Abstract
We use a purely data-driven rectified factor analysis to identify early-type galaxies with young (≲ 4 Gyr) stellar populations in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Spectroscopic Catalogue. We call these galaxies E+F galaxies, analogous to E+A galaxies. These galaxies lie in the ‘Green Valley’, between the blue cloud and the red sequence on the colour-magnitude diagram. As such, these galaxies may represent an important transient stage in the evolution of galaxies from blue and star-forming to red and passive. We investigate the distribution in projected local galaxy surface density of the E+F galaxies, and compare it with the environment of early-type and E+A galaxies. We find that i) the E+A distribution peaks strongly in projected local galaxy surface density, $\Sigma_5$, at ~ 0.1−0.2 Mpc$^{−2}$, ii) early-types have a flatter peak at ~ 0.06−0.2 Mpc$^{−2}$, iii) the E+Fs lie somewhere in between, and iv) the distributions of the models do not agree well with the data, peaking at higher densities, and under-predicting the number of E+As at low ($\Sigma_5 < 0.3$ Mpc$^{−2}$) densities. The dearth of E+A and E+F galaxies in dense environments confirms that E+A and E+F galaxies are most likely the products of galaxy-galaxy merging or interactions, rather than star-forming galaxies whose star formation has been quenched by processes unique to dense environments, such as ram-pressure stripping or galaxy harassment. The similarity of the environments in which the E+F population and the E+A galaxy sample are found, together with the spectral evidence, suggests that E+F galaxies are E+A galaxies, which have evolved by a further ~ one to a few Gyr.
Introduction: The Stellar Population Dichotomy
In the standard hierarchical model of the universe, smaller objects are expected to form first. However, observations of early-type galaxies (ETGs) often reveal a "dichotomy": smaller present-day ETGs frequently host younger stellar populations than their more massive counterparts. Understanding the star-formation history of these galaxies is essential to mapping the transition from the "blue cloud" of active star formation to the "red sequence" of passive, evolved stars. This study identifies a transient population in the "Green Valley" to determine if their star formation was halted by internal mergers or external environmental quenching.
Methods: Rectified Factor Analysis
To identify these transition galaxies, the authors employed Rectified Factor Analysis (RFA), a data-driven machine learning technique. Unlike traditional template matching, RFA decomposes over 10,000 SDSS spectra into statistically independent components. By enforcing a positivity restriction, the model ensures physically realistic flux values.
The analysis revealed that ETG spectra are effectively described by two primary components: a mature, metal-rich stellar population and a younger (~4 Gyr) population resembling an F-type star. Galaxies dominated by this younger component are classified as E+F galaxies, representing a longer-lived successor to the well-known "E+A" (post-starburst) galaxies.
The Evolutionary Bridge
E+F galaxies appear to be the missing link between post-starburst (E+A) galaxies and standard passive ETGs. Spectral evidence suggests that E+Fs are essentially E+As that have aged by an additional 1 to 4 billion years. On the color-magnitude diagram, these galaxies occupy the "Green Valley," confirming their status as a transient evolutionary stage.
Environmental Analysis and Results
A key question is whether these galaxies are formed by cluster-specific processes like ram-pressure stripping or by galaxy-galaxy mergers. The study analyzed the projected local galaxy surface density ($\Sigma_5$) for different populations:
- E+A galaxies peak strongly at $\Sigma_5 \sim 0.1–0.2 \text{ Mpc}^{-2}$.
- General ETGs show a flatter distribution peaking at $\sim 0.06–0.2 \text{ Mpc}^{-2}$.
- E+F galaxies fall between these two, supporting the theory of evolution from the E+A phase toward the general ETG population.
The relative lack of E+A and E+F galaxies in high-density environments suggests they are primarily products of galaxy-galaxy mergers or interactions in low-to-medium density regions, rather than environmental quenching in massive clusters.
Conclusion and Model Discrepancies
The study identified 970 E+F galaxies within the SDSS sample. Notably, current semi-analytic models fail to reproduce these observations, over-predicting the prevalence of such galaxies in high-density environments while under-predicting them in low-density regions. This discrepancy highlights the need for more sophisticated modeling of galaxy interactions outside of massive clusters to accurately reflect the observed "Green Valley" population.
Summary updated