Why the oldest old in China bypass primary care: culture, family, and health system limitations

Marius Wamsiedel, Boyang LiInternational Journal of Qualitative Studies on Health and Well-Being 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores why the oldest old in China often bypass primary care (PHC) for higher-tier hospitals, revealing that it's not just about systemic issues but also deeply ingrained cultural beliefs, family influence, and personal connections. Understanding these multifaceted drivers is crucial for designing effective interventions to improve PHC utilization and equitable healthcare access for China's aging population.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In China, despite significant reforms aimed at strengthening primary healthcare (PHC), a persistent problem of "bypassing" exists, where individuals opt for secondary or tertiary hospitals even for minor ailments. While previous research has largely focused on systemic factors like resource shortages or distrust in PHC quality, this study tackles a critical gap: understanding why the oldest old (individuals aged 80 and above) bypass PHC. This demographic presents unique health needs and is heavily influenced by social and cultural contexts, making their decision-making processes particularly complex and underexplored. The paper aims to provide a more holistic understanding by integrating cultural norms, family dynamics, and individual health beliefs with systemic limitations.

Methods

The researchers employed a qualitative approach, conducting 20 in-depth, semi-structured interviews with individuals aged 80 and above from three diverse locations in China: Tengzhou (Shandong), Anyang (Henan), and Shanghai. The interview guide covered a broad range of topics, including beliefs about health and aging, family relationships, healthcare experiences, and expectations. Data analysis involved a combination of inductive and deductive coding. Initially, inductive coding, guided by constructive grounded theory, allowed themes to emerge directly from participant narratives. Subsequently, these emergent categories were integrated within the Health Belief Model (HBM) to provide a structured framework for understanding the factors influencing bypassing behaviors.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ageing as Natural, Endurance as Norm: A significant cultural factor is the perception of aging as an inevitable, natural process, coupled with a strong cultural norm of endurance. This leads many older adults to dismiss minor ailments and delay seeking care, viewing it as a sign of weakness or a burden.
  • Filial Piety Drives Hospital Preference: Family, particularly adult children, plays a pivotal role. Driven by filial piety and a belief that hospitals offer superior care, children often push their elderly parents towards higher-tier facilities, even providing transportation and managing administrative tasks.
  • "Guanxi" (Connections) as a Key: Personal connections within hospitals ("guanxi") are a powerful, often unspoken, factor. Having a child or relative working in a hospital grants preferential treatment, reduces waiting times, and increases trust, making hospitals a more attractive option than PHC.
  • PHC Perceived as Substandard, Especially for Diagnosis: Despite acknowledging PHC's convenience, participants often perceive its diagnostic capabilities as inferior to hospitals. This perception is fueled by concerns about practitioner qualifications, limited access to advanced equipment, and past negative experiences.
  • Medication Availability and Quality Concerns: While PHC is seen as affordable for procuring medicines, issues like frequent drug shortages, restricted essential medicine lists, and perceived lower quality compared to hospital pharmacies further deter usage.

Key Results

The study identified several key drivers for PHC bypassing among the oldest old:

  • Cultural and Historical Factors: The perception of aging as natural and the norm of endurance significantly delay care-seeking for minor issues. Past experiences of poverty and medical scarcity also contribute to a disposition to endure rather than seek immediate care.
  • Family Involvement: Children actively encourage hospital visits, viewing it as a demonstration of filial devotion and believing hospitals offer better care. They often facilitate the entire process, from decision-making to transportation and paperwork.
  • Health System Limitations: While not the sole driver, perceived inferior quality of PHC services, limited availability and perceived lower quality of medicines, and inadequate infrastructure (e.g., lack of handrails) contribute to bypassing.
  • Personal Connections (Guanxi): The presence of personal connections within hospitals significantly enhances trust, access, and the overall patient experience, making PHC less appealing.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Practical Constraints: The inability to conduct data collection and analysis jointly meant that some nuances, like the full extent of filial devotion's role, might not have been fully captured.
  • Sample Homogeneity: The study's sample consisted only of ethically Han people. Future research should explore bypassing behaviors among other ethnic groups in China.

The paper suggests several avenues for future work and interventions:

  • Improving PHC Quality: Attracting and retaining qualified PHC workforce, equipping facilities with modern medical equipment, and enhancing diagnostic capabilities are crucial.
  • Reforming Policies: Revising the essential medicines list to better meet patient needs and increasing PHC doctors' autonomy in prescribing medicines are recommended.
  • Promoting Cultural Change: Public awareness campaigns are needed to emphasize prevention, share positive PHC experiences, and highlight the negative consequences of bypassing. This aims to shift perceptions of PHC and encourage its use for appropriate conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our findings suggest that health system improvements alone, albeit necessary, are insufficient to reduce the bypassing of primary care. Interventions should also address the socio-cultural factors influencing this practice. Specifically, this paper calls for improving the quality of primary health services, reforming the essential medicines policy, and promoting cultural change by prioritizing preventive care and improving the general perception of community health centres, township health centres, and village clinics.
BibTeX
@article{wamsiedel2025why,
  author = {Marius Wamsiedel and Boyang Li},
  title = {{Why the oldest old in China bypass primary care: culture, family, and health system limitations}},
  journal = {International Journal of Qualitative Studies on Health and Well-Being},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1080/17482631.2025.2536103},
}
Figure