Woody Vegetation Die off and Regeneration in Response to Rainfall Variability in the West African Sahel

Martin Brandt, G. Gray Tappan, Abdoul Aziz Diouf, Gora Beye, Cheikh Mbow, Rasmus FensholtRemote 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that while the West African Sahel is experiencing "woody greening" driven by favorable rainfall, this trend is not linear and is highly susceptible to drought. The research highlights that the resilience of this ecosystem relies on a dynamic interplay of rainfall variability, species composition, and low human pressure, rather than a simple increase or decrease in vegetation cover.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Sahel region has long been a focus of ecological research, often characterized by narratives of desertification and degradation, particularly after the severe droughts of the 1980s. However, recent observations suggest a "greening" trend, with an increase in woody vegetation. This apparent contradiction raises critical questions: Is this greening a sign of true recovery and resilience, or is it a temporary phenomenon masking underlying vulnerabilities? Furthermore, what are the specific drivers and mechanisms behind these observed changes in woody vegetation, and how do they relate to climate, soil, and human activities? This paper aims to disentangle these complexities by investigating the dynamics of woody plant growth and mortality in Senegal, moving beyond simplified "greening" or "degradation" labels to understand the nuanced responses to rainfall variability.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining Earth Observation (EO) data with in situ measurements. A key methodological innovation was the use of a phenology-based approach to estimate woody cover. This method leverages the fact that herbaceous vegetation in the Sahel is largely dormant during the dry season (October to June), allowing satellite-derived Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) during this period to serve as a proxy for woody vegetation green foliage density.

To account for inter-annual rainfall variations that can influence foliage density, the study used wet season peak NDVI as a proxy for rainfall and growing conditions. This allowed them to correct the dry season NDVI, effectively isolating changes in woody populations from rainfall-induced foliage fluctuations. A Theil-Sen trend analysis was then applied to estimate woody cover trends over time.

High-resolution satellite imagery (50 cm resolution) was used for visual comparison and to document observed dynamics at specific field sites. Rainfall data was sourced from NOAA's Climate Prediction Center. In situ data collection involved detailed field surveys of woody species composition, age, and health at selected sites, as well as repeat photography to document changes over time.

Datasets

  • MODIS MCD43A4 Collection 5: BRDF-corrected reflectance product at 500 m spatial resolution, used for estimating woody cover.
  • NOAA Climate Prediction Center Rainfall Products (RFE v2.0 and ARC2): Used for rainfall data analysis.
  • High-Resolution Satellite Imagery (Geoeye 1, Quickbird 2, Worldview 2): Provided at 50 cm resolution for detailed visual analysis of field sites.
  • In situ Woody Cover Measurements: Data collected from 77 sites across Senegal, Mali, and Niger between 2000 and 2015, including canopy cover measurements and species composition.
  • In situ Woody Cover Measurements (5 CSE Sites): Multi-year data without gaps for specific sites in Senegal, used for model calibration and monitoring.
  • Repeat Photography: Images from 1983, 1994, and 2013-2015 to visually document landscape changes.
  • MODIS Fire Product MCD45A1: Used to mask out areas affected by bushfires.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Resilience is dynamic, not static: The Sahelian system exhibits resilience at decadal scales through increases in woody cover and regeneration after droughts, but this is not a linear, guaranteed recovery.
  • Species composition matters for drought resistance: The dominance of drought-prone species like Guiera senegalensis, while contributing to greening during wet periods, poses a significant risk of substantial woody cover loss during droughts.
  • Rainfall is the primary driver, but not the sole one: While mean annual rainfall strongly correlates with woody cover and its trends, the lack of a clear spatial relationship between rainfall trends and woody cover trends highlights the influence of other factors.
  • Human pressure is a critical moderator: Areas with low human population density and protected status (sylvo-pastoral reserves) show the most significant increases in woody cover, underscoring the importance of conservation and sustainable land management.
  • Simplified labels are insufficient: The observed spatial and temporal variations in woody vegetation dynamics challenge simplistic labels of "greening" or "degradation," revealing a more complex and fluctuating ecological state.

Key Results

  • Woody cover increase: Between 2000 and 2013, favorable conditions (forest reserves, low human population density, sufficient rainfall) led to a rapid growth of woody cover, with an average increase of 4%.
  • Drought-induced die-off: The study documented a significant die-off of Guiera senegalensis in 2014-2015 following a period of low rainfall, demonstrating the vulnerability of certain species.
  • Species dominance: Guiera senegalensis was found to be a major driver of greening in many areas, but also a key contributor to die-off during dry periods. Balanites aegyptiaca and Combretum glutinosum also showed significant presence and varying responses to drought.
  • Rainfall correlation: Woody cover and its trends were strongly correlated with mean annual rainfall. However, correlations between rainfall trends and woody cover trends were weak over the study period.
  • Lagged rainfall effects: Woody cover showed a stronger correlation with rainfall when considering lagged periods, with the highest correlation observed at a 2-year lag and a strong correlation after 5 years of integrated rainfall, suggesting a delayed response and the need for sustained favorable conditions.
  • Soil type influence: Sandy soils showed a medium to long-term response to rainfall, while shallow soils exhibited a more short-term response and a weaker relation with long-term rainfall sums, sometimes even showing a negative correlation with high rainfall due to runoff.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Proxy for woody cover: The study acknowledges that dry season green foliage density is used as a proxy for woody cover, which is an indirect measurement. Future work could benefit from new data sources (e.g., very high-resolution satellite images, passive microwave data) that allow for more direct assessment of tree mortality and growth.
  • Complexity of interactions: While the study identifies key drivers, the complex interplay of climate, soil, morphology, and human management requires further detailed analysis to fully explain the observed patterns.
  • Species diversity and resilience: The paper notes that low woody plant diversity can negatively impact regional resilience. Further research is needed to explore this relationship more deeply in the Sahelian context.
  • CO2 fertilization and other drivers: The study mentions the potential role of CO2 fertilization in woody encroachment, as observed in other African savannas, and suggests that its impact, along with livestock grazing and fire, needs further analysis in Sahelian rangelands.
  • Operational monitoring: The authors emphasize the need for an applicable method for assessing woody encroachment and tree mortality for operational monitoring and to enhance understanding of climate-vegetation interactions and woody plant vulnerability.

Summary updated

Abstract

The greening in the Senegalese Sahel has been linked to an increase in net primary productivity, with significant long-term trends being closely related to the woody strata. This study investigates woody plant growth and mortality within greening areas in the pastoral areas of Senegal, and how these dynamics are linked to species diversity, climate, soil and human management. We analyse woody cover dynamics by means of multi-temporal and multi-scale Earth Observation, satellite based rainfall and in situ data sets covering the period 1994 to 2015. We find that favourable conditions (forest reserves, low human population density, sufficient rainfall) led to a rapid growth of Combretaceae and Balanites aegyptiaca between 2000 and 2013 with an average increase of 4% woody cover. However, the increasing dominance and low drought resistance of drought prone species bears the risk of substantial woody cover losses following drought years. This was observed in 2014–2015, with a die off of Guiera senegalensis in most places of the study area. We show that woody cover and woody cover trends are closely related to mean annual rainfall, but no clear relationship with rainfall trends was found over the entire study period. The observed spatial and temporal variation contrasts with the simplified labels of “greening” or “degradation”. While in principal a low woody plant diversity negatively impacts regional resilience, the Sahelian system is showing signs of resilience at decadal time scales through widespread increases in woody cover and high regeneration rates after periodic droughts. We have reaffirmed that the woody cover in Sahel responds to its inherent climatic variability and does not follow a linear trend.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{brandt2017woody,
  author = {Martin Brandt and G. Gray Tappan and Abdoul Aziz Diouf and Gora Beye and Cheikh Mbow and Rasmus Fensholt},
  title = {{Woody Vegetation Die off and Regeneration in Response to Rainfall Variability in the West African Sahel}},
  booktitle = {Remote},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/rs9010039},
}
Figure