Young Chinese Consumers’ Choice between Product-Related and Sustainable Cues—The Effects of Gender Differences and Consumer Innovativeness

Osmud Rahman, Benjamin C. M. Fung, Zhimin ChenSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores how young Chinese consumers make apparel choices, focusing on the interplay between product features, sustainability, gender, and individual innovativeness. It reveals that while men lean towards brand and origin, women prioritize style and color, and both genders show a greater concern for social/ethical sustainability over environmental aspects.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The fashion industry faces increasing pressure to adopt sustainable practices, yet understanding consumer behavior in this area, especially in diverse markets like China, remains complex. While sustainability is gaining traction, its influence on purchasing decisions is not fully understood, particularly how it interacts with traditional product attributes and demographic factors like gender and consumer innovativeness. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating which cues (intrinsic, extrinsic, and sustainable) young Chinese consumers prioritize when choosing apparel, and how these preferences differ based on gender and their propensity to adopt new fashion trends.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative approach using a self-administered online survey. The survey collected data on:

  • Sustainable commitment and behavior: Measured using eight items.
  • Consumer fashion innovativeness: Assessed using six items from the Domain-Specific Innovativeness (DSI) scale, categorizing participants into "fashion innovators" and "fashion non-innovators."
  • Product cues: Participants rated the importance of 20 product cues, categorized into:
  • 10 intrinsic cues (e.g., color, style, durability, comfort, fabric, quality, garment fit, garment life, certified eco-label, certified ethical label).
  • 3 extrinsic cues (brand name, country of origin, price).
  • 7 sustainable cues (e.g., less water usage, air quality, less energy usage, worker safety, fair wages, no child labor, no animal skin use).
  • Demographics and behavior: Including age, gender, income, education, and annual clothing expenditure.

Statistical analyses, including t-tests and correlation analysis, were used to examine the relationships between these variables and test the proposed hypotheses.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from a survey of 1,819 young Chinese consumers. No external datasets were used for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Gendered Preferences: A significant divide exists in how men and women evaluate apparel. Men prioritize brand name and country of origin, likely as shortcuts when unfamiliar with products, while women focus more on aesthetic cues like style and color.
  • Sustainability's Nuance: While consumers are aware of sustainability, its impact isn't uniform. Chinese consumers in this study showed a stronger concern for social/ethical aspects (e.g., fair wages, no child labor) than environmental ones.
  • Innovators vs. Non-Innovators: Fashion innovators are more willing to spend on apparel and are more influenced by aesthetic cues like style and color, aligning with a desire for novelty and self-expression.
  • The "Six Pockets" Effect: The study touches upon the "six-pocket" phenomenon in China, where children receive significant financial support, potentially explaining the higher disposable income and focus on non-essential product attributes.

Key Results

  • Hypothesis Support: Four out of eleven hypotheses were fully supported, four were partially supported, and three were not supported.
  • Gender Differences:
    • Men relied more on brand name and country of origin (Hypothesis 1a supported).
  • Women relied more on style and color (Hypothesis 1b supported).
  • Durability and comfort were more important for men, but the results were mixed (Hypothesis 1c partially supported).
  • Price was not a significant differentiator between genders (Hypothesis 1d not supported).
  • Women were more concerned about "no animal skin use" than men (Hypothesis 2 partially supported).
  • Both genders relied more on intrinsic cues than sustainable cues (Hypothesis 3 partially supported).
  • Consumer Innovativeness:
    • Fashion innovators spent more on apparel (Hypothesis 4 supported).
  • Innovators relied more on style and color (Hypothesis 5a supported).
  • Comfort was more important for innovators than durability (Hypothesis 5b not supported).
  • Production-related sustainable cues were not significantly different between innovators and non-innovators (Hypothesis 6a not supported).
  • Product-related sustainable cues showed mixed results (Hypothesis 6b partially supported).
  • Overall Cues: "Comfort" was rated as the most important cue overall, followed by "fit," "quality," and "style." Brand name and country of origin were rated as the least important.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Generalizability: The study focused on young Chinese consumers, limiting generalizability to other age groups or cultural contexts.
  • Product Scope: Apparel was the sole product category studied, and findings may not apply to other consumer goods.
  • Methodology: Future research could benefit from employing mixed methods, such as ethnography or eye-tracking, and longitudinal studies to capture evolving consumer preferences and behaviors over time.
  • Comparative Studies: Comparative analyses of online vs. offline eco-clothing evaluation, or across different demographics and countries, could provide deeper insights.

Future work could also explore other apparel cues, such as wardrobe coordination and versatility, and delve deeper into the "why" behind consumers' purchasing behaviors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sustainability has received widespread attention in both academia and industry, but there is still a paucity of research investigating the relationships between gender, consumer innovativeness, and clothing, as well as how they may influence sustainable practices. The overarching objective of this study is to investigate clothing expenditure, product cues (intrinsic, extrinsic and sustainable), gender (men and women) and consumer innovativeness (fashion innovators and non-innovators) in China, in order to find out how these factors may influence consumers’ choices. To address the research objective, 10 intrinsic cues, three extrinsic cues, and seven sustainable cues were used to investigate apparel consumers’ choices and preferences. A self-administered online survey consisted of eight items on sustainable commitment and behaviour, six items of fashion innovativeness adapted from the Domain-Specific Innovativeness scale, 20 items concerning product cues, and numerous demographic and behaviour-related questions. In total, 1819 usable data were collected in China, including 614 males and 1196 females. The results revealed that four out of eleven hypotheses were supported, another four were partially supported, while the remainders were not. For example, both female consumers and fashion innovators relied more on style and colour to evaluate an apparel product than fashion non-innovators and male consumers. However, men tended to rely more on the brand name and country of origin to guide their product selection and purchases than women. In terms of the influence of sustainable cues, Chinese consumers are more concerned about the social/ethical cues than environmental cues. Interestingly, women were more concerned about “no animal skin use” in evaluating apparel products than men. All in all, the results of this study can provide valuable information and meaningful insight for fashion designers, product developers, and marketers to develop effective communication strategies to guide potential customers in understanding a plethora of apparel values, including functionality, aesthetics, finances, altruism, and sustainability.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rahman2020young,
  author = {Osmud Rahman and Benjamin C. M. Fung and Zhimin Chen},
  title = {{Young Chinese Consumers’ Choice between Product-Related and Sustainable Cues—The Effects of Gender Differences and Consumer Innovativeness}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su12093818},
}
Figure