Abstract: The study compares the competitiveness of three Korean groups raised in different institutional environments: South Korea, North Korea, and China. Laboratory experiments reveal that North Korean refugees are less likely to participate in competitive tournaments than South Koreans and Korean-Chinese immigrants. Analysis using a choice model with probability weighting suggests that lower cognitive ability may lead to lower expected performance, more pessimistic beliefs, and greater aversion to competition.
Introduction
Economists have long identified "competitiveness"—the willingness to engage in contests—as a vital trait for success within market economies. However, a central question remains: is this trait innate, or is it shaped by the institutional environment? The division of the Korean Peninsula provides a rare "natural experiment" to explore this. Three groups with identical ethnic and historical origins were raised in vastly different systems: the democratic market economy of South Korea (SK), the centrally planned dictatorship of North Korea (NK), and the one-party state of China (KC), which features significant market exposure. This study investigates whether growing up in North Korea leads individuals to "shy away" from competition and identifies the specific mechanisms driving that behavior.
Experimental Design and Methods
The researchers conducted a laboratory experiment with 456 participants currently living in South Korea. The sample included 191 North Korean refugees, 193 South Korean natives (oversampled for low-income individuals to match the refugees' socioeconomic status), and 72 Korean-Chinese immigrants.
The core task required participants to count the number of zeros in a series of 7x7 grids within five minutes. The experiment followed a multi-stage design:
- Piece-Rate vs. Tournament: Participants performed the task under a guaranteed payment per correct answer and then in a winner-take-all tournament against an anonymous partner.
- The Choice: Participants chose which payment scheme they preferred for a third round.
- Random Bonus: To disentangle skill from preference, the authors introduced a random bonus of 0–10 points added to scores, encouraging lower-performing individuals to consider the tournament.
- Psychometric Testing: Participants completed the Raven’s Progressive Matrices Test (a measure of fluid intelligence) and surveys regarding risk preferences and subjective winning beliefs.
Key Findings: The Cognitive Link
The study revealed a significant "competitiveness gap." Initially, North Korean refugees were 20 percentage points less likely to choose the tournament than South Koreans (45% vs. 65%). However, the most striking finding emerged when researchers controlled for cognitive ability.
There was a "staggering gap" in Raven test z-scores: -0.771 for NK refugees versus 0.724 for SK natives. When these scores were factored into the regression analysis, the statistical difference in competitiveness between the two groups vanished. In fact, the data suggested that for a given level of cognitive ability, North Korean refugees might actually be more competitive than their South Korean counterparts. This indicates that the reluctance to compete is not a fixed ideological trait but is closely tied to cognitive development.
Mechanisms of Competition Aversion
Using a choice model, the authors identified three channels through which lower cognitive ability impacts the decision to compete:
- Lower Expected Performance: Participants correctly anticipated they would solve fewer problems.
- Pessimism: Lower-scoring individuals were more likely to underestimate their chances of winning, even when accounting for their objective skill level.
- Direct Aversion: There was a higher inherent "distaste" for the act of competing itself among those with lower cognitive scores.
Discussion and Implications
The authors argue that the lower cognitive scores among NK refugees likely stem from "macro factors" rather than innate differences. These include childhood malnutrition—particularly for those who grew up during the "Arduous March" famine—and an education system that emphasizes ideological rote memorization over analytical problem-solving. This suggests that the competitiveness gap is a product of "nurture" and environmental deprivation rather than communist ideology alone.
Limitations
The study acknowledges several caveats. First, selection bias is a factor; North Korean refugees are not a random sample, as they are individuals who chose to escape the regime. Second, the "black box" of the environment makes it difficult to isolate whether the cognitive gap is caused by caloric deficits, educational differences, or the general stress of living under a totalitarian regime. Finally, a potential for mistrust exists, as refugees might suspect tournament rules are rigged against them. Future research may focus on "catch-up" effects to see if these gaps close as refugees spend more time in market-based democracies.
Summary updated