Why is penguin more similar to polar bear than to sea gull? Analyzing conceptual knowledge in distributional models

Pia SommerauerACL 2020

TL;DR

This paper proposes a framework to understand what kind of conceptual knowledge is encoded in distributional semantic models (like Word2vec or BERT). By combining linguistic hypotheses with novel analysis methods and a custom-annotated dataset, the authors aim to reveal how these models represent semantic information and what limitations they have in capturing human-like conceptual understanding.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern Natural Language Processing (NLP) models, particularly those based on distributional semantics (e.g., Word2vec, BERT), have achieved remarkable success by representing words as vectors in a high-dimensional space. These "embeddings" capture semantic similarity, allowing models to understand relationships between words. However, a fundamental question remains: what exactly do these embeddings represent about the concepts themselves? Do they capture nuanced aspects of human knowledge, like typicality, affordances, or variability? Current methods for analyzing these representations are limited and not well understood, making it difficult to interpret their outputs or to determine what kind of linguistic information they can reliably capture. This paper seeks to bridge this gap by systematically investigating the semantic information encoded in these models and how it relates to human conceptual knowledge.

Methods

The proposed framework involves a four-step approach:

  1. Formulating Linguistic Hypotheses: The authors define semantic relations based on cognitive and computational linguistics research, focusing on factors like impliedness, typicality, affordedness, and variability. These hypotheses predict what aspects of conceptual knowledge are likely to be expressed in natural language.
  2. Building a Human Judgment Corpus: A dataset of concept-property pairs is created, annotated by crowd workers with the defined semantic relations. This corpus aims to reflect human knowledge about concepts and their properties, serving as a ground truth.
  3. Simulating Linguistic Evidence: To understand how distributional models process information, the authors plan to simulate different types of linguistic evidence within text corpora. This involves introducing artificial "evidence words" to manipulate the contexts of words and observe their impact on model representations.
  4. Model Analysis and Interpretation: Existing and novel model analysis methods, such as diagnostic classification and Singular Vector Canonical Correlation Analysis (SVCCA), will be applied to both real and simulated data. The goal is to interpret the results in light of the linguistic hypotheses and the limitations of the analysis methods themselves.

Datasets

  • Human Judgment Corpus: A newly introduced dataset of concept-property pairs annotated with fine-grained semantic relations (impliedness, typicality, affordedness, variability, etc.). This dataset is designed to include positive and negative examples that are not easily separable by general semantic similarity, making it a challenging benchmark for model analysis.
  • Existing Resources: The dataset construction leverages existing resources like the CSLB feature norms, WordNet, ConceptNet, and stereotype data.
  • Simulated Data: Artificial text corpora are generated by introducing specific linguistic evidence to observe how distributional models learn from controlled inputs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Simple Similarity: The paper argues that distributional models might capture more than just basic semantic similarity. They could potentially encode nuanced aspects of human conceptual knowledge, such as how typical a property is for a concept or what actions are afforded by an object.
  • The Importance of Negative Examples: For robust analysis, it's crucial to have well-defined negative examples that are semantically close to positive examples but lack the specific property. This helps distinguish true property recognition from general semantic clustering.
  • Simulating Evidence for Control: By artificially injecting linguistic evidence into corpora, the researchers can gain precise control over the input and better understand how models learn and represent specific semantic properties. This is a key step towards interpreting the black box of deep learning models.
  • Bridging Linguistics and NLP: The framework explicitly connects linguistic theories about how humans represent knowledge with computational methods for analyzing NLP models, aiming to create a more grounded understanding of semantic representations.

Key Results

The paper is a proposal, so it does not present final quantitative results. However, it outlines the expected outcomes:

  • Understanding Model Capabilities: The research is expected to reveal what types of semantic information can be inferred from linguistic co-occurrence patterns alone and what potential distributional models have for capturing linguistic evidence.
  • Methodological Insights: The study aims to provide insights into the strengths and weaknesses of various model analysis methods, particularly in the context of controlled simulations.
  • Falsifiable Hypotheses: The linguistic hypotheses are designed to be testable and potentially falsifiable, which, even if proven wrong, would still offer valuable insights into the limitations of current models and data.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Ambiguity in Annotation: The authors acknowledge that ambiguity in interpreting concepts, properties, or relations can lead to disagreements among annotators. This is seen as a valuable aspect that can reveal polysemy and other complexities in semantic representation.
  • Data Size for Models: It is challenging to design small, controlled experiments for distributional models, as they typically require substantial amounts of data. The proposed approach of introducing artificial evidence to existing corpora aims to mitigate this.
  • Future Work: The proposal sets the stage for future work that will involve applying the developed framework to analyze real-world distributional models, interpret their findings in relation to human knowledge, and potentially inform the development of more semantically rich NLP systems. The insights gained are also expected to complement existing common-sense knowledge resources.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{sommerauer2020why,
  author = {Pia Sommerauer},
  title = {{Why is penguin more similar to polar bear than to sea gull? Analyzing conceptual knowledge in distributional models}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2020},
}
Figure