Zero-Shot Dialogue Relation Extraction by Relating Explainable Triggers and Relation Names

Ze-Song Xu, Yun-Nung ChenACL 2023

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of dialogue relation extraction (DRE) by proposing a novel zero-shot approach. Instead of relying on massive labeled datasets for every possible relation, the method leverages "explainable triggers" (keywords) and relation names to infer relationships that the model hasn't explicitly seen during training. This significantly improves the scalability and practical applicability of DRE systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dialogue Relation Extraction (DRE) is crucial for understanding conversations, but traditional supervised methods require vast amounts of labeled data for each relation type. This makes it difficult and expensive to scale DRE to new, unseen relations. Existing models trained on limited data can only identify relations they've been explicitly trained on, failing to recognize similar but novel relationships. This paper aims to bridge this gap by enabling DRE models to predict unseen relations by learning to connect explicit cues (triggers) within the dialogue to the names of potential relations.

Methods

The core of the proposed approach is a reformulation of the DRE task from multi-class classification to multiple binary classification tasks. This allows the model to evaluate each potential relation independently. The architecture consists of three main components:

  • Trigger Prediction: Inspired by question-answering models, this component identifies "trigger" words or phrases within the dialogue that are indicative of a specific relationship between a subject and object. This is framed as an extractive question-answering task where the dialogue is the document, the subject-object pair is the question, and the trigger span is the answer.
  • Relation Name Injection: Unlike previous methods that treat relation names as mere labels, this approach injects the natural language description of the relation name directly into the model's input. This provides the model with a richer understanding of what each relation signifies.
  • Binary Relation Prediction: This component takes the relation name embedding and the predicted trigger span as input. A general attention mechanism is used to establish the connection between the relation name and the trigger words. The output is a binary prediction indicating whether the subject and object have the given relation.

The model is trained using multi-task learning to simultaneously predict triggers and perform relation prediction. Negative sampling is employed to create challenging training examples. For inference, a crucial modification is made: the trigger span is replaced with a general context embedding to prevent overfitting to seen relations and improve generalization to unseen ones.

Datasets

The experiments were conducted using the DialogRE dataset. The authors divided the dataset's 36 relations into 20 "seen" relations (used for training) and 16 "unseen" relations (used for zero-shot evaluation).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Relating Triggers to Relation Names is Key: The paper highlights that explicitly connecting dialogue triggers (keywords) to the semantic meaning of relation names is crucial for generalizing to unseen relations.
  • Relation Name Semantics Matter: Injecting the natural language description of relation names into the model's input significantly improves its ability to understand and predict unseen relations, outperforming methods that solely rely on predicted triggers.
  • Preventing Overfitting to Seen Relations: A critical insight is the need to modify the input during inference (replacing trigger spans with general context embeddings) to prevent the model from defaulting to predicting seen relations, thereby enhancing its zero-shot capabilities.
  • Trigger Identification Aids Reasoning: While the primary goal is zero-shot prediction, the ability to identify explicit triggers also contributes to the interpretability of the DRE task.

Key Results

  • Significant Improvement in Unseen Relations: The proposed method, particularly when using relation name embeddings, achieved the best performance for unseen relations, reaching 32.5% for top 1 and 34.8% for top 2 ranked predictions. This is a substantial improvement over the reformulated BERT baseline (24.9% and 28.9%).
  • Competitive Performance on Seen Relations: The proposed models also achieved comparable scores to previous state-of-the-art methods on seen relations (66.7% vs. 66.8% in top 1 scores), demonstrating strong overall performance.
  • Gold Triggers as Upper Bound: Using gold-standard triggers during inference yielded the highest results, indicating the strong potential of the trigger mechanism.
  • Qualitative Analysis: The paper notes that while triggers can accurately capture subject-object information, models can still tend to predict seen relations. The proposed method with relation name embeddings helps mitigate this tendency.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Tendency to Predict Seen Relations: The authors acknowledge that even with their proposed method, there's a tendency for the model to prioritize predicting seen relations, especially when similar triggers are present. This is observed in the qualitative example where "uncle" triggers the "per:children" relation instead of the unseen "per:other_family."
  • Further Improvement with Gold Triggers: The best performance is achieved when using gold triggers, suggesting that improving trigger prediction accuracy could further boost overall performance.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that their approach is a promising solution for real-world applications due to its enhanced generalization and practicality. Further research could focus on refining trigger prediction and exploring more sophisticated ways to leverage relation name semantics for even better zero-shot performance.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2023zero,
  author = {Ze-Song Xu and Yun-Nung Chen},
  title = {{Zero-Shot Dialogue Relation Extraction by Relating Explainable Triggers and Relation Names}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure