Will the next pandemic be caused by coronavirus again? An interview with George Fu Gao

Weijie ZhaoNational 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Professor George Fu Gao, a leading immunologist, discusses the inevitability of future pandemics, highlighting respiratory viruses like influenza and coronaviruses as the most probable culprits. He emphasizes the critical need for global collaboration, data sharing, and preparedness, while acknowledging that lessons learned from COVID-19, particularly in data management, may not be fully integrated into future responses.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

This paper addresses the persistent question of when and from what source the next pandemic might emerge, a concern amplified by the recent COVID-19 crisis. It delves into the scientific predictions and preparedness strategies for future infectious disease outbreaks. The context is the post-COVID-19 era, where societies are recovering but remain acutely aware of global health vulnerabilities. Professor Gao, drawing on his extensive experience, provides insights into the likelihood of different viral threats and the systemic challenges in global pandemic response.

Methods

This paper is an interview, not a traditional research paper with experimental methods. Professor Gao's insights are based on his scientific expertise, past predictions, participation in international exercises (like Event 201), and membership in global health bodies (like the Global Preparedness Monitoring Board). His "methods" involve synthesizing scientific consensus, historical data on pandemics, and understanding viral evolution and transmission dynamics.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pandemics are inevitable: Professor Gao firmly believes that future pandemics are not a matter of "if" but "when," emphasizing that viruses, as ancient inhabitants of Earth, will continue to challenge humanity.
  • Respiratory viruses are the prime suspects: Influenza and coronaviruses are identified as the most likely agents of the next pandemic due to their efficient respiratory transmission, which is far harder to control than fecal-oral routes.
  • Event 201 was not a coincidence: The foresight behind the Event 201 pandemic simulation, which eerily mirrored COVID-19, stemmed from long-standing scientific predictions about coronavirus and influenza threats.
  • COVID-19 response had strengths and weaknesses: While the global response to COVID-19 was swift and comprehensive in areas like NPIs and vaccine development, significant shortcomings exist in data collection and sharing, which are unlikely to improve for the next pandemic.
  • Mpox is a growing concern: The re-declaration of mpox as a PHEIC highlights its evolving transmission patterns, including suspected airborne spread in certain regions, posing a potential future threat.
  • Preparedness requires investment and monitoring: A WHO list of potential pandemic pathogens serves as a crucial guide for policymakers and the public, directing funding towards basic research and robust monitoring systems.
  • TCM's "scientification" is key: Professor Gao advocates for integrating modern scientific methods to study and develop Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), viewing it as a valuable component of medical science rather than a separate entity.
  • Openness and collaboration are paramount: Despite geopolitical shifts, global cooperation in human health and climate change is essential for humanity's survival.

Key Results

  • Professor Gao predicts that future pandemics will most likely be caused by respiratory viruses, specifically influenza or coronaviruses.
  • He notes that while the world has gained some immunity to coronaviruses from COVID-19, the possibility of new viral strains emerging or existing ones recombining to cause another pandemic remains.
  • The mpox outbreak's re-declaration as a PHEIC is linked to its rapid spread in some African regions and the suspicion of airborne transmission, suggesting it could become a larger outbreak.
  • Professor Gao believes that while the response to COVID-19 was largely effective in terms of interventions and development, data collection and sharing were weak points that are unlikely to be significantly improved for future pandemics.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Predicting the timing of the next pandemic: Professor Gao states that predicting the exact timing of the next pandemic is impossible, it could be tomorrow or decades later.
  • Definitive source of SARS-CoV-2: He suggests that a definitive source for SARS-CoV-2 may never be found, drawing parallels to the unresolved origins of HIV.
  • HIV vaccine development: There is currently little hope for an effective HIV vaccine, requiring significant breakthroughs in immunology.
  • Future work: The paper implicitly calls for continued investment in basic research, enhanced monitoring systems, and improved global data-sharing platforms. It also highlights the need for "scientification" of TCM and continued efforts to understand viral evolution and transmission.

Summary updated

Abstract

<i>For Chinese people, 2024 has been a good year. The shadow of the COVID-19 pandemic has dissipated; social activities and domestic travels have largely returned to normal; and they enjoyed the unity and enthusiasm of the Paris Olympic Games together with the whole world. However, there is a lingering thought in everyone's mind that there may be 'a next pandemic' coming sometime in the future. 'Be prepared for danger in times of peace' is a wisdom that never goes out of style. National Science Review (NSR) conducted an interview in September 2024 with Prof. George Fu Gao, the former Director General of the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, an Academician of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, and a top scientist in pathogenic microbiology and immunology. In this interview, Gao talked about the possibilities of 'the next pandemic' from a scientific perspective, and calls on the world to maintain openness, sharing and collaboration in research and action related to global health</i>.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2024will,
  author = {Weijie Zhao},
  title = {{Will the next pandemic be caused by coronavirus again? An interview with George Fu Gao}},
  booktitle = {National},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1093/nsr/nwae477},
}
Figure