Abstract
The investigated hybrid carbon fiber reinforced plastics-elastomer-metal laminates (HyCEML) offer the potential of tailored structural materials with adaptable damping properties. Conventional fiber metal laminates, like glass laminate aluminum reinforced epoxy, are already widely spread in the aviation industry owing to their outstanding fatigue behavior. By integrating an elastomeric interlayer, the glass fibers can be substituted by carbon fibers and damping properties of these laminates can be adjusted. The viscoelastic interlayer dissipates energy within the laminate by inducing shear strain during bending, which is commonly known as constrained layer damping. The aim of this paper is the description of the vibration and damping behavior of HyCEML over a wide temperature and frequency range by using different test methods. Dynamic mechanical analysis is used for the individual polymeric constituents and coupon specimens and modal analysis is used with different specimen geometries up to a component sized panel. In addition, analytical and numerical approaches complement the experiments and lead to a deeper understanding of the vibration and damping behavior. Owing to the high damping, already at frequencies of 5 kHz only running waves can be detected for the investigated panel size. The discussion of different test methods helps to identify material and wavelength dependent effects, but also possible adverse effects of certain methods.
Introduction
Engineers in the aerospace and automotive sectors are increasingly seeking lightweight materials that combine structural strength with high vibration damping. Hybrid Carbon Fiber Reinforced Plastic-Elastomer-Metal Laminates (HyCEML) address this need through Constrained Layer Damping (CLD). In this architecture, a thin viscoelastic elastomer layer is sandwiched between stiff face sheets. When the laminate undergoes bending, the elastomer is forced into shear, effectively dissipating kinetic energy as heat.
However, characterizing this damping is complex because loss factors vary significantly with temperature, frequency, and part geometry. This research provides a "wide scale" comparison, bridging the gap between material-level properties and component-level behavior using various experimental and numerical methods.
Material Architecture and Composition
The study focuses on a specific symmetric laminate system designed for high performance. The layup consists of a [CFRP/El/Al/El/CFRP] stack, utilizing HexPly® M77 CFRP and AL2024-T3 Aluminum face sheets, with a Kraibon® SAA9579-52 EPDM elastomer core.
As shown in the micrograph above, the CFRP layers are approximately 0.60 mm thick (comprising four 0.15 mm plies), while the elastomer interlayers are 0.65 mm thick, surrounding a 0.30 mm aluminum core. This precise layering is critical for inducing the shear strain necessary for energy dissipation.
Experimental and Numerical Methodology
The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to capture the material's behavior across scales:
- Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (DMA): Used to establish "master curves" for the raw elastomer and the laminate under non-resonant 3-point bending.
- Experimental Modal Analysis (EMA): Resonant testing performed on various geometries, including clamped cantilever beams and a large 380mm x 380mm panel.
- Wave Attenuation Analysis: High-frequency (5 kHz) testing using a scanning laser Doppler vibrometer to observe how vibrations dissipate as they travel across the panel.
- Modeling: Analytical approaches using the Ross-Kerwin-Ungar (RKU) equations were complemented by 3D Finite Element Analysis (FEA) in Abaqus.
Characterizing the Viscoelastic Core
The damping performance of the entire laminate is fundamentally driven by the viscoelastic properties of the elastomer interlayer. By performing DMA across a range of temperatures and frequencies, the authors generated master curves that describe the material's transition from a rubbery to a glassy state.
These curves reveal that the loss factor ($\tan \delta$) peaks during the glass transition, providing a roadmap for predicting at which frequencies and temperatures the HyCEML will be most effective at damping vibrations.
Key Insights: Wavelength vs. Frequency
A primary finding of the study is that the loss factor is highly dependent on the bending wavelength rather than frequency alone. Higher-order vibration modes, which feature shorter wavelengths, create more intense shear in the elastomer, leading to higher damping.
The authors demonstrated that non-resonant DMA tests could be reconciled with resonant modal tests by matching the semi-wavelength of the deformation. For instance, the damping measured in a 3-point bending test with an 80mm span closely aligned with the 4th bending mode of a cantilever beam.
Results and Modeling Accuracy
- Damping Levels: The HyCEML system achieved significant damping, with loss factors ($\eta$) ranging from 0.02 to over 0.10—substantially higher than plain aluminum or CFRP (typically < 0.01).
- Running Waves: At high frequencies (5 kHz), the material is so efficient that vibrations dissipate before reaching the panel edges, resulting in "running waves" rather than traditional standing modes.
- Model Performance: The analytical RKU model proved robust for simple geometries, predicting natural frequencies within ~15% of experimental data. However, numerical models tended to overestimate stiffness, likely due to the challenges of accurately modeling CFRP anisotropy and manufacturing variations.
Conclusion and Future Work
While HyCEMLs offer exceptional tailored damping, the study highlighted limitations in current testing and modeling. Boundary conditions in "free-free" modal tests can introduce parasitic damping, and the "Payne effect" (strain-dependent stiffness in elastomers) requires further exploration. Future research will focus on 3D stress states in the elastomer at ultra-high frequencies where simple shear assumptions may no longer hold.
Summary updated