TL;DR
This study quantifies food waste in 78 Italian primary school canteens, finding that 21.7% of prepared food is wasted daily. The research establishes a large-scale, standardized dataset for Italy, crucial for tracking progress in reducing food waste at the consumption stage.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Food waste is a significant global issue, with advanced economies seeing the majority of waste occur at the consumption stage. In the EU, food service accounts for a substantial portion of this waste. While efforts are underway to measure and reduce food waste, there's a need for reliable, comparable data, especially from large-scale studies in specific sectors like school canteens. These settings are critical for shaping future generations' food habits. Previous studies have often used varying methodologies, making direct comparisons difficult. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing a comprehensive, methodologically sound assessment of food waste in Italian primary schools, offering a benchmark for future research and policy.
Methods
The study employed a direct assessment method, meticulously weighing food waste using electronic scales. This approach is consistent with validated food waste assessment operations and the EU's standardized methodology (EC Delegated Decision 2019/1597). Data collection involved weighing:
- Prepared food: The total amount of food made ready for serving.
- Plate waste: Food left uneaten on children's plates.
- Unserved food: Food that was prepared but not served (surplus servings) or entirely rejected by diners.
- Recovered food: Food that was not consumed but redistributed for human consumption (e.g., bread and fruit taken by teachers for later distribution).
The methodology aimed to minimize bias by not informing children about the study's true purpose and by having food service staff, teachers, and students involved in data collection, with researchers providing remote supervision. Statistical analyses were performed using R, employing Mann-Whitney and Kruskal-Wallis tests for group comparisons and Pearson's correlation for relationships between variables.
Datasets
The study utilized data collected from 78 primary schools across three Italian regions (Emilia-Romagna, Lazio, and Friuli-Venezia Giulia) during the 2016/2017 school year. This involved monitoring approximately 110,656 meals served to over 11,518 students. The paper presents a detailed dataset of per capita food waste, broken down by dish type, food category, and region. This dataset is highlighted as the largest sample size ever analyzed in Italy for this type of research, adhering to EU standards, and intended to serve as a reference for Eurostat reporting.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Standardization is Key: The paper strongly emphasizes the importance of using standardized methodologies (like the one adopted from the EC) for comparable data collection across different regions and countries. This is crucial for effective policy-making and tracking progress.
- School Canteens as a Microcosm: School canteens are not just about feeding children; they are a vital environment for shaping food habits and promoting sustainability. Interventions here can have long-term impacts.
- Beyond Plate Waste: The study highlights that food waste encompasses more than just what's left on plates. Unserved food and recovered food are significant components that need to be accounted for in a comprehensive assessment.
- The "Why" Matters: While quantifying waste is essential, understanding the underlying causes (as explored in their previous work) is critical for developing targeted reduction strategies. Factors like menu palatability, kitchen location, and even the provision of mid-morning snacks play a role.
Key Results
- Overall Waste: An average of 21.7% of prepared food was wasted at lunch.
- Per Capita Waste:
- Plate waste: Approximately 90 g/day per capita.
- Total food waste (including unserved food): Approximately 117 g/day per capita.
- Food Categories Wasted Most:
- Fruit and processed fruit (43.9% of non-consumed food).
- Bakery products, mainly bread (41.8%).
- Vegetables and legumes (31.8%).
- Regional Differences: Significant differences in food waste were observed across regions, with Emilia-Romagna and Lazio showing higher waste than Friuli-Venezia Giulia.
- Kitchen Location Impact: Schools with internal kitchens had significantly lower food waste (96.2 g/day per capita) compared to those using external catering services (130.8 g/day per capita).
- Menu Seasonality: Winter menus were associated with higher plate waste (90.5 g/day) than summer menus (74.6 g/day).
- Mid-Morning Snack Influence: Schools where children brought snacks from home had higher plate waste (99.7 g/day) than those where snacks were provided by the service provider (76.8 g/day).
Limitations and Future Work
- Inclusion of Staff Waste: For simplification, food waste from school staff and food service personnel (6.8% of participants) was included in the analysis.
- Self-Reporting Bias: The use of a self-reporting technique by teachers could introduce misreporting due to forgetfulness or guilt. However, the study notes that children's curiosity and direct involvement, along with supervisory measures, likely mitigated this.
- Observer Effect: While efforts were made to minimize it, the progressive exposure of children to monitoring procedures could potentially influence their behavior.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that fully automated measurement systems could overcome some limitations and reduce the burden of manual data collection. They also highlight the need for interventions that balance nutritional recommendations with palatability and address social factors influencing waste. Further research could explore the impact of peer influence and dining group size more deeply.
Summary updated