Whole-lake algal responses to a century of acidic industrial deposition on the Canadian Shield

Rolf D. Vinebrooke, Sushil S. Dixit, Mark D. Graham, John M. Gunn, Yuwei Chen, Nelson BelzileCanadian 2002 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses sedimentary pigment analysis to reconstruct the algal community structure of six boreal lakes in Canada over the past century. The findings reveal that industrial acid deposition has significantly altered algal abundance and composition in four acidified lakes and one circumneutral lake, suggesting a widespread impact on the base of aquatic food webs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Boreal lakes are naturally species-poor ecosystems, making them particularly vulnerable to anthropogenic stressors like acid rain and climate change. While it's hypothesized that a century of industrial acidification has altered algal communities, this has been difficult to prove due to a lack of historical data predating industrial pollution and challenges in assessing whole-lake algal structure. This paper aims to fill that gap by using a novel approach to reconstruct past algal communities and test the hypothesis that industrial deposition has significantly impacted these sensitive ecosystems.

Methods

The core methodology employed is paleolimnology, specifically the analysis of sedimentary pigments using High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC). This technique allows researchers to identify and quantify pigments preserved in lake sediments, which act as chemical fingerprints of the algal communities that existed in the past.

Here's a breakdown of the key methods:

  • Sediment Core Collection: Sediment cores were collected from the deepest parts of six boreal lakes in Killarney Provincial Park, Ontario. These cores represent a chronological record of the lake's history.
  • Dating: Sediment cores were dated using 210Pb activity, a common radiometric dating technique for recent sediments. This allowed researchers to establish a timeline for the sediment layers.
  • Pigment Extraction and Analysis: Freeze-dried sediment samples were subjected to pigment extraction using a mixture of acetone, methanol, and water. The extracted pigments were then analyzed using reversed-phase HPLC. This method separates and quantifies various chlorophylls and carotenoids.
  • Taxonomic Pigment Identification: Specific pigments were identified and linked to particular algal groups. For example, chlorophyll b is indicative of chlorophytes (green algae), while fucoxanthin is associated with chromophytes (like diatoms and chrysophytes).
  • Statistical Analysis:
    • T-tests and Z-tests were used to compare pre- and post-industrial pigment concentrations.
  • Randomization testing was employed to determine the statistical significance of these comparisons, accounting for potential temporal pseudoreplication.
  • Correspondence Analysis (CA) was used to ordinate pigment data and sediment samples, revealing temporal shifts in algal community structure and identifying associations between specific pigments and time periods.

What's novel here is the application of detailed sedimentary pigment analysis to reconstruct whole-lake algal community structure over a century, directly linking it to the onset of industrial pollution.

Datasets

The study utilized sediment cores collected from six boreal lakes in Killarney Provincial Park, Ontario, Canada. These cores provided the historical dataset for pigment analysis. The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather uses existing paleolimnological techniques on a specific set of lakes to address a long-standing question.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Industrial Pollution's Long Reach: The study provides strong evidence that industrial pollution, specifically acid deposition, has had a significant and lasting impact on the base of aquatic food webs in boreal lakes, extending beyond just the acidified lakes.
  • Algal Blooms in Acidified Lakes: Contrary to initial expectations that acidification would suppress algal growth, the study found evidence of increased algal abundance in four acidified lakes. This suggests that acidification can create conditions that favor certain algal groups.
  • Deepwater and Benthic Algae Thrive: The pigment signatures point towards an increase in deepwater phytoplankton (phytoflagellates) and benthic algae (filamentous green algae) in acidified lakes. This shift is attributed to factors like increased underwater light penetration (due to reduced dissolved organic carbon) and potentially reduced grazing pressure.
  • Circumneutral Lakes Also Affected: The impact wasn't limited to acidified lakes; one small, circumneutral lake also showed significant increases in algal abundance, suggesting that even lakes not directly acidified can be influenced by broader atmospheric pollution, possibly through nutrient inputs.
  • Resilience vs. Vulnerability: While some lakes show signs of recovery, the altered algal community structure may make them less resilient to future environmental stressors.

Key Results

  • Increased Pigment Concentrations: Post-industrial (ca. 1900) sedimentary pigment concentrations (chlorophylls and carotenoids) increased significantly by 50-300% in five of the six study lakes.
  • Specific Pigment Increases: The most significant increases in total chlorophyll and carotenoid concentrations were observed after 1940 in the heavily acidified lakes (Acid and OSA). Increases in chlorophyll b, alloxanthin, and fucoxanthin were particularly notable.
  • Algal Group Shifts: Taxonomically diagnostic pigments indicated shifts towards filamentous green phytobenthos and deepwater phytoflagellates in the acidified lakes.
  • Teardrop Lake Anomaly: A small, circumneutral lake (Teardrop Lake) also showed increased algal abundance, linked to aeolian nutrient inputs from industrial activities.
  • Helen Lake Stability: One larger, circumneutral lake (Helen Lake) showed no significant change in pigment signatures over the past 300 years, serving as a reference.
  • Recovery Signs: Recent declines in sedimentary pigments in George Lake and Bell Lake suggest potential chemical and biological recovery since the mid-1980s.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Pigment Preservation: The authors acknowledge that pigment deposition can be influenced by factors like phytoplankton depth (affecting preservation) and herbivory (which can concentrate pigments). This can confound inferences of increased whole-lake algal abundance.
  • Taxonomic Resolution: While pigments provide good taxonomic clues, the lability of some pigments (e.g., peridinin from dinoflagellates) limits their use in reconstructing the full algal community.
  • Inter-annual Resolution: Visible laminae were absent in the sediment cores, preventing finer inter-annual resolution of pigment stratigraphies.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that further research could explore the specific mechanisms driving the increased abundance of deepwater and benthic algae, as well as the implications of these altered food web bases for higher trophic levels and overall ecosystem resilience. Investigating the role of climate change in conjunction with acidification is also a promising avenue.

Summary updated

Abstract

A century of cultural acidification is hypothesized to have altered algal community structure in boreal lakes. To date, this hypothesis has remained untested because of both the lack of data predating the onset of industrial pollution and incomplete estimates of whole-lake algal community structure. High-pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) of sedimentary pigments was used to quantify whole-lake algal responses to acid deposition in six boreal lakes located in Killarney Park, Ontario, Canada. Concomitant significant increases in chlorophyll and carotenoid concentrations, diatom-inferred lake acidity, and metal levels since 1900 suggested that algal abundances in four acidified lakes and one small, circumneutral lake were enhanced by aerial pollution. An alternate explanation is that increased acidity and underwater light availability in the acidified lakes shifted algal abundance towards phytobenthos and deepwater phytoplankton, whose pigment signatures were better preserved in the sediments. Taxonomically diagnostic pigment stratigraphies were consistent with shifts in algal community structure towards filamentous green phytobenthos and deepwater phytoflagellates in the acidified lakes. Our findings suggest that decades of aerial pollution have altered the base of foodwebs in boreal lakes, potentially rendering them less resilient to other environmental stressors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{vinebrooke2002whole,
  author = {Rolf D. Vinebrooke and Sushil S. Dixit and Mark D. Graham and John M. Gunn and Yuwei Chen and Nelson Belzile},
  title = {{Whole-lake algal responses to a century of acidic industrial deposition on the Canadian Shield}},
  booktitle = {Canadian},
  year = {2002},
  doi = {10.1139/f02-025},
}
Figure