐ming Jahn and Dunyi Liu and Wei Zhang and Huadóng Ma},
  title = {{Zircon ages and Hf isotopic compositions of plutonic rocks from the Central Tianshan (Xinjiang, northwest China) and their significance for early to mid-Palaeozoic crustal evolution}},
  journal = {International Geology Review},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1080/00206814.2014.942807},
}
Figure