Will bots take over the supply chain? Revisiting Agent-based supply chain automation

Liming Xu, Stephen Mak, Alexandra BrintruparXiv 2021 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper reviews the state-of-the-art in agent-based supply chain automation (ABS-SCM), highlighting how advancements in AI and supporting technologies like IoT and digital ledgers are making ABS more viable. It identifies key research areas, challenges, and opportunities for future development to overcome the historical lag in industrial adoption.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the persistent gap between the theoretical promise of agent-based systems (ABS) for supply chain management (SCM) and their slow industrial adoption. Despite being proposed for over two decades, ABS have not been widely implemented due to perceived immaturity of the technology, interoperability issues with existing SCM systems, and a general lack of trust in AI. The authors aim to provide a comprehensive review of the field, identify current trends, and outline future research directions to bridge this gap.

Methods

The authors conducted a systematic literature review of ABS-SCM research. Their methodology involved:

  1. Search Strategy: Using keywords related to "supply chain" and "intelligent agent" across major academic databases (Google Scholar, Scopus, Web of Science).
  2. Inclusion/Exclusion Criteria: Focusing on peer-reviewed, English-language studies that explicitly discuss agent-based technology, practices, or methodologies in SCM, excluding purely simulation-based studies.
  3. Classification and Analysis: Categorizing reviewed studies by publication year, venue, research area (e.g., agent architecture, negotiation, learning), and supply chain function (using the SCOR model).
  4. Bibliometric Analysis: Conducting citation network analysis to identify influential papers and research clusters.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Convergence of Technologies: The paper emphasizes a crucial convergence effect where mature agent-based technology is now being complemented by other emerging technologies like the Internet of Things (IoT) for sensing supply chain states and digital ledgers for secure data sharing, reducing the need for deep ERP integration.
  • From Automation to Autonomy: Learning capabilities within agents are enabling a shift from mere automation to more autonomous decision-making and action.
  • Historical Adoption Lag: The industrial uptake of ABS-SCM has been significantly slower than anticipated, attributed to factors like technology immaturity, interoperability challenges, and trust issues.
  • Research Dispersal: ABS-SCM research is spread across various publication outlets, lacking a consolidated repository, which may hinder progress.
  • Key Research Areas: The dominant research areas are distributed agent architectures, communication and negotiation, learning and optimization, and logic and reasoning.
  • SCOR Model Alignment: Most ABS-SCM research has focused on the "Enable" and "Source" functional areas of the SCOR model, with less exploration in "Tactical automation."
  • Lack of Standardization: A significant challenge is the absence of commonly used performance metrics, benchmark problems, and open-source software, hindering comparative analysis and research advancement.

Key Results

  • The review identified a trend of increasing publications in ABS-SCM, particularly in recent years, likely driven by the resurgence of AI interest.
  • Bibliometric analysis revealed that while seminal papers like "Agents that buy and sell" by Maes et al. are highly cited, the most central work in the ABS-SCM network is on modeling supply chain dynamics (Swaminathan, Smith, and Sadeh, 1998), which focused on simulation frameworks rather than real-life transactions.
  • The majority of reviewed studies focused on process and operational automation, with tactical automation being the least explored.
  • The "Enable" functional area of the SCOR model dominated ABS-SCM research, followed by "Source."
  • A significant portion of research on agent architectures favors physical decomposition, with federated architectures being more common than hierarchical ones for holistic planning.
  • Contract Net Protocol and automated negotiation remain core communication protocols, but extensions from computer science literature are largely overlooked in SCM.
  • The field suffers from a lack of common performance metrics, making it difficult to evaluate and compare different approaches.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Lack of Benchmarks and Metrics: The paper strongly advocates for the definition of benchmark problems and common performance evaluation metrics to facilitate comparative research and advance the field.
  • Interdisciplinary Integration: There's a need for better integration between research on agent architectures and communication protocols, as well as a stronger connection between computer science advancements and SCM applications.
  • Trust and Explainability: Building trust in decentralized operations and developing explainable AI for agent learning and collective behavior are crucial for industrial adoption.
  • Error Handling: There is a notable absence of research on error handling for ABS-SCM systems, which is critical for reliability.
  • Emerging Technologies: The paper anticipates increased research at the intersection of ABS with blockchain, IoT, and digital twins, driven by the trend towards decentralization and digital transformation.
  • Industrial Adoption Barriers: Future work should address the cost of deployment, standardization, and the need for a wider skillset beyond data science for effective ABS implementation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Agent-based systems have the capability to fuse information from many distributed sources and create better plans faster. This feature makes agent-based systems naturally suitable to address the challenges in Supply Chain Management (SCM). Although agent-based supply chains systems have been proposed since early 2000; industrial uptake of them has been lagging. The reasons quoted include the immaturity of the technology, a lack of interoperability with supply chain information systems, and a lack of trust in Artificial Intelligence (AI). In this paper, we revisit the agent-based supply chain and review the state of the art. We find that agent-based technology has matured, and other supporting technologies that are penetrating supply chains; are filling in gaps, leaving the concept applicable to a wider range of functions. For example, the ubiquity of IoT technology helps agents "sense" the state of affairs in a supply chain and opens up new possibilities for automation. Digital ledgers help securely transfer data between third parties, making agent-based information sharing possible, without the need to integrate Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems. Learning functionality in agents enables agents to move beyond automation and towards autonomy. We note this convergence effect through conceptualising an agent-based supply chain framework, reviewing its components, and highlighting research challenges that need to be addressed in moving forward.
BibTeX
@misc{xu2021will,
  author = {Liming Xu and Stephen Mak and Alexandra Brintrup},
  title = {{Will bots take over the supply chain? Revisiting Agent-based supply chain automation}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2109.01703},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2109.01703},
}

Loading related content...

Figure