Women in science: bridging gaps in basic sciences

Bhavita Kumari, Narjis Fatima Hussain, Stephen Kennedy, Aris T. Papageorghiou, Jai K Das, Zulfiqar A BhuttaTrends 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper examines the challenges and strategies for increasing female representation in basic sciences research, particularly in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). It highlights the "Supporting Women in Science" (SWIS) program's efforts to build capacity, provide mentorship, and overcome systemic barriers, ultimately aiming to foster gender equity in scientific research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the persistent gender disparities in academia, especially within basic sciences in LMICs. Globally, women are underrepresented as researchers, with even lower proportions in South and West Asia. This inequality not only hinders progress towards Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) related to quality education and gender equality but also means that valuable talent and perspectives are underutilized. Specific challenges include lower publication rates in high-impact journals, fewer international collaborations, disparities in grant funding, and institutional biases in hiring and promotion. Basic sciences, in particular, are often perceived as male-dominated, with fewer role models and targeted interventions, exacerbating these inequities.

Methods

The paper focuses on the "Supporting Women in Science" (SWIS) program, which employs a multi-phase approach to address these issues.

  • Phase I: Involves nomination of early-to-mid-career female researchers for a capacity-strengthening initiative, including self-paced online coursework.
  • Phase II: A summative assessment serves as a shortlisting criterion for the next phase.
  • Phase III: Selected fellows receive research grants under remote mentorship from prominent faculty at partner institutions (Aga Khan University, University of Oxford, and others).

The program also incorporates discipline-specific strategies and aims to build a global network for collaboration and knowledge exchange. Comparative programs like ARISE are mentioned as reinforcing the value of mentorship and leadership development. The SWIS program is also exploring frameworks like the Athena SWAN Charter and UNESCO's SAGA to support institutional reforms.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the SWIS program's structure and outcomes rather than specific datasets used for training or evaluation in a machine learning context.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Leaky Pipeline" is pronounced in basic sciences: The proportion of participants from basic sciences significantly drops from the application cycle through to Phase III fellowship, with a particularly high dropout rate (78%) for basic science participants in Phase I. This suggests unique challenges for women in these disciplines.
  • Mentorship and capacity-building are critical but challenging: While the SWIS program aims to provide these, matching mentors to fellows with laboratory-based projects proved difficult, with a limited number of mentors having basic science backgrounds.
  • Systemic barriers are multifaceted: Beyond individual challenges, the paper highlights administrative and regulatory hurdles, lack of transparent institutional support, and the need for costly equipment as significant obstacles for research projects.
  • Discipline-specific strategies are essential: The program recognizes the need to diversify curricula to better accommodate scientists from non-clinical disciplines and is adapting by introducing virtual mentorship and discipline-specific online courses.
  • Global frameworks need localized solutions: The SWIS program aims to combine international best practices (like Athena SWAN) with tailored approaches for LMICs to create a scalable and equitable model.

Key Results

  • Out of 1329 applications for the SWIS program, 22.4% (297) had a basic science degree.
  • Of the participants enrolled in Phase I, 150 had a basic science background.
  • The dropout rate from Phase I was nearly 60% overall, but higher for basic science participants at 78%.
  • Only 7 (8%) of the 84 participants selected for Phase III fellowships had a basic science degree.
  • Among the 84 Phase III fellows, 13 (15.5%) are conducting exclusively laboratory-based projects.
  • The research interests of fellows are diverse, with Maternal, Child & Adolescent Health (27) being the largest category, followed by NCDs, Cancer & Geriatrics (13), and Nutrition (10).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Curriculum Inclusivity: The paper acknowledges that the initial curriculum, heavily focused on epidemiology and biostatistics, was challenging for basic science participants. Future work needs to diversify this to be more inclusive.
  • Mentor Matching: The difficulty in finding mentors with basic science backgrounds for laboratory-based projects is a significant limitation. Future efforts should focus on expanding the pool of qualified mentors in these areas.
  • Administrative and Regulatory Hurdles: Navigating complex administrative processes and securing funding for laboratory equipment remain significant challenges that require institutional-level engagement and strategic partnerships.
  • Sustainability: While SWIS is fostering a network, further steps are needed for long-term sustainability, including curriculum restructuring, diversified funding, and collaboration with regional science bodies. Implementing robust monitoring and evaluation mechanisms is crucial for data-driven refinement and impact.
  • Future Directions: The SWIS program plans to adopt frameworks like Athena SWAN and UNESCO's SAGA to support institutional reforms and reduce gender gaps in STEM. They also aim to build sustainability through peer learning, webinars, and annual conferences.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{kumari2025women,
  author = {Bhavita Kumari and Narjis Fatima Hussain and Stephen Kennedy and Aris T. Papageorghiou and Jai K Das and Zulfiqar A Bhutta},
  title = {{Women in science: bridging gaps in basic sciences}},
  booktitle = {Trends},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1016/j.molmed.2025.07.005},
}
Figure