Who Sees UFOs? The Relationship Between Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena Sightings and Personality Factors

Daniel Stubbings, Sophie Ali, Alexander WongJournal of Scientific Exploration 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study challenges the "neurotic witness" stereotype by finding that people who report Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP) are generally psychologically stable and often possess "admirable" traits like high openness and conscientiousness. The research suggests that personality factors alone are an insufficient explanation for sightings, which remain vastly underreported due to persistent social stigma.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, the psychological "status quo" hypothesis has suggested that UFO/UAP sightings are primarily the result of individual differences—specifically, that witnesses are likely "fantasy-prone," neurotic, or prone to unusual perceptual experiences (schizotypy). This creates a significant barrier to scientific inquiry: if witnesses are dismissed as "unreliable" by default, the underlying phenomena are never seriously investigated.

The authors aim to determine if UAP witnesses actually differ from the general population in terms of the "Big Five" personality traits and schizotypy. They also seek to quantify the "reporting gap"—how many sightings go unrecorded—and compare civilian descriptions to recently declassified military data to see if the two groups are seeing the same things.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional survey of 206 participants (103 who reported a sighting and 103 who did not). They utilized three primary psychometric instruments:

  • Big Five Inventory (BFI): Measuring Extraversion, Agreeableness, Conscientiousness, Neuroticism, and Openness.
  • Schizotypal Personality Questionnaire-Brief Revised (SPQ-BRU): To identify traits related to "atypical" perceptions or disorganized thinking.
  • Extra-terrestrial Belief Scale (EBS): To control for existing biases regarding alien visitation.

The study's novel analytical approach involved Latent Profile Analysis (LPA). Rather than just looking at individual traits, LPA allowed the researchers to cluster participants into "types" or profiles based on how their traits intersected. They then used Logistic Regression to see which profiles or specific traits best predicted a UAP sighting.

Datasets

The primary dataset consisted of original survey data from 206 individuals recruited via "UFOTwitter" (now X). While this introduces a self-selection bias, it provided a high-density sample of both "experiencers" and interested "non-experiencers."

For qualitative comparison, the authors used data from the All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO), which contains UAP sighting characteristics reported by U.S. military personnel.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "O-ACE" Profile: The most surprising finding was that the group most likely to report a UAP was the "O-ACE" cluster—individuals high in Openness, Agreeableness, Conscientiousness, and Extraversion, but low in Neuroticism and Schizotypy. These are generally considered "grounded" and "resilient" individuals.
  • Neuroticism is a Negative Predictor: Contrary to the "crazy person" stereotype, Neuroticism was actually negatively related to sightings. For every one standard deviation increase in neuroticism, the odds of having a UAP sighting decreased by 35.6%.
  • The Reporting Iceberg: Only 28% of witnesses reported their sightings anywhere (including social media), and only 14% reported to a formal UAP organization. The primary barriers were a lack of known reporting channels and the fear of social stigma.
  • Civilian vs. Military Alignment: Civilian descriptions (orbs, spheres, triangles) closely mirrored the 2023 AARO military data. For example, 56% of civilian sightings were "orb/round/sphere/star-like," compared to 60% in military reports.

Key Results

  • Predictive Power: Logistic regression showed that Openness (OR = 1.524) and Neuroticism (OR = 0.644) were the only significant personality predictors of a sighting.
  • Group Differences: The "O-ACE" group had significantly higher UAP sightings (64.9%) compared to the "Average" group (44.3%) and the "Neurotic/Schizotypy" group (39.4%).
  • Belief vs. Sighting: While witnesses were more likely to believe in alien visitation ($p < .001$), personality traits only explained about 2.3% to 5.1% of the variation in sightings, suggesting that "who you are" doesn't explain "what you saw."

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size and Bias: $N=206$ is relatively small for LPA. Recruiting from Twitter likely skewed the sample toward people already interested in the topic.
  • Credibility Assessment: The study relied on self-reports without independent verification of the sightings (e.g., radar data or multiple witnesses).
  • Cross-sectional Design: The study cannot determine if a sighting changes a person's personality or if certain personalities are simply more likely to notice (or report) anomalies.

Future Work: The authors suggest larger, geographically stratified samples and the inclusion of measures for "gullibility" and "suggestibility" to further refine the psychological profile of witnesses. They also call for standardized, non-stigmatized reporting mechanisms to close the massive data gap.

Summary updated

Abstract

Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP) have become a serious topic in the US Congress, and new legislation has been released outlining a plan for declassification for the public. There are numerous factors that could lead an individual to mistakenly think they saw a UAP, and one of those factors might be the proclivities of the personalities that observe what they think to be a UAP. This study examined the big five personality traits: extraversion, neuroticism, openness, agreeableness, and conscientiousness, as well as schizotypy traits, to see if UAP experiencers could be distinguished from people who had not seen a UAP. The study included 206 participants, with 103 people who self-reported to have seen a UAP. Latent profile analysis was conducted on the personality variables to explore the grouping of participants. Group one was average on the traits, a second cluster was labeled as the Neurotic/Schizotypy group, which was high in neuroticism and schizotypy traits, and a third group was labeled as O-ACE, which were high on openness, agreeableness, conscientiousness, and extraversion but low on neuroticism and schizotypy traits. The findings indicated that the O-ACE group was more likely to see UAP, but this effect was not strong. A presumptuous stereotype exists in the general public that people who see UAP are probably people who are emotionally reactive (neurotic) and vulnerable to perceptual and cognitive abnormalities, but this was not evident in our data. We also found that the descriptive UAP accounts by the general public were similar to the descriptions provided by military witnesses. It was also of note that only 28% of participants reported their sightings anywhere, and 14% used a UFO reporting organization, which suggests that events are vastly underreported. Stigma and a lack of places to legitimately report sightings appeared to be primary barriers. The conclusion of this study is that personality factors are an insufficient explanation for most UAP sightings.
BibTeX
@article{stubbings2024who,
  author = {Daniel Stubbings and Sophie Ali and Alexander Wong},
  title = {{Who Sees UFOs? The Relationship Between Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena Sightings and Personality Factors}},
  journal = {Journal of Scientific Exploration},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.31275/20243153},
}
Figure