TL;DR
This paper explores what happens to the fundamental properties of physical theories (like the number of particles, unitarity, and renormalizability) when you perform a "double Wick rotation" – essentially swapping a spatial dimension for time. They discover that if a theory doesn't respect Lorentz invariance (the idea that the laws of physics are the same for all observers), these properties can drastically change, leading to unexpected and sometimes problematic outcomes.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In theoretical physics, Wick rotation is a common mathematical trick. It involves analytically continuing the time coordinate (e.g., replacing $t$ with $it$) to transform a theory with a Lorentzian signature (like spacetime in relativity) into one with a Euclidean signature (like standard geometry). This is incredibly useful for calculations. However, the paper asks a crucial question: what happens if you perform this rotation twice (a "double Wick rotation" or DWR), effectively turning a spatial dimension into a new time dimension? Specifically, they investigate whether the physical properties of a theory remain the same after such a transformation, especially when the theory itself doesn't obey Lorentz invariance. This is important because many theories beyond the Standard Model, like some theories of gravity, naturally break Lorentz invariance, and understanding how their fundamental properties behave under transformations is key to their validity.
Methods
The authors employ a direct analytical approach. They start with theories defined in Euclidean spacetime and then perform a double Wick rotation by analytically continuing one of the spatial coordinates into a time coordinate. They then analyze the resulting actions and their implications for:
- Degrees of Freedom (dof): How many independent propagating particles or modes does the theory describe?
- Unitarity: Does the theory maintain probability conservation, or does it lead to unphysical negative probabilities (often associated with "ghost" states)?
- Renormalizability: Can the theory be consistently defined at all energy scales, or does it suffer from uncontrollable infinities?
They illustrate their points with specific examples of scalar field theories and a Proca (massive vector) field theory, both in flat spacetime. They also consider cases where Lorentz invariance is explicitly broken by introducing parameters into the action.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. This paper is a theoretical exploration using mathematical manipulations of field theory actions, not an empirical study requiring datasets.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Lorentz Invariance is Key: The most striking finding is that the translation of physical properties under DWR is highly dependent on whether the original theory respects Lorentz invariance. If it does, properties generally translate well. If not, they can change dramatically.
- DWR Can Break Symmetries: When Lorentz invariance is broken, different choices of which spatial coordinate to turn into time can lead to inequivalent theories. This means the "mirror" theory obtained after DWR is not unique and depends on the specific rotation performed.
- Emergence of Ghosts: DWR can introduce "ghost" states (Ostrogradsky ghosts) in theories that were previously unitary. This happens when higher-order spatial derivatives in the Euclidean theory translate into higher-order time derivatives in the Lorentzian theory, leading to a breakdown of unitarity.
- Strong Coupling Phenomena: In some cases, DWR can lead to the emergence of extra degrees of freedom. If these new modes interact strongly, they might decouple from the rest of the theory at certain energy scales, similar to phenomena seen in massive gravity.
- Renormalizability is Not Guaranteed: While some properties might translate, renormalizability is not automatically preserved. The structure of the theory can change so drastically that a renormalizable theory might become non-renormalizable, or vice-versa, depending on the specific DWR and the theory's initial properties.
Key Results
The paper provides concrete examples demonstrating how:
- A simple scalar field theory, when Lorentz invariance is broken (e.g., by an anisotropic term), can lead to different numbers of propagating modes depending on which spatial direction is chosen as time.
- A Proca field theory, when subjected to DWR in a way that breaks Lorentz invariance, can develop an Ostrogradsky ghost, indicating a loss of unitarity.
- The renormalizability of a theory can be affected by DWR, particularly when dealing with conserved currents in vector field theories. The paper shows that source conservation is crucial for maintaining renormalizability in certain Wick-connected scenarios.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that their analysis is primarily conducted in flat spacetime. They suggest that a crucial next step is to generalize these findings to curved spacetimes, especially in the context of modified gravity theories, which are often motivated by cosmology and can naturally incorporate Lorentz violation. They also propose exploring the implications of DWR for theories with CP and CPT violation, which could have interesting phenomenological consequences in particle physics. The question of whether strongly coupled modes that emerge after DWR can match the properties of the original theory beyond a certain scale also remains an open and intriguing avenue.
Summary updated