Wing Deformation of an Airborne Wind Energy System in Crosswind Flight Using High-Fidelity Fluid–Structure Interaction

Niels Pynaert, Thomas Haas, Jolan Wauters, Guillaume Crevecoeur, Joris DegrooteEnergies 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a high-fidelity simulation framework for analyzing the complex fluid-structure interaction (FSI) of airborne wind energy (AWE) systems during crosswind flight. By coupling advanced computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and computational structural mechanics (CSM) models, the study reveals that wing deformation in crosswind flight can lead to more symmetric spanwise loading, a finding with potential implications for improving AWE system efficiency and safety.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Airborne Wind Energy (AWE) systems hold promise for generating electricity from wind at higher altitudes, but scaling them up presents significant challenges. One key challenge is understanding the intricate interplay between the flexible AWE wing and the surrounding airflow, especially during dynamic flight maneuvers like crosswind patterns. This interaction, known as fluid-structure interaction (FSI), becomes more critical as AWE systems grow larger. Current research often simplifies these dynamics, either by assuming steady-state conditions or using lower-fidelity models. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing and applying a high-fidelity FSI simulation approach to accurately capture the unsteady aerodynamic and structural behavior of an AWE wing during crosswind flight, a maneuver crucial for energy generation.

Methods

The core of this research lies in a partitioned and explicit fluid-structure interaction (FSI) approach. This means that separate models for fluid dynamics (CFD) and structural mechanics (CSM) are used and interact with each other.

  • Aerodynamic Model (CFD): A high-fidelity CFD model using the unsteady Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (URANS) equations with a k-w SST turbulence model was employed. To handle the large rigid-body motion of the aircraft during its flight path, a Chimera/overset mesh technique was utilized. This allows for independent meshing of the wing and the surrounding flow domain, with data being interpolated at the overlapping boundaries.
  • Structural Model (CSM): A finite element method (FEM) model, derived from a reference AWE system design, was used to represent the wing's structural behavior. This model accounts for the composite nature of the wing.
  • Mesh Deformation: To accommodate the wing's deformation due to aerodynamic loads, an Arbitrary Lagrangian-Eulerian (ALE) formulation was implemented. This allows the mesh to move with the deforming structure while maintaining its connectivity.
  • Coupling Algorithm: A partitioned and explicit coupling algorithm was used. This means that the CFD and CSM solvers are called sequentially within each time step, with data (loads and deformations) exchanged at the FSI interface.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilizes a reference AWE system design from existing literature ([7, 17]) for its structural and aerodynamic properties, but no new experimental datasets were used for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Wing Deformation Matters in Crosswind Flight: The study demonstrates that wing deformation is not negligible and significantly influences the aerodynamic loads experienced by an AWE wing during crosswind maneuvers.
  • Symmetry Enhancement: A key finding is that wing deformation in crosswind flight leads to a more symmetric spanwise loading. This is a crucial insight, as symmetric loading can contribute to increased efficiency and improved flight stability.
  • FSI vs. CFD: While the FSI model predicted slightly lower lift and drag coefficients compared to rigid-wing CFD simulations (around 1.4% reduction), the primary impact was on the deformation and twist of the wing.
  • Asymmetric Loading and Twist: The crosswind flight path inherently creates asymmetric aerodynamic loading, leading to differences in deformation and twist between the left and right wingtips.
  • Potential for Passive Design: The observed increase in spanwise loading symmetry due to deformation suggests that future AWE wing designs could leverage this phenomenon for passive aerodynamic improvements, enhancing both efficiency and safety.

Key Results

  • Lift Coefficient Reduction: The FSI simulations showed a slight reduction in the lift coefficient (around 1.4%) compared to rigid-wing CFD simulations.
  • Twist Deformation: Negative twist deformation was observed at the wingtips, with values of -0.44° at the left tip and -0.53° at the right tip.
  • Tip Deflection Variation: The tip deflection varied with the flight path, particularly in a logarithmic wind profile, due to changes in lift. However, twist deformation remained relatively stable.
  • No Aeroelastic Instabilities: Despite the dynamic interactions, no aeroelastic instabilities were encountered in the simulations for the studied wing.
  • Computational Cost: Unsteady aerodynamic simulations took approximately 7.55 hours per loop on 392 cores, while FSI simulations were significantly more demanding, taking around 75.6 hours per loop on 52 cores.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Structural Stiffness: The study acknowledges that the observed FSI effects were limited due to the high stiffness of the simulated structure. For more flexible structures, these effects would likely be more pronounced.
  • Rigid-Body Motion in Structural Model: The structural model did not initially include rigid-body motion, meaning inertial and gravitational forces were neglected. While assumed to be small, this is a simplification.
  • Tether Neglect: The effect of the tether and its interaction with the aircraft and ground station were neglected.
  • Future Work: The authors propose extending the framework to include rigid-body motion in the structural model and coupling the FSI model with a body dynamics model. This would enable more physically realistic flight predictions and a more accurate simulation of power production. Further investigation into more flexible structures is also suggested.

Summary updated

Abstract

Airborne wind energy (AWE) is an emerging technology for the conversion of wind energy into electricity. There are many types of AWE systems, and one of them flies crosswind patterns with a tethered aircraft connected to a generator. The objective is to gain a proper understanding of the unsteady interaction of air and this flexible and dynamic system during operation, which is key to developing viable, large AWE systems. In this work, the effect of wing deformation on an AWE system performing a crosswind flight maneuver was assessed using high-fidelity time-varying fluid–structure interaction simulations. This was performed using a partitioned and explicit approach. A computational structural mechanics (CSM) model of the wing structure was coupled with a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) model of the wing aerodynamics. The Chimera/overset technique combined with an arbitrary Lagrangian–Eulerian (ALE) formulation for mesh deformation has been proven to be a robust approach to simulating the motion and deformation of an airborne wind energy system in CFD simulations. The main finding is that wing deformation in crosswind flights increases the symmetry of the spanwise loading. This property could be used in future designs to increase the efficiency of airborne wind energy systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pynaert2023wing,
  author = {Niels Pynaert and Thomas Haas and Jolan Wauters and Guillaume Crevecoeur and Joris Degroote},
  title = {{Wing Deformation of an Airborne Wind Energy System in Crosswind Flight Using High-Fidelity Fluid–Structure Interaction}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/en16020602},
}
Figure