Where did you hear that? Narrative Competition and Societal Instability in Burkina Faso

Richard Wolfel, Christiana Fairfield, Amy Richmond, Rick Grannis, Scott Womack, Daniel Moriarty, Pete Grazaitis, Enhua WuScientia 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Military coups are rarely random "black swan" events. Instead, they represent the predictable result of significant shocks to a societal system, particularly catastrophic in nations with high levels of vulnerability. In these contexts, global powers often engage in "narrative competitions"—sophisticated information campaigns designed to project influence by manipulating local sociocultural and economic triggers. This study utilizes the Modeling Dense Urban Networks (MDUN) analytical model to examine how these triggers influenced public opinion and led to the 2022 military coups in Burkina Faso.

Introduction: The Problem of Regime Change

Traditional political science often struggles to predict sudden regime changes, frequently treating them as isolated incidents or macro-economic failures. However, this approach overlooks the "sociocultural fabric" of a nation—the specific triggers like ethnic tension, distrust of government, and anti-colonial sentiment. In a "multidomain" geopolitical environment, global powers such as Russia, China, and France use information campaigns to push vulnerable societies toward a "critical phase transition," potentially triggering a social catastrophe without a single shot being fired by the intervening power.

Regional Context and the Sahel Crisis

Burkina Faso exists within a region of intense societal vulnerability. Economic inequalities, environmental security issues, and the ongoing conflict in the Sahel have created a fertile ground for instability.

Satellite map of West Africa highlighting Burkina Faso and the surrounding Sahel region.

The distrust of the central government and the former colonial power, France, are internal factors that strongly influenced the two military coups in 2022. External actors have co-opted these grievances; for instance, Russian information campaigns framed France as a "colonial milk cow" while positioning Russia as a "savior," successfully shifting public sentiment toward accepting authoritarian "putschists" as legitimate alternatives.

Methodology: The MDUN Framework

The researchers employed the Modeling Dense Urban Networks (MDUN) analytical tool, a sociological situational awareness model. The model's technical core includes:

  • Entropy Indexing: Measuring "emergent disorder" where high entropy indicates a system vulnerable to collapse.
  • AI-Driven Weighting: Utilizing an AI routine trained on 320 global events to determine the best weightings for sociocultural inputs.
  • Multidimensional Analysis: Tracking 12 dimensions (e.g., Xenophobia, Lack of Confidence in Government, Desire for Income Redistribution) visualized via radar charts.
  • Theoretical Grounding: Results are interpreted through Binder’s (1964) model of political development, categorizing societal health into networks of production, identity, legitimacy, participation, penetration, and allocation.

To feed this model, the study integrated over 20 diverse datasets, including ACLED for conflict data, Afrobarometer for public opinion, and World Bank indices for socioeconomics.

Key Results: Forecasting the 2022 Coup

The MDUN model demonstrated remarkable predictive power. While macro-level indicators in mid-2022 suggested stability, the MDUN’s micro-level analysis of individual perceptions revealed a hidden, rapid decline.

On June 13, 2022, the team projected conditions for the following seven months. The model predicted a "critical" lack of confidence in the government for September 2022—the exact month the second military coup occurred. Between June and September, the "Lack of Confidence in Government" score rose by approximately 40%, crossing the criticality threshold. Furthermore, the model captured a significant rise in anti-French sentiment, which served as a leading indicator for the eventual expulsion of French Special Operations forces in early 2023.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The study proves that societal collapses can be forecasted by monitoring the intersection of local vulnerabilities and external narrative manipulation. One of the most striking findings was the rapid transition of the "Need for National Sovereignty" from a stable to a critical metric, fueled by dissatisfaction with foreign control of the mining industry and security failures.

Future defense strategies must focus as much on the "information environment" as on physical security. While the MDUN provides a powerful forecasting tool, the next challenge lies in developing effective non-kinetic intervention strategies to counter-narratives before they reach a point of systemic failure.

Summary updated

Abstract

Coups do not occur randomly. They are the result of significant shocks, or triggers, to a societal system, which is especially catastrophic in societies with high levels of vulnerability. It is often in this context of high vulnerability that global powers act to gain influence throughout the world. Narrative competitions, or information campaigns, are becoming increasingly important as an approach to projecting influence at international scale. Socio-cultural and economic triggers of societal instability are critical spaces where narrative and indirect competitions occur. Explaining how competitors manipulate these country-specific triggers as part of an influence campaign is essential to understanding modern geopolitics. The study on which this article reports, used the Modeling Dense Urban Networks analytical model to explain the influence of economic, geographical, and political changes on the opinion of the local population on crucial societal tipping points in Burkina Faso. Burkina Faso is a region with intense societal vulnerability due to economic inequalities, regional instability brought on by the ongoing conflict in the Sahel, significant environmental security issues, and a distrust of the government and the former colonial power, France. These internal factors of instability strongly influenced the two military coups in 2022. In addition to the internal factors of instability, Burkina Faso is an area of powerful competition between several global powers, each providing a narrative to manipulate societal opinion around these local issues of vulnerability to promote their influence in Burkina Faso at the expense of their adversaries.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wolfel2024where,
  author = {Richard Wolfel and Christiana Fairfield and Amy Richmond and Rick Grannis and Scott Womack and Daniel Moriarty and Pete Grazaitis and Enhua Wu},
  title = {{Where did you hear that? Narrative Competition and Societal Instability in Burkina Faso}},
  booktitle = {Scientia},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.5787/52-3-1483},
}
Figure