Where Have All the Kaczmarz Iterates Gone?

El Houcine Bergou, Soumia Boucherouite, Aritra Dutta, Xin Li, Anna MaarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

The Randomized Kaczmarz (RK) algorithm is a cornerstone of large-scale linear algebra, prized for its efficiency in solving systems of the form $Ax = b$ by iteratively projecting estimates onto the solution space of individual rows. While its convergence is well-mapped for consistent systems, real-world data is rarely perfect. This research provides a definitive map for the "final destination" of RK iterates when they encounter noisy, inconsistent systems.

The Optimal Convergence Horizon

A central question in stochastic optimization is where an algorithm "stalls" when a perfect solution doesn't exist. Previous theories suggested that RK iterates approach a ball around the "true" solution of an underlying noiseless system. However, this work proves a more precise and tighter result: the iterates are most strongly attracted to the least-squares solution ($\tilde{x}_{LS}$) of the actual noisy system.

Geometric representation of the convergence horizon. The iterates are attracted to a ball centered at the least-squares solution $\tilde{x}_{LS}$, which provides the tightest possible description of the convergence region.

By treating the choice of the ball's center as a minimization problem, the authors demonstrate that $\tilde{x}_{LS}$ is the optimal center that yields the smallest possible radius, or "convergence horizon." This horizon is a fundamental property of the system's noise and geometry, remaining consistent regardless of the starting point $x_0$.

Geometric Dynamics and Filtering

The path these iterates take is not random wandering. By decomposing the error into components along the singular vectors of the matrix, the authors reveal a "filtering" effect. The RK algorithm resolves components associated with large singular values rapidly. As the process continues, the remaining error becomes dominated by directions corresponding to the smallest singular values.

3D trajectories of RK iterates. (a) shows the path from $x_0$ toward the solution line, while (b) illustrates the clustering around the least-squares solution $x_{LS}$ as the algorithm reaches its noise floor.

In inconsistent systems, the noise introduces a residual term dependent on the left singular vectors. This term effectively sets the "noise floor"—the limit of how accurate the algorithm can become before it begins to oscillate within the convergence horizon.

Empirical Validation and Impact

The theoretical bounds derived in this paper—specifically the explicit formulas for expected error at each step—were validated against both synthetic Gaussian matrices and large-scale real-world benchmarks from the LIBSVM library (e.g., a1a, w1a, dna). These experiments confirmed that the new bounds are remarkably tight, offering a much more accurate prediction of empirical performance than previous square-root estimates.

Conclusion

By identifying the least-squares solution as the true attractor for Randomized Kaczmarz iterates, this work moves beyond vague "neighborhood" descriptions to a rigorous geometric understanding of the algorithm's behavior in the presence of noise. This insight not only clarifies the limits of RK but also opens doors for future work in pre-conditioning noisy systems to reach this optimal horizon even faster.

Summary updated

Abstract

The randomized Kaczmarz (RK) algorithm is one of the most computationally and memory-efficient iterative algorithms for solving large-scale linear systems. However, practical applications often involve noisy and potentially inconsistent systems. While the convergence of RK is well understood for consistent systems, the study of RK on noisy, inconsistent linear systems is limited. This paper investigates the asymptotic behavior of RK iterates in expectation when solving noisy and inconsistent systems, addressing the locations of their limit points. We explore the roles of singular vectors of the (noisy) coefficient matrix and derive bounds on the convergence horizon, which depend on the noise levels and system characteristics. Finally, we provide extensive numerical experiments that validate our theoretical findings, offering practical insights into the algorithm's performance under realistic conditions. These results establish a deeper understanding of the RK algorithm's limitations and robustness in noisy environments, paving the way for optimized applications in real-world scientific and engineering problems.
BibTeX
@misc{bergou2025where,
  author = {El Houcine Bergou and Soumia Boucherouite and Aritra Dutta and Xin Li and Anna Ma},
  title = {{Where Have All the Kaczmarz Iterates Gone?}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2510.08563},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.08563},
}
Figure