Working Upstream in Advance Care Planning in Pandemic Palliative Care

Milana Zaurova, Mona Krouss, Sigal Israilov, Louis H. Hart, Hillary S. Jalon, Georgia Conley, Khoi Luong, Eric Wei, Robert Smeltz, Michael Frankenthaler, Jeffrey Nichols, Susan E. Cohen, Natasha Suleman, Marina Ivanyuk, Pavel Shulman, Osbely Tala, L.a. Parker, Tita Castor, Nicole Pearlstein, Elizabeth Kavanagh, Hyung J. ChoHealth 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

The COVID-19 pandemic exposed critical gaps in advance care planning (ACP) and palliative care delivery, particularly in safety-net healthcare systems. This paper details how New York City Health + Hospitals (NYC H+H) rapidly adapted its palliative care services by optimizing its existing workforce, recruiting external volunteers, and significantly expanding telehealth capacity to meet unprecedented demand.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic placed immense strain on healthcare systems, especially those serving vulnerable populations. The authors highlight the critical need for proactive palliative care and advance care planning (ACP) to ensure patients' wishes are honored, particularly for those with serious illnesses who are most at risk. Traditional palliative care models, often reliant on in-person consultations and limited by existing workforce shortages, were overwhelmed by the surge in critically ill patients. The pandemic also introduced new challenges, such as visitor restrictions, which further complicated communication between patients, families, and healthcare teams. The paper addresses the problem of how a large, safety-net healthcare system can rapidly scale and adapt its palliative care services to meet an overwhelming and evolving crisis.

Methods

The authors describe a multi-pronged approach to address the surge in palliative care needs:

  • Optimizing Existing Workforce: This involved re-evaluating and re-deploying existing palliative care teams to high-acuity areas, increasing "curbside" consultations with primary teams, and coaching these teams to handle difficult conversations independently. The goal was to ensure all palliative care consultations were addressed despite staff illness and redeployments.
  • Recruiting External Volunteers: NYC H+H leveraged both city/state-wide calls for volunteers and a national social media outreach for "telepalliative medicine volunteers" (TPMV). This initiative aimed to augment staffing and provide remote consultations, rapidly credentialing and onboarding volunteers to support the system.
  • Increasing Telehealth Capacity: Recognizing the limitations of in-person contact due to infection control measures, the system prioritized the use of voice and video communication. This included efforts to standardize telehealth even within inpatient settings and to secure devices like iPads for patient-provider communication. The paper also discusses the challenges of implementing telehealth in unscheduled inpatient settings and the need for dedicated support staff.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the operational response and lessons learned rather than a data-driven evaluation of specific algorithms or models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Palliative Care is Scalable and Essential in Crises: The pandemic demonstrated that palliative care services, even in resource-limited safety-net settings, can be scaled and are vital for managing a public health emergency.
  • The Power of Proactive ACP: The crisis underscored the importance of "working upstream" in ACP, initiating conversations early with high-risk patients to ensure goal-concordant care, especially in settings like nursing homes where COVID-19 had a devastating impact.
  • Telehealth as a Force Multiplier: Expanding telehealth capacity, particularly for remote consultations, proved crucial in extending the reach of palliative care services and overcoming geographical and logistical barriers.
  • Volunteer Enthusiasm is Invaluable: External volunteers, both in-person and remote, provided critical support, bringing energy, compassion, and much-needed capacity to overwhelmed teams.
  • System-Wide Collaboration is Key: The success of the response relied heavily on collaboration across different departments, facilities, and even external organizations.

Key Results

  • Volunteer Recruitment Success: A national outreach for telepalliative medicine volunteers (TPMV) successfully enlisted 413 volunteers, leading to 109 TPMV consultations within the first 14 days of the program.
  • Telehealth Device Deployment: NYC H+H secured 1,300 iPad tablets for the system, prioritizing palliative care teams, to enhance telehealth capabilities.
  • Operational Adaptations: The system increased "curbside" consultations, coached primary teams, and stationed clinicians in high-acuity areas to proactively meet rising palliative care needs.
  • Qualitative Feedback: Volunteers received overwhelmingly positive feedback for their service, and site leads praised their contributions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations of Remote Volunteers: While effective, remote volunteers faced challenges in accessing real-time patient information due to documentation delays, necessitating a "point-person on the ground" for clarification. Some facilities also declined remote volunteers due to logistical concerns and a lack of existing telehealth infrastructure.
  • Inpatient Telehealth Challenges: Implementing telehealth in inpatient settings presented unique difficulties, including unscheduled encounters, patient movement for procedures, and the need for additional staffing and coordination for equipment setup and disinfection.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest continuing to invest in palliative care, revisiting needs assessments to account for the pandemic's impact, leveraging electronic health records for automatic consultation triggers, and assisting other health systems in developing their pandemic palliative care responses. They also emphasize the need to incorporate lessons learned to optimize goal-concordant care conversations and advance care planning.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{zaurova2020working,
  author = {Milana Zaurova and Mona Krouss and Sigal Israilov and Louis H. Hart and Hillary S. Jalon and Georgia Conley and Khoi Luong and Eric Wei and Robert Smeltz and Michael Frankenthaler and Jeffrey Nichols and Susan E. Cohen and Natasha Suleman and Marina Ivanyuk and Pavel Shulman and Osbely Tala and L.A. Parker and Tita Castor and Nicole Pearlstein and Elizabeth Kavanagh and Hyung J. Cho},
  title = {{Working Upstream in Advance Care Planning in Pandemic Palliative Care}},
  booktitle = {Health},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1089/hs.2020.0096},
}
Figure