Young stellar populations in early-type galaxies in the SDSS

L. A. Nolan, Ata Kabán, Markus Harva, Andrew Benson, Somak RaychaudhuryProceedings of the International Astronomical Union 2007 · DOI

Abstract

We use a purely data-driven rectified factor analysis to identify early-type galaxies with young (≲ 4 Gyr) stellar populations in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Spectroscopic Catalogue. We call these galaxies E+F galaxies, analogous to E+A galaxies. These galaxies lie in the ‘Green Valley’, between the blue cloud and the red sequence on the colour-magnitude diagram. As such, these galaxies may represent an important transient stage in the evolution of galaxies from blue and star-forming to red and passive. We investigate the distribution in projected local galaxy surface density of the E+F galaxies, and compare it with the environment of early-type and E+A galaxies. We find that i) the E+A distribution peaks strongly in projected local galaxy surface density, $\Sigma_5$, at ~ 0.1−0.2 Mpc$^{−2}$, ii) early-types have a flatter peak at ~ 0.06−0.2 Mpc$^{−2}$, iii) the E+Fs lie somewhere in between, and iv) the distributions of the models do not agree well with the data, peaking at higher densities, and under-predicting the number of E+As at low ($\Sigma_5 < 0.3$ Mpc$^{−2}$) densities. The dearth of E+A and E+F galaxies in dense environments confirms that E+A and E+F galaxies are most likely the products of galaxy-galaxy merging or interactions, rather than star-forming galaxies whose star formation has been quenched by processes unique to dense environments, such as ram-pressure stripping or galaxy harassment. The similarity of the environments in which the E+F population and the E+A galaxy sample are found, together with the spectral evidence, suggests that E+F galaxies are E+A galaxies, which have evolved by a further ~ one to a few Gyr.

Introduction: The Stellar Population Dichotomy

In the standard hierarchical model of the universe, smaller objects are expected to form first. However, observations of early-type galaxies (ETGs) often reveal a "dichotomy": smaller present-day ETGs frequently host younger stellar populations than their more massive counterparts. Understanding the star-formation history of these galaxies is essential to mapping the transition from the "blue cloud" of active star formation to the "red sequence" of passive, evolved stars. This study identifies a transient population in the "Green Valley" to determine if their star formation was halted by internal mergers or external environmental quenching.

Methods: Rectified Factor Analysis

To identify these transition galaxies, the authors employed Rectified Factor Analysis (RFA), a data-driven machine learning technique. Unlike traditional template matching, RFA decomposes over 10,000 SDSS spectra into statistically independent components. By enforcing a positivity restriction, the model ensures physically realistic flux values.

The analysis revealed that ETG spectra are effectively described by two primary components: a mature, metal-rich stellar population and a younger (~4 Gyr) population resembling an F-type star. Galaxies dominated by this younger component are classified as E+F galaxies, representing a longer-lived successor to the well-known "E+A" (post-starburst) galaxies.

Spectral decomposition using Rectified Factor Analysis showing the young stellar component (comp 1) and mature populations.

The Evolutionary Bridge

E+F galaxies appear to be the missing link between post-starburst (E+A) galaxies and standard passive ETGs. Spectral evidence suggests that E+Fs are essentially E+As that have aged by an additional 1 to 4 billion years. On the color-magnitude diagram, these galaxies occupy the "Green Valley," confirming their status as a transient evolutionary stage.

Environmental Analysis and Results

A key question is whether these galaxies are formed by cluster-specific processes like ram-pressure stripping or by galaxy-galaxy mergers. The study analyzed the projected local galaxy surface density ($\Sigma_5$) for different populations:

  • E+A galaxies peak strongly at $\Sigma_5 \sim 0.1–0.2 \text{ Mpc}^{-2}$.
  • General ETGs show a flatter distribution peaking at $\sim 0.06–0.2 \text{ Mpc}^{-2}$.
  • E+F galaxies fall between these two, supporting the theory of evolution from the E+A phase toward the general ETG population.
Distribution of galaxy fractions across different local surface densities ($\Sigma_5$), comparing E+A, E+F, and general early-type galaxies.

The relative lack of E+A and E+F galaxies in high-density environments suggests they are primarily products of galaxy-galaxy mergers or interactions in low-to-medium density regions, rather than environmental quenching in massive clusters.

Conclusion and Model Discrepancies

The study identified 970 E+F galaxies within the SDSS sample. Notably, current semi-analytic models fail to reproduce these observations, over-predicting the prevalence of such galaxies in high-density environments while under-predicting them in low-density regions. This discrepancy highlights the need for more sophisticated modeling of galaxy interactions outside of massive clusters to accurately reflect the observed "Green Valley" population.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We use a purely data-driven rectified factor analysis to identify early-type galaxies with young (≲ 4 Gyr) stellar populations in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Spectroscopic Catalogue. We call these galaxies E+F galaxies, analogous to E+A galaxies. These galaxies lie in the ‘Green Valley’, between the blue cloud and the red sequence on the colour-magnitude diagram. As such, these galaxies may represent an important transient stage in the evolution of galaxies from blue and star-forming to red and passive. We investigate the distribution in projected local galaxy surface density of the E+F galaxies, and compare it with the environment of early-type and E+A galaxies. We find that i) the E+A distribution peaks strongly in projected local galaxy surface density, Σ 5 , at ~ 0.1−0.2 Mpc −2 , ii) early-types have a flatter peak at ~ 0.06−0.2 Mpc−2, iii) the E+Fs lie somewhere in between, and iv) the distributions of the models do not agree well with the data, peaking at higher densities, and under-predicting the number of E+As at low (Σ 5 &lt; 0.3 Mpc −2 ) densities. The dearth of E+A and E+F galaxies in dense environments confirms that E+A and E+F galaxies are most likely the products of galaxy-galaxy merging or interactions, rather than star-forming galaxies whose star formation has been quenched by processes unique to dense environments, such as ram-pressure stripping or galaxy harassment. The similarity of the environments in which the E+F population and the E+A galaxy sample are found, together with the spectral evidence, suggests that E+F galaxies are E+A galaxies, which have evolved by a further ~ one to a few Gyr.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nolan2007young,
  author = {L. A. Nolan and Ata Kabán and Markus Harva and Andrew Benson and Somak Raychaudhury},
  title = {{Young stellar populations in early-type galaxies in the SDSS}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1017/s1743921308018206},
}
Figure