Why do people believe COVID-19 conspiracy theories?

Joseph E. Uscinski, Adam Enders, Casey Klofstad, Michelle I. Seelig, John Funchion, Caleb Everett, Stephan Wuchty, Kamal Premaratne, Manohar N. MurthiHarvard Kennedy School Misinformation Review 2020 · DOI

Abstract

As conspiracy theories about COVID-19 take root in the United States, understanding the psychological foundations of conspiracy beliefs is increasingly critical. Our research shows that beliefs in two popular variants of COVID-19 conspiracy theory are the joint product of the psychological predispositions 1) to reject information coming from experts and other authority figures and 2) to view major events as the product of secret plots.

Introduction

As COVID-19 began to spread in early 2020, so did misinformation. A significant portion of the U.S. population adopted conspiracy theories that contradicted scientific consensus, such as the idea that the virus was a hoax or a purposefully created bioweapon. These beliefs have dire consequences: individuals who subscribe to them are less likely to follow public health guidelines, including social distancing and vaccination. Understanding the psychological and political drivers of these beliefs is essential for designing effective mitigation strategies.

Methods

We conducted a representative survey of 2,023 U.S. adults between March 17–19, 2020, just as the nation entered its first major lockdowns. Using Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) regression models, we analyzed the relationship between belief in conspiracy theories and several key variables:

  • Conspiracy Thinking: A psychological scale measuring the tendency to see secret plots behind major events.
  • Denialism: A scale measuring the predisposition to reject authoritative or expert information.
  • Partisanship and Ideology: Self-identified political leanings and support for Donald Trump.
  • Demographics: Age, education, income, race, and religiosity.

Key Insights: The Foundations of Belief

Our analysis reveals that distrust is the primary foundation for COVID-19 conspiracy beliefs. The strongest predictors are not a lack of intelligence or education, but rather a psychological predisposition to distrust experts (denialism) and a general worldview that "nothing is as it seems" (conspiracy thinking).

Interestingly, we found no correlation between educational attainment and belief in these theories. This suggests that simply providing more information or "fact-checking" may be ineffective if the underlying issue is a fundamental rejection of the source of that information.

Results: Two Flavors of Conspiracy

We examined two primary conspiracy theories: the "Exaggerated Threat" theory (the virus was hyped to damage President Trump) and the "Virus Created on Purpose" theory. At the time of the survey, 29% of respondents agreed with the former, and 31% agreed with the latter.

Standardized regression coefficients for predictors of COVID-19 conspiracy beliefs.

As shown in Figure 5, the predictors for these two theories differ. Conspiracy thinking was the single strongest predictor for the "created on purpose" theory (blue triangles). In contrast, for the "exaggerated threat" theory (red circles), denialism and partisanship were the dominant factors.

The "Top-Down" Effect of Partisanship

Partisanship acts as a powerful filter for pandemic-related information. Supporters of Donald Trump were significantly more likely to believe the threat was exaggerated. This suggests that elite cues—messages from political leaders—directly shape the perceived "truth" for their followers.

Predicted beliefs in COVID-19 conspiracies as a function of conspiracy thinking and partisanship.

Figure 6 illustrates how these predispositions differentially predict belief in the two theories. The top panel shows that conspiracy thinking is a much stronger driver for the "created on purpose" theory (blue line), while the bottom panel shows that partisanship is the dominant driver for the "exaggerated threat" theory (red line).

Discussion and Future Directions

Because these beliefs are rooted in a distrust of experts, traditional corrections from scientists or health officials often fail. Effective intervention may require "co-partisan" corrections, where trusted political leaders explicitly debunk misinformation. Future research should explore "pre-bunking" strategies to inoculate the public against misinformation before it takes root and investigate ways to address the existential and social motivations that drive individuals toward conspiracy thinking.

Summary updated

Abstract

As conspiracy theories about COVID-19 take root in the United States, understanding the psychological foundations of conspiracy beliefs is increasingly critical. Our research shows that beliefs in two popular variants of COVID-19 conspiracy theory are the joint product of the psychological predispositions 1) to reject information coming from experts and other authority figures and 2)
BibTeX
@article{uscinski2020why,
  author = {Joseph E. Uscinski and Adam Enders and Casey Klofstad and Michelle I. Seelig and John Funchion and Caleb Everett and Stephan Wuchty and Kamal Premaratne and Manohar N. Murthi},
  title = {{Why do people believe COVID-19 conspiracy theories?}},
  journal = {Harvard Kennedy School Misinformation Review},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.37016/mr-2020-015},
}
Figure