Worldwide genetic variation of the IGHV and TRBV immune receptor gene families in humans

Shishi Luo, Jane A. Yu, Heng Li, Yun S. SongbioRxiv 2017 · DOI

Abstract

The immunoglobulin heavy variable (IGHV) and T cell beta variable (TRBV) loci are essential for immune diversity but present significant genomic complexity. This study quantifies copy number and single nucleotide variation across a globally diverse sample of 109 (IGHV) and 286 (TRBV) individuals. We demonstrate that while IGHV is characterized by frequent gene duplication and deletion, TRBV exhibits greater structural stability but higher single nucleotide variation. These findings reveal divergent evolutionary paths for these functionally similar loci and highlight a significant gap in current immunogenetic databases.

Introduction

The human adaptive immune system relies on the ability of B and T cells to recognize a nearly infinite array of pathogens. This recognition is mediated by receptors encoded within the Immunoglobulin Heavy Variable (IGHV) and T Cell Beta Variable (TRBV) loci. Despite their critical role, these regions remain some of the most challenging segments of the human genome to characterize. Their repetitive nature, high similarity between gene segments (paralogs), and significant variation in copy number between individuals have historically made them the "dark matter" of immunogenetics.

Methodological Innovations: Navigating the "Dark Matter"

Standard genomic pipelines often struggle with the IGHV and TRBV loci, as short-read sequencing data frequently misaligns to the highly similar paralogous genes. To overcome these technical hurdles, the researchers developed a specialized bioinformatic pipeline applied to the Simons Genome Diversity Project (SGDP) dataset, which features whole-genome sequencing of individuals from 142 globally diverse populations.

Instead of relying solely on the standard human reference genome (GRCh37), the team utilized minimap to capture reads corresponding to functional alleles not present in the reference. They employed the SPAdes assembler to construct individual "contigs" for each gene segment, allowing for more accurate copy number estimation based on coverage depth. To ensure the integrity of single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) calling, the analysis was restricted to "two-copy" segments—genes appearing exactly twice in most individuals—to avoid the confounding effects of multi-copy gene families. Finally, HapCUT2 was used for phasing, enabling a high-resolution view of individual haplotypes.

Divergent Evolutionary Strategies: Structural vs. Sequence Diversity

The study’s most significant finding is the stark contrast in how these two loci have evolved. While IGHV and TRBV share a common evolutionary ancestor and perform similar functions, they utilize different mechanisms to generate diversity.

The IGHV Locus: Structural Instability The IGHV locus is characterized by extreme structural variation. It evolves primarily through frequent gene duplication and deletion events. The researchers estimated approximately 200 different IGHV copy number haplotypes within their sample. Quantitatively, if two individuals are selected at random, there is a 98% probability that they will possess a different set of IGHV genes present or absent in their genome.

The TRBV Locus: Sequence Diversification In contrast, the TRBV locus is structurally stable but exhibits a higher propensity for point mutations. The probability of two individuals having different TRBV gene sets is only 11%. However, TRBV segments showed a higher or equal mutation rate compared to IGHV, averaging 2.1 SNPs per segment versus 1.8 for IGHV. This suggests that while TRBV maintains its structural architecture, it diversifies through rapid nucleotide substitution.

Global Diversity and the "Missing" Alleles

By analyzing a globally diverse cohort, the study provides a much-needed perspective on immunogenetic variation beyond European populations. A striking 45% of the alleles identified in this study were "novel," meaning they were absent from the official IMGT database. This underscores a massive gap in current knowledge.

Consistent with broader genomic patterns, African populations exhibited the highest levels of unique (private) alleles. For instance, all five private IGHV variants identified were found exclusively in African samples. While most copy number variations appear to be ancient and globally distributed, some geographic specificities were noted, such as a specific three-gene deletion in the TRBV locus found in 50% of Native American samples but only 5% of the global population.

Conclusion and Clinical Implications

This research provides a comprehensive reference for the computational immunology community. Understanding the "normal" range of genetic variation in IGHV and TRBV is essential for interpreting how individual genetic backgrounds influence responses to vaccines, susceptibility to infections, and the development of autoimmune diseases.

While the study represents a major advancement, the authors note that 100bp short reads still face limitations in distinguishing between nearly identical gene segments. Future work utilizing long-read sequencing technologies will be necessary to fully resolve the most complex, multi-copy regions of these critical immune loci.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The immunoglobulin heavy variable (IGHV) and T cell beta variable (TRBV) loci are among the most complex and variable regions in the human genome. Generated through a process of gene duplication/deletion and diversification, these loci can vary extensively between individuals in copy number and contain genes that are highly similar, making their analysis technically challenging. Here, we present a comprehensive study of the functional gene segments in the IGHV and TRBV loci, quantifying their copy number and single nucleotide variation in a globally diverse sample of 109 (IGHV) and 286 (TRBV) humans from over a hundred populations. We find that the IGHV and TRBV gene families exhibit starkly different patterns of variation. In particular, with hundreds of copy number haplotypes (instances that have differences in the number of functional gene segments), the IGHV locus has undergone more frequent gene duplication/deletion compared to the TRBV locus, which has only a few copy number haplotypes. In contrast, the TRBV locus has a greater or at least equal propensity to mutate, as evidenced by greater single nucleotide variation, compared to the IGHV locus. Thus, despite common molecular and functional characteristics, the genes that comprise the IGHV and TRBV loci have evolved in strikingly different ways. As well as providing insight into the different evolutionary paths the IGHV and TRBV loci have taken, our results are also important to the adaptive immune repertoire sequencing community, where the lack of frequencies of common alleles and copy number variants is hampering existing analytical pipelines.
BibTeX
@misc{luo2017worldwide,
  author = {Shishi Luo and Jane A. Yu and Heng Li and Yun S. Song},
  title = {{Worldwide genetic variation of the IGHV and TRBV immune receptor gene families in humans}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1101/155440},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure