Wireless and battery-operatable IoT platform for cost-effective detection of fouling in industrial equipment

Julius Korsimaa, Martin Weber, Petteri Salminen, Joonas Mustonen, Denys Iablonskyi, Edward Hæggström, Arto Klami, Ari SalmiScientific 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a wireless, battery-powered IoT platform that uses "helical" ultrasonic waves to detect buildup (fouling) inside industrial pipes. By analyzing waves that wrap around the pipe's circumference rather than just traveling in a straight line, the system can accurately localize fouling using significantly fewer sensors than traditional wired methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Industrial pipelines are the arteries of modern infrastructure, but they are prone to fouling—the accumulation of unwanted sediments like mineral scales or biological growth. Fouling increases flow resistance and decreases thermal efficiency, leading to massive operational costs and environmental impact.

Monitoring fouling is notoriously difficult. Engineers often rely on indirect indicators like pressure drops, which only signal a problem after it has become severe. Direct monitoring usually requires Ultrasonic Guided Waves (UGWs), but traditional UGW systems are bulky, expensive, and require "collars" of many sensors connected by a web of cables. This makes large-scale, permanent installation economically and logistically unfeasible.

Methods

The authors propose a decentralized, wireless approach:

  • The IoT Node: Each sensor unit is built around an ESP32 microcontroller. It includes a custom "Class D" amplifier to generate ultrasonic pulses and a high-gain receiver to capture the faint returning signals (often in the microvolt range).
  • Wireless Synchronization: To measure the "time-of-flight" of a sound wave accurately, the transmitter and receiver must be perfectly synced. The team used Radio Frequency (RF) signals to trigger the sensors wirelessly, achieving a timing jitter of only 2.6 nanoseconds.
  • Helical Path Analysis: This is the "secret sauce." Instead of only looking at the shortest path between two sensors, the system analyzes waves that travel helically around the pipe. Because these waves wrap around the cylinder multiple times, a single pair of sensors can "scan" various sections of the pipe's circumference.
  • A0 Mode Selection: The researchers specifically tuned the system to use the "A0" Lamb wave mode, which is highly sensitive to changes in wall thickness and energy leakage caused by internal fouling.

Datasets

The study did not use a public dataset; instead, the researchers generated experimental data using a controlled laboratory setup:

  • Hardware: A 2.54-meter-long steel pipe (150 mm diameter, 2 mm wall thickness).
  • Fouling Proxy: To simulate fouling in a repeatable way, they used 100g adhesive pads spread over an 8 cm circular area.
  • Measurements: They recorded signal envelopes from four sensors (T1, T2, R1, R2) across "clean" and "fouled" states, creating a 2D matrix of signal changes to validate their localization theory.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • More Data from Fewer Sensors: By treating helical wrap-around signals as useful data rather than noise, the researchers effectively increased the "coverage" of each sensor pair. This allows for a "scattered" network where sensors can be placed arbitrarily based on where there is space on the pipe.
  • Energy Leakage as a Binary Indicator: The primary detection mechanism is attenuation. When a wave hits a fouled area, energy leaks out of the pipe wall and into the fouling layer. This causes a dramatic drop in the amplitude of specific "wave packets" in the received signal.
  • Power Efficiency: By operating with a 2% uptime (periodically waking up to check the pipe), a single node can run for a month on a standard 39 Wh battery, making it viable for remote industrial environments.

Key Results

  • High Stability: On a clean pipe, the system showed less than 2% variation in signal amplitude over time, proving that the wireless triggering and acoustic coupling were robust.
  • Clear Detection: When fouling was present on a wave's path, the signal amplitude dropped by approximately 48% to 53%.
  • Successful Localization: By comparing which helical paths were attenuated across different sensor pairs, the system could distinguish between two different fouling locations (Location A vs. Location B) with high confidence. For example, a fouling spot might block the 0th, 3rd, and 4th helical paths between sensors T1 and R1, but leave the paths between T1 and R2 completely untouched.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Fouling Proxies: The study used adhesive pads on the outside of the pipe. While the physics of UGWs allows for this (the pipe wall is thin enough that it behaves like a single waveguide), real-world internal fouling may have different acoustic properties.
  • Ray Approximation: The current analysis treats ultrasonic waves like thin "rays." In reality, the waves have a finite width, and scattering/reflections from the fouling can create complex interference patterns.
  • Scaling Up: The authors suggest that future work will involve using Machine Learning to automate the localization process, moving beyond simple manual "box" checks of wave packets to a system that can reconstruct a full map of fouling density across a complex pipeline network.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a novel internet of things (IoT) sensing platform that uses helical propagation paths of ultrasonic guided waves (UGWs) for structural health monitoring. This wireless sensor network comprises multiple identical sensor units that communicate with a host PC. The units have dedicated hardware to both generate and receive ultrasonic signals, as well as RF signals for use in triggering the sensors. The system was developed for monitoring and sensing pipelines and similar structures in real-time to facilitate interactive sensing. For accurate sensing with a limited number of arbitrarily scattered sensors, we obtain information from all sensor pairs and analyze helical propagation paths in addition to the commonly used shortest paths. UGWs can propagate long distances along the walls of pipelines, and their propagation velocity depends directly on the thickness of the waveguide, and is affected by energy leakage and mass loading. In this paper, we evaluated the network by utilizing it to detect fouling. The network could be adapted for further ultrasonic measurement tasks, e.g., measuring wall thicknesses or monitoring defects with pulse-echo methods.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{korsimaa2024wireless,
  author = {Julius Korsimaa and Martin Weber and Petteri Salminen and Joonas Mustonen and Denys Iablonskyi and Edward Hæggström and Arto Klami and Ari Salmi},
  title = {{Wireless and battery-operatable IoT platform for cost-effective detection of fouling in industrial equipment}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-64675-4},
}
Figure