Xsense: a miniaturised multi-sensor platform for explosives detection

Michael Schmidt, Natalie Kostesha, Filippo Bosco, Jesper Kenneth Olsen, Carsten Johnsen, Kent A. Nielsen, Jan O. Jeppesen, Tommy Sonne Alstrøm, Jan Larsen, Thomas Thundat, Mogens Jakobsen, Anja BoisenProceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "Xsense," a miniaturized, multi-sensor platform designed for explosives detection. By integrating four distinct sensing technologies—microcantilevers, microcalorimetry, Surface Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy (SERS), and colorimetric arrays—Xsense aims to achieve high sensitivity, reliability, and low cost, overcoming the limitations of single-principle sensors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Current explosives detection methods often rely on single sensing principles, which can be prone to false alarms or limitations in sensitivity and environmental robustness. For instance, some methods might struggle with specific environmental conditions or have difficulty distinguishing between similar compounds. The need for a reliable, portable, and cost-effective explosives detector for applications like anti-terror efforts, border control, and de-mining is critical. This paper addresses this by proposing a multi-modal sensing approach where different sensor types complement each other, providing redundancy and improving overall detection accuracy.

Methods

The Xsense platform integrates four key sensing technologies, all leveraging micro- and nanotechnologies for miniaturization and cost-effectiveness:

  • Microcantilever-based Sensing: These sensors detect minute changes in surface stress caused by the binding of explosive molecules. The bending of the cantilever is optically read out. The authors employ a novel system using a DVD-ROM pickup head to scan hundreds of cantilevers on a rotating platform, enabling fast and robust measurements.
  • Microcalorimetry: This technique measures the heat generated or absorbed during chemical reactions or physical changes. The Xsense system uses suspended silicon nitride membranes with integrated heating and sensing resistors. Rapid heating can induce deflagration, producing a distinct thermal signature for explosives.
  • Surface Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy (SERS): SERS amplifies Raman signals from molecules adsorbed onto nanostructured surfaces. The Xsense platform utilizes silicon nanopillars coated with silver or gold to create highly Raman-active surfaces, significantly enhancing the detection of trace explosives.
  • Colorimetric Arrays: This method uses an array of chemo-selective compounds that change color upon exposure to specific analytes. The color change creates a unique "fingerprint" for different explosives, allowing for identification. This technique is known for its sensitivity, speed, and low cost.

A crucial aspect of the Xsense project is the integration of these sensors and the development of advanced data processing techniques, including pre-processing, data fusion, and data presentation, to combine the information from all sensors for robust detection and quantification.

Datasets

Not explicitly detailed in the paper. The authors mention using "sensor data sets assisted by reference measurements of explosive expressions" for training and developing their data fusion strategies. They also refer to previous work on colorimetric data and Quartz Crystal Microbalance (QCM) data, suggesting these might serve as analogous datasets or benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy of Multiple Sensing Principles: The core idea is that no single sensor is perfect. Combining complementary sensing principles (mechanical, thermal, spectroscopic, and chemical) provides redundancy and significantly improves reliability and reduces false alarms.
  • MEMS for Cost-Effective Miniaturization: The use of microfabrication techniques (MEMS) is key to achieving small device size, low fabrication costs, and the integration of multiple sensors into a single portable unit.
  • Novel Readout for Microcantilevers: The adaptation of a DVD-ROM pickup head for scanning microcantilever arrays offers a cost-effective and robust optical readout mechanism.
  • Enhanced SERS Substrates: The development of nanostructured silicon nanopillars coated with silver/gold provides a significant Raman signal enhancement, enabling more sensitive detection.
  • Data Fusion is Critical: The success of the multi-sensor platform hinges on sophisticated data processing and fusion algorithms to intelligently combine the diverse signals into a coherent and reliable detection output.

Key Results

  • The Xsense project aims to detect concentrations of TNT and other explosives at sub-parts-per-billion (ppb) levels.
  • Proof of concept has been confirmed for all four sensor technologies.
  • The SERS substrate developed shows a Raman signal enhancement two orders of magnitude larger than commercial substrates.
  • Colorimetric signatures for TNT, RDX, and PETN were obtained and were easily distinguishable. As little as 12ng of explosives can produce a distinguishable calorimetric signature.
  • The integrated system is intended to provide explosives detection capabilities comparable to trained dog teams, but in a portable, automated device.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Unspecific Binding: A challenge for microcantilever sensors is finding selective coating materials to bind explosives and minimize unspecific binding.
  • Environmental Conditions: While the multi-sensor approach aims to improve robustness, the paper acknowledges the need to account for various environmental conditions (humidity, temperature) in data processing.
  • Integration Complexity: Integrating four distinct sensor technologies and their associated electronics into a single, compact, and user-friendly device presents significant engineering challenges.
  • Future Work: The ongoing effort is focused on optimizing sensitivity, integrating all sensors into one device, and developing advanced data processing and fusion algorithms. The ultimate goal is a reliable, sensitive, portable, and low-cost explosives detector for widespread application.

Summary updated

Abstract

Realizing that no one sensing principle is perfect we set out to combine four fundamentally different sensing principles into one device. The reasoning is that each sensor will complement the others and provide redundancy under various environmental conditions. As each sensor can be fabricated using microfabrication the inherent advantages associated with MEMS technologies such as low fabrication costs and small device size allows us to integrate the four sensors into one portable device at a low cost.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{schmidt2011xsense,
  author = {Michael Schmidt and Natalie Kostesha and Filippo Bosco and Jesper Kenneth Olsen and Carsten Johnsen and Kent A. Nielsen and Jan O. Jeppesen and Tommy Sonne Alstrøm and Jan Larsen and Thomas Thundat and Mogens Jakobsen and Anja Boisen},
  title = {{Xsense: a miniaturised multi-sensor platform for explosives detection}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1117/12.884050},
}
Figure