Yielding transition of a two dimensional glass former under athermal cyclic shear deformation

Himangsu Bhaumik, Giuseppe Foffi, Srikanth SastryThe Journal of Chemical Physics 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We study numerically the yielding transition of a two dimensional model glass subjected to athermal quasi-static cyclic shear deformation, with the aim of investigating the effect on the yielding behavior of the degree of annealing, which in turn depends on the preparation protocol. We find two distinct regimes of annealing separated by a threshold energy. Poorly annealed glasses progressively evolve toward the threshold energy as the strain amplitude is increased toward the yielding value. Well annealed glasses with initial energies below the threshold energy exhibit stable behavior, with a negligible change in energy with increasing strain amplitude, until they yield. Discontinuities in energy and stress at yielding increase with the degree of annealing, consistent with recent results found in three dimensions. We observe a significant structural change with strain amplitude that closely mirrors the changes in energy and stresses. We investigate groups of particles that are involved in plastic rearrangements. We analyze the distributions of avalanche sizes, of clusters of connected rearranging particles, and related quantities, employing finite size scaling analysis. We verify previously investigated relations between exponents characterizing these distributions.

Introduction

Amorphous solids—such as window glass, metallic alloys, and foams—lack the long-range periodic structure of crystals. When subjected to external stress, their failure mechanism, known as the yielding transition, involves complex, collective rearrangements of particles called avalanches. A fundamental question in condensed matter physics is how the "degree of annealing" (the cooling rate or preparation history) influences the nature of this transition. While 3D studies have observed a shift from ductile to brittle yielding as annealing improves, this research investigates if these principles hold in 2D and seeks to define the statistical laws governing the clusters of particles that move during failure.

Methods

The researchers conducted Athermal Quasi-Static (AQS) cyclic shear simulations on a 2D binary Lennard-Jones mixture. By ignoring thermal fluctuations and deforming the material in infinitesimal increments, they focused purely on the system's energy landscape. The study compared four types of glass preparation: two "poorly annealed" (quenched from high temperatures) and two "well-annealed" (prepared via specialized mechanical protocols). Finite Size Scaling (FSS) was applied to systems ranging from 1,000 to 22,500 particles to extract universal statistical exponents and ensure results were not size-dependent.

Key Insights and Results

The Threshold Energy and Yielding Behavior

The study identified a critical threshold energy that dictates the system's response to cyclic shear. Poorly annealed glasses, starting above this threshold, undergo "mechanical annealing," where cyclic shearing helps them settle into lower energy states. Conversely, well-annealed glasses starting below this threshold remain stable until they reach the yield point.

Figure 2: Evolution of potential energy (a, d), maximum shear stress (b, e), and diffusion coefficient (c, f) as a function of strain amplitude. Panels (a-c) compare different annealing protocols, while (d-f) show system size scaling for the HTL protocol. The yielding transition occurs at a strain amplitude of approximately 0.06.

Yielding in poorly annealed glasses is continuous and gradual (ductile), whereas well-annealed glasses exhibit sharp discontinuities in energy and stress, mimicking brittle fracture. The transition occurs at a strain amplitude of approximately $\gamma_y = 0.06$.

Structural Mirroring

A significant finding is that macroscopic changes in energy and stress are closely mirrored by microscopic structural changes. This was measured using bond-orientational order parameters ($ψ_n$), which track the local symmetry of particle arrangements.

Figure 5: Bond-orientational order parameters for small (S) and large (L) particles as a function of strain amplitude. The structural changes closely follow the trends observed in macroscopic energy and stress, indicating a strong link between local order and stability.

Avalanche and Cluster Statistics

An "avalanche" (the total number of particles moving during a stress drop) is composed of several spatially disconnected clusters. The authors determined universal exponents for these distributions:

  • Avalanche size distribution ($S$): $P(S) \sim S^{-1.1}$
  • Cluster size distribution ($s$): $P(s) \sim s^{-1.66}$
  • Clusters per avalanche ($n_{cl}$): $P(n_{cl}) \sim n_{cl}^{-1.18}$

Above the yield point, deformation localizes into "shear bands"—regions of high mobility and reduced structural order that span the entire system. In this regime, the mean cluster size scales with system size as $\langle s \rangle \sim N^{1/3}$, consistent with 3D observations.

Conclusion

This work demonstrates that the brittleness of 2D glasses is highly dependent on preparation history, mirroring 3D behavior. The identification of a threshold energy and universal scaling laws for particle clusters provides a robust framework for understanding the microscopic mechanisms of failure in amorphous materials. Future research may extend these cluster-based analyses to other amorphous solids like silica to test the universality of these scaling relations.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study numerically the yielding transition of a two dimensional model glass subjected to athermal quasi-static cyclic shear deformation, with the aim of investigating the effect on the yielding behavior of the degree of annealing, which in turn depends on the preparation protocol. We find two distinct regimes of annealing separated by a threshold energy. Poorly annealed glasses progressively evolve toward the threshold energy as the strain amplitude is increased toward the yielding value. Well annealed glasses with initial energies below the threshold energy exhibit stable behavior, with a negligible change in energy with increasing strain amplitude, until they yield. Discontinuities in energy and stress at yielding increase with the degree of annealing, consistent with recent results found in three dimensions. We observe a significant structural change with strain amplitude that closely mirrors the changes in energy and stresses. We investigate groups of particles that are involved in plastic rearrangements. We analyze the distributions of avalanche sizes, of clusters of connected rearranging particles, and related quantities, employing finite size scaling analysis. We verify previously investigated relations between exponents characterizing these distributions.
BibTeX
@article{bhaumik2022yielding,
  author = {Himangsu Bhaumik and Giuseppe Foffi and Srikanth Sastry},
  title = {{Yielding transition of a two dimensional glass former under athermal cyclic shear deformation}},
  journal = {The Journal of Chemical Physics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1063/5.0085064},
}
Figure