Abstract
The awareness of facial expressions allows one to better understand, predict, and regulate his/her states to adapt to different social situations. The present research investigated individuals' awareness of their own facial expressions and the influence of the duration and intensity of expressions in two self-reference modalities: a real-time condition and a video-review condition. The results revealed that awareness rates were 57.79% in the real-time condition and 75.92% in the video-review condition. The awareness rate was influenced by intensity and duration differently across modalities. These findings extend our understanding of human facial expression self-awareness.
Introduction
In social interactions, we often assume we have a clear handle on the "vibe" we are projecting. However, researchers have long noted a disconnect between what people think they are expressing and what others actually see—a phenomenon often summarized by the phrase, "You should have seen the look on your face." While previous research has extensively explored how we recognize emotions in others, very little work has quantified how aware we are of our own facial movements.
This study aimed to bridge this gap by comparing two types of self-awareness:
- Real-time (Somatosensory) Awareness: Sensing the "feeling" of muscles tensing and moving.
- Video-review (Visual) Awareness: Identifying movements when looking at ourselves from an external perspective.
The researchers sought to determine the "detection thresholds"—the specific levels of intensity and duration required for a person to realize they have made a facial expression.
Methods
The researchers recruited 27 participants and utilized a facial neutralization paradigm. Participants watched high-arousal emotional videos (designed to elicit happiness, disgust, or anger) and were instructed to maintain a "poker face." This setup was designed to trigger "leaked" expressions—subtle, involuntary movements that occur despite attempts to suppress them.
The experiment was split into two phases:
- Phase 1 (Real-time): Participants pressed a spacebar the moment they felt any facial movement.
- Phase 2 (Video-review): Participants watched recordings of their own faces from Phase 1 and pressed a button when they saw a facial movement.
A primary dataset of 353 leaked facial expression samples was generated from 23 valid participants. To establish a ground truth, two trained coders analyzed the video frame-by-frame to identify the actual onset, peak (apex), and end (offset) of every facial movement, rating the intensity on a scale of 1 to 7.
Results and Key Insights
The study revealed a significant "Modality Gap": we are much better at seeing our expressions than feeling them. Awareness rates were 57.79% in the real-time condition compared to 75.92% in the video-review condition.
Real-time Awareness
In the real-time condition, awareness was significantly predicted by intensity ($\beta = 0.67, p < 0.001$) but not by the duration of the expression. This suggests that somatosensory feedback must reach a certain "noise floor" of muscle contraction before it enters conscious awareness, regardless of how long the movement lasts.
Video-review Awareness
When watching themselves on video, participants' awareness was predicted by both intensity ($\beta = 0.41, p < 0.001$) and duration ($\beta = 0.03, p < 0.01$). As the duration of an expression increases, the intensity required for a person to "see" it on video drops.
Cross-Modality Prediction
Using Generalized Estimating Equations (GEE), the authors found that video-review awareness was a significant predictor of real-time awareness. This suggests a unified underlying "self-awareness" trait; individuals who are more attuned to their visual appearance also tend to be more sensitive to their internal muscle sensations.
Discussion
These findings highlight that visual feedback is a more advantageous source of information for self-monitoring than internal muscle sensations. While intensity is the primary driver for real-time awareness, visual detection is more complex, integrating both intensity and temporal duration.
Future research should consider broader demographics, as older adults may process facial emotions differently. Additionally, exploring individual differences in expressivity could reveal whether those with more active "poker faces" are more or less in tune with their internal sensations. Understanding these thresholds provides a foundation for improving social-emotional regulation and interpersonal communication.
Summary updated