Wind and Solar Intermittency and the Associated Integration Challenges: A Comprehensive Review Including the Status in the Belgian Power System

Siavash Asiaban, Nezmin Kayedpour, Arash E. Samani, Dimitar Bozalakov, Jeroen D. M. De Kooning, Guillaume Crevecoeur, Lieven VandeveldeEnergies 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This comprehensive review examines the challenges of integrating intermittent renewable energy sources (RES), specifically wind and solar, into power systems, with a focus on Belgium. It highlights the need for advanced forecasting and mitigation strategies to ensure grid stability and reliability while transitioning to a low-carbon future.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global push towards decarbonization necessitates a significant increase in renewable energy sources (RES) like wind and solar. However, their inherent intermittency—variable power generation due to fluctuating wind speeds and solar irradiance—poses a major challenge for grid operators. This variability impacts power system stability, reliability, and operational costs by requiring increased reserves, affecting CO2 emissions from conventional plants, and potentially leading to grid losses and curtailment. The paper addresses the need for a thorough understanding of these challenges and the solutions available, particularly within the context of Belgium's ambitious decarbonization goals and its planned nuclear phase-out.

Methods

This paper is a comprehensive review, synthesizing existing research rather than presenting novel experimental or simulation methods. The authors analyze and discuss:

  • Impact Assessment: Reviewing studies that quantify the short-term and long-term impacts of RES intermittency on power system reserves, CO2 emissions, grid losses, curtailment, ancillary services, protection systems, and overall reliability.
  • Forecasting Techniques: Surveying various methods for predicting wind speed and solar irradiance, including physical models, statistical methods, deep learning algorithms, and hybrid approaches.
  • Mitigation and Accommodation Strategies: Examining solutions to manage RES variability, broadly categorized into those not associated with Energy Storage Systems (ESS) (e.g., Supply-Side Management, Demand-Side Management, aggregation) and those that utilize ESS.
  • Energy Storage Systems (ESS) Classification: Categorizing different types of ESS (mechanical, electrochemical, chemical, electromagnetic, thermal) and their characteristics.
  • Belgian Power System Analysis: Evaluating the current status, challenges, and future projections for RES integration in Belgium, including nuclear phase-out plans and energy targets.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a review and synthesizes findings from numerous existing studies, rather than using specific datasets for its own analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Intermittency is a Multifaceted Challenge: It's not just about unpredictable generation; it impacts reserves, operational costs, emissions, grid infrastructure, and even protection systems.
  • Forecasting is Crucial, but Not a Silver Bullet: While advanced forecasting (especially using deep learning) is vital for managing variability, it doesn't eliminate the need for other mitigation strategies.
  • Energy Storage Systems (ESS) are Key Enablers: ESS are presented as a primary solution for smoothing RES output and providing essential grid services, with a wide range of technologies available.
  • Aggregation and Diversification Help: Combining multiple wind or solar farms, or integrating wind and solar, can reduce overall variability due to spatial and temporal complementarity.
  • Belgium's Unique Situation: The country faces a significant challenge with its planned nuclear phase-out by 2025, necessitating rapid and substantial RES integration and replacement capacity.
  • Offshore Wind's Potential: Offshore wind offers higher and more consistent speeds, leading to better performance and reduced fatigue, though at a higher cost.
  • CSP vs. PV Trade-offs: CSP offers thermal storage capabilities, while PV has seen dramatic cost reductions and is more widely deployed globally.

Key Results

  • Quantitative Impacts of Intermittency: The paper summarizes findings from various studies showing how RES penetration affects parameters like system reserve (0.3-1.1% increase per 10% wind penetration), CO2 reduction (actual reduction can be less than theoretical), system losses (e.g., extra transmission costs of 2-3 €/MWh at 20-30% penetration), and curtailment ratios (varying significantly by region and penetration level).
  • Belgian RES Targets: Belgium aims for a 40.4% share of RES in electricity by 2030, with significant growth projected for onshore wind, offshore wind, and solar PV.
  • Nuclear Phase-out Impact: Belgium needs to replace approximately 3.9 GW of nuclear capacity by 2025, highlighting the urgency for RES and other generation sources.
  • RES Resilience: The wind energy sector showed resilience during COVID-19, with only a minor projected decrease in installations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Belgium: While the review covers general challenges, the detailed analysis is specific to the Belgian context.
  • Review Nature: The paper synthesizes existing literature; therefore, its limitations are those of the studies it reviews.
  • Future Work: The authors implicitly suggest the need for continued research into advanced forecasting, optimized ESS deployment, and robust grid integration strategies to meet ambitious decarbonization targets. They also highlight the importance of understanding the interplay between different RES technologies and conventional power sources for a stable and reliable future grid.

Summary updated

Abstract

Renewable Energy Sources (RES) have drawn significant attention in the past years to make the transition towards low carbon emissions. On the one hand, the intermittent nature of RES, resulting in variable power generation, hinders their high-level penetration in the power system. On the other hand, RES can aid not only to supply much more eco-friendly energy but also it allows the power system to enhance its stability by ancillary service provision. This article reviews the challenges related to the most intermittent RES utilised in Belgium, that is, wind energy and solar energy. Additionally, wind speed and solar irradiance variations, which are the cause of wind and solar intermittency, are studied. Then, recent techniques to forecast their changes, and approaches to accommodate or mitigate their impacts on the power system, are discussed. Finally, the latest statistics and future situation of RES in the Belgian power system are evaluated.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{asiaban2021wind,
  author = {Siavash Asiaban and Nezmin Kayedpour and Arash E. Samani and Dimitar Bozalakov and Jeroen D. M. De Kooning and Guillaume Crevecoeur and Lieven Vandevelde},
  title = {{Wind and Solar Intermittency and the Associated Integration Challenges: A Comprehensive Review Including the Status in the Belgian Power System}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/en14092630},
}
Figure