TL;DR
This paper proposes a quantitative, GIS-based approach to delineate protection scopes for the Kaiping Diaolou and Villages World Heritage site, focusing on the "integrity principle." By analyzing the spatial organization and hierarchical defensive functions of these unique structures, the study reveals that current preservation boundaries may be inadequate, potentially overlooking crucial aspects of their cultural value.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The UNESCO World Heritage Convention emphasizes the "integrity principle" when defining protection scopes, meaning that a site must include all necessary elements to express its Outstanding Universal Value (OUV). However, the practical application of this principle, especially for cultural heritage sites with complex spatial organizations, remains a challenge. The Kaiping Diaolou and Villages (KDVs) in China, a UNESCO World Heritage site, exemplify this. While recognized for their unique architecture and defensive functions against bandits, existing preservation plans primarily focus on architectural value and overlook the integrated defensive system formed by different types of Diaolou buildings (Genglou, Zhonglou, Julou) and their spatial relationships. This oversight can lead to an underestimation of the OUV and a failure to fully capture the site's cultural sustainability. The paper aims to address this gap by developing a method to spatially delineate protection scopes that better reflect the integrity of the KDVs' defensive system.
Methods
The study employs a multi-step, quantitative approach using Geographic Information Science (GIS) and statistical analysis:
- Delineating Defensive Regions: The core of the methodology involves defining "defensive regions" as the basic organizational units of the Diaolou's defensive function. This is achieved by:
- Creating Thiessen polygons around each "Genglou" (the largest type of defensive structure) to initially allocate village space.
- Calculating the maximum defensive distance from a Genglou (determined to be 1.8 km based on historical analysis) to create buffer areas.
- Overlapping Thiessen polygons and buffer areas, then adjusting boundaries based on village patches to ensure Genglous protect at least one entire village.
- Considering river shorelines as additional boundaries and merging overlapping defensive regions from pairs of Genglous (Zhalou). This process results in 150 distinct defensive regions.
- Classifying Defensive Regions: Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and hierarchical clustering are used to categorize these defensive regions based on attributes like the number of Zhonglous and Julous, distance to roads/rivers/towns, terrain height difference, regional area, and population density. This analysis identifies three principal components (F1, F2, F3) that capture these variations.
- Typology and Evaluation: The clustered regions, along with a pre-identified Type-1 category (Genglou-only regions), are grouped into four distinct types of defensive regions (Type-1 to Type-4), reflecting different defensive hierarchies and characteristics. Finally, these newly defined defensive regions are overlaid with the existing WHC-delineated protection scopes to evaluate their adequacy in representing the integrity of the defensive system.
Datasets
- Kaiping Diaolou Data: The study utilizes data from the Census of Kaiping Diaolou (2001), the Map of Kaiping Diaolou (2004), and the Kaiping Diaolou Directory (2004). This includes information on 1629 Diaolous, detailing their location, ownership, use, and architectural features.
- Geographical Data: Basic geographical elements such as roads, rivers, and village patches from the Kaiping area were used.
- Official WHC Documents: The study references official documents from the World Heritage Convention (WHC), including the Operational Guidelines and protection plans for Kaiping Diaolou and Villages.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Defensive System as OUV: The paper strongly argues that the spatial organization and hierarchical nature of the Diaolou defensive system are integral to their Outstanding Universal Value (OUV) and must be considered for effective heritage preservation.
- Typology Matters: Different types of Diaolous (Genglou, Zhonglou, Julou) have distinct defensive roles (public, sub-public, private), forming a complex system. Ignoring this typology leads to an incomplete understanding of the heritage.
- Current Scopes are Insufficient: Existing protection scopes, primarily based on architectural value, fail to encompass all types of defensive regions (specifically Type-1) and often cut across natural defensive boundaries, breaking the integrity of the system.
- GIS as a Powerful Tool: GIS-based spatial analysis is demonstrated as a crucial tool for objectively identifying and delineating complex spatial relationships and functional areas within heritage sites, moving beyond purely architectural assessments.
Key Results
- 150 Defensive Regions Identified: The GIS analysis successfully delineated 150 distinct defensive regions across Kaiping.
- Four Types of Defensive Regions: The study categorized these regions into four types (Type-1 to Type-4), representing varying levels of defensive hierarchy and reliance on different Diaolou types.
- Type-1 Regions Overlooked: A significant finding is that current WHC protection scopes do not include Type-1 defensive regions, which are characterized by sole reliance on Genglous for public defense and are often found in less developed areas.
- Boundary Mismatches: The boundaries of existing conservation zones do not align with the identified defensive region boundaries, leading to fragmentation of the defensive system. For example, the Zili Village, Majianglong Village, and Jinjiangli Village areas are shown to cut integral defensive regions into pieces.
Limitations and Future Work
- Historical Data Limitations: The identification of defensive region boundaries relied on Thiessen polygon analysis due to a lack of detailed historical data on village boundaries. Future work aims to recover more accurate historical village boundaries from ancient maps and local chronicles to improve boundary integrity.
- Focus on Defensive Function: The current study primarily focuses on the spatial organization of the defensive function. Future research will integrate architecture-level defensive features and explore protection technologies for a more comprehensive evaluation of typology and element integrity.
- Non-Public Defensive Areas: The paper notes that more attention should be paid to non-public defensive areas that might not have Genglous but are protected by other Diaolou types.
- Environmental Monitoring: The authors suggest integrating environmental monitoring systems to ensure the feasibility and environmental friendliness of delineated protection scopes.
Summary updated