Youths’ awareness and attitudes towards raising the minimum legal age of smoking and passive smoking in Singapore

Kalaipriya Gunasekaran, Prashwin Singh, Ding Xuan Ng, Yi Ling Eileen Koh, H. Lee, Rei Tan, Yier Wang, Ngiap Chuan TanFrontiers in Public Health 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

A study of over 600 Singaporean youth reveals overwhelming support (80.3%) for raising the minimum legal age (MLA) for smoking to 21. Interestingly, the youngest participants (aged 15–17) were the most supportive of the restriction, suggesting that early-intervention policies align well with the attitudes of the very demographic they aim to protect.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Tobacco use remains a leading cause of preventable death globally. Because the vast majority of smokers begin the habit during adolescence—a period of significant brain development—public health officials have turned to "Tobacco 21" policies to delay or prevent initiation.

Singapore raised its MLA from 18 to 21 in 2021. However, legislative change doesn't always guarantee cultural buy-in. The authors sought to investigate whether Singaporean youth actually support these laws or if the restrictions trigger a "forbidden fruit" effect, where the illegality of the product increases its allure. Additionally, the study explores youth awareness of passive smoking (second-hand smoke) in a high-density urban environment where proximity to smokers is often unavoidable.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional study using a 23-item electronic survey distributed via secure platforms (FORMSG) and social media (WhatsApp and Telegram) between September and November 2022.

To analyze the data, they employed:

  • Descriptive Statistics: To summarize demographics and awareness levels.
  • Chi-Squared Tests: To find associations between demographic variables and support for the MLA change.
  • Multivariable Logistic Regression: To calculate Odds Ratios (OR), allowing the team to determine which factors (like age or smoking status) were independent predictors of support for the law.
  • Post-hoc Bonferroni Correction: A statistical adjustment used to ensure that findings across multiple age groups remained significant and weren't just due to chance.

Datasets

The study utilized a primary dataset generated from 608 survey respondents aged 15–24 living in Singapore. While the study did not use external benchmarks, it compared its findings against international data, such as the International Tobacco Control (ITC) Four Country Survey and US-based studies by the CDC.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Age Paradox: Contrary to the idea that teenagers might rebel against age-based restrictions, the 15–17 age group was 2.1 times more likely to support the MLA 21 law than those aged 21 and above. This suggests that younger adolescents may be more receptive to health-centric messaging or more aware of the risks before they reach the legal age.
  • The "Non-Smoker" Mandate: Unsurprisingly, smoking status was the strongest predictor of attitude. Non-smokers were 4 times more likely to support the MLA 21 bill than current or past smokers.
  • Social Circles Over Mass Media: When asked what effectively discourages smoking, youth ranked family influence (64%) and school education (55.6%) as the most potent factors. Conversely, traditional anti-smoking advertisements (19.1%) and smoking alternatives like e-cigarettes (11.5%) were viewed as significantly less effective.
  • Passive Smoking Awareness: Awareness of the harms of passive smoking is exceptionally high (nearly 90%), yet exposure remains a major issue due to Singapore’s urban layout. Open public spaces and smoking corners at food establishments were identified as the primary "hotspots" for second-hand smoke.

Key Results

  • High Approval: 80.3% of participants supported the implementation of MLA 21.
  • Statistical Significance: Support for the law was significantly associated with age ($p=0.005$), ethnicity ($p=0.021$), and smoking status ($p<0.001$).
  • Passive Smoking: 89.8% of respondents were aware of the harmful effects of passive smoking, and 78% had experienced indoor passive smoking.
  • Economic Deterrents: Younger cohorts (15–17 and 18–20) were significantly more likely to view cigarette pricing as an effective deterrent compared to the 21–24 age group.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Selection Bias: The use of a convenience sample via social media may not perfectly represent the entire Singaporean youth population, particularly those who are less "tech-savvy" or lack internet access.
  • Social Desirability Bias: Since smoking is highly stigmatized in Singapore, some respondents may have provided "correct" answers rather than their true feelings.
  • Cross-sectional Nature: The study provides a snapshot in time; it cannot track how attitudes change as a specific individual grows older.

Future Work: The authors suggest that future efforts should focus on "less cognizant" youth through targeted public education. They also highlight the need for more research into how family dynamics can be leveraged as a primary tool for tobacco cessation, given its high ranking in the survey.

Summary updated

Abstract

Most of the youth express strong support for raising the MLA to 21, with over 80% in favor of such change, reflects a significant harmony among youth in favor of tobacco-free environment.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gunasekaran2024youths,
  author = {Kalaipriya Gunasekaran and Prashwin Singh and Ding Xuan Ng and Yi Ling Eileen Koh and H. Lee and Rei Tan and Yier Wang and Ngiap Chuan Tan},
  title = {{Youths’ awareness and attitudes towards raising the minimum legal age of smoking and passive smoking in Singapore}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2024.1359929},
}
Figure