Widespread global disparities between modelled and observed mid-depth ocean currents

Fenzhen Su, Rong Fan, Fengqin Yan, Michael E. Meadows, Vincent Lyne, Po Hu, Xiangzhou Song, Tianyu Zhang, Zenghong Liu, Chenghu Zhou, Tao Pei, Xiaomei Yang, Yunyan Du, Zexun Wei, Fan Wang, Yiquan Qi, Fei ChaiNature Communications 2023 · DOI

Abstract

The mid-depth ocean circulation is critically linked to actual changes in the long-term global climate system. However, in the past few decades, predictions based on ocean circulation models highlight the lack of data, knowledge, and long-term implications in climate change assessment. Here, using 842,421 observations produced by Argo floats from 2001-2020, and Lagrangian simulations, we show that only 3.8% of the mid-depth oceans, including part of the equatorial Pacific Ocean and the Antarctic Circumpolar Current, can be regarded as accurately modelled, while other regions exhibit significant underestimations in mean current velocity. Knowledge of ocean circulation is generally more complete in the low-latitude oceans but is especially poor in high latitude regions. Accordingly, we propose improvements in forecasting, model representation of stochasticity, and enhancement of observations of ocean currents. The study demonstrates that knowledge and model representations of global circulation are substantially compromised by inaccuracies of significant magnitude and direction, with important implications for modelled predictions of currents, temperature, carbon dioxide sequestration, and sea-level rise trends.

Introduction

The mid-depth ocean, roughly 1,000 meters below the surface, acts as a critical regulator for the Earth's climate by redistributing heat and sequestering carbon dioxide. Despite its importance, it remains one of the most difficult parts of the planet to observe directly. For decades, researchers have relied on Global Circulation Models (GCMs) to predict these currents, but these models are often tuned to surface data, leaving their ability to simulate mid-depth velocity and direction largely unvalidated on a global scale. This study quantifies the "knowledge gap" by comparing current simulations against twenty years of direct observations.

Methods and Data Coverage

The researchers performed a massive "apples-to-apples" comparison between real-world observations and three leading eddy-permitting ocean models: ECCO2, OFES, and CMEMS GLORYS12. The primary observational source was the ANDRO dataset, containing over 840,000 displacements from Argo floats between 2001 and 2020.

To ensure a fair comparison, the authors ran Lagrangian simulations within the models, "dropping" virtual floats into the digital ocean at the same times and places as the real ones. They measured disparity using five key metrics, including Difference of Direction (DOD) and Difference of Velocity (DOV).

Global coverage of Argo float trajectories used to validate mid-depth current simulations across different model frameworks.

The 3.8% Reality Check

The results reveal a startling gap: even the best-performing model (CMEMS) accurately simulated only 3.843% of the global mid-depth ocean. These "well-modelled" areas are almost exclusively limited to the equatorial Pacific and parts of the Antarctic Circumpolar Current (ACC). In over 80% of the global ocean, the predicted current direction deviated from observations by more than 45 degrees.

Furthermore, models consistently underestimate the ocean's kinetic energy. In high-energy regions like the Gulf Stream or the Agulhas Current, models missed velocity marks by as much as 16 cm/s. In these Western Boundary Currents, observed velocities were often 70% higher than predicted.

Global maps of disparities in direction (left column) and velocity (right column) between observations and models, highlighting widespread underestimation of current speeds.

Latitudinal Bias and Stochasticity

A significant finding is the latitudinal bias in model performance. Accuracy is generally higher at low latitudes near the equator but degrades significantly toward the poles. This suggests that the physics of high-latitude "stochasticity"—the randomness and turbulence associated with mesoscale eddies—is not being adequately captured by current simulations.

Cluster analysis categorized the global ocean into four zones based on these failures. Cluster 1, representing 40.4% of the ocean, is characterized by high directional error, mostly in mid-latitudes. Cluster 4, found in major boundary currents, shows the highest levels of velocity underestimation.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The widespread inaccuracies identified in this study have serious implications for our predictions of heat transport, carbon sequestration, and sea-level rise. The authors attribute these failures to the insufficient resolution of current "eddy-permitting" models and inadequate representation of sub-grid processes like tidal mixing against rough seafloor topography.

To bridge this gap, the study calls for transitioning to "eddy-resolving" models with much finer horizontal grids, improving mathematical parameterizations for mid-depth turbulence, and increasing intensive observations in high-latitude regions where model performance is currently poorest.

Summary updated

Abstract

The mid-depth ocean circulation is critically linked to actual changes in the long-term global climate system. However, in the past few decades, predictions based on ocean circulation models highlight the lack of data, knowledge, and long-term implications in climate change assessment. Here, using 842,421 observations produced by Argo floats from 2001-2020, and Lagrangian simulations, we show that only 3.8% of the mid-depth oceans, including part of the equatorial Pacific Ocean and the Antarctic Circumpolar Current, can be regarded as accurately modelled, while other regions exhibit significant underestimations in mean current velocity. Knowledge of ocean circulation is generally more complete in the low-latitude oceans but is especially poor in high latitude regions. Accordingly, we propose improvements in forecasting, model representation of stochasticity, and enhancement of observations of ocean currents. The study demonstrates that knowledge and model representations of global circulation are substantially compromised by inaccuracies of significant magnitude and direction, with important implications for modelled predictions of currents, temperature, carbon dioxide sequestration, and sea-level rise trends.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{su2023widespread,
  author = {Fenzhen Su and Rong Fan and Fengqin Yan and Michael E. Meadows and Vincent Lyne and Po Hu and Xiangzhou Song and Tianyu Zhang and Zenghong Liu and Chenghu Zhou and Tao Pei and Xiaomei Yang and Yunyan Du and Zexun Wei and Fan Wang and Yiquan Qi and Fei Chai},
  title = {{Widespread global disparities between modelled and observed mid-depth ocean currents}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-023-37841-x},
}
Figure