When Overweight Is the Normal Weight: An Examination of Obesity Using a Social Media Internet Database

Meghan Kuebler, Elad Yom‐Tov, Dan Pelleg, Rebecca M. Puhl, Peter MuennigPLoS 2013 · DOI

Abstract

Using a large social media database, Yahoo Answers, we explored postings to an online forum in which posters asked whether their height and weight qualify themselves as "skinny," "thin," "fat," or "obese" over time and across forum topics. We used these data to better understand whether a higher-than-average body mass index (BMI) in one's county might, in some ways, be protective for one's mental and physical health. For instance, we explored whether higher proportions of obese people in one's county predicts lower levels of bullying or "am I fat?" questions from those with a normal BMI relative to his/her actual BMI. Most women asking whether they were themselves fat/obese were not actually fat/obese. Both men and women who were actually overweight/obese were significantly more likely in the future to ask for advice about bullying than thinner individuals. Moreover, as mean county-level BMI increased, bullying decreased and then increased again (in a U-shape curve). Regardless of where they lived, posters who asked "am I fat?" who had a BMI in the healthy range were more likely than other posters to subsequently post on health problems, but the proportions of such posters also declined greatly as county-level BMI increased. Our findings suggest that obese people residing in counties with higher levels of BMI may have better physical and mental health than obese people living in counties with lower levels of BMI by some measures, but these improvements are modest.

Introduction

Obesity is a major public health challenge, but its impact extends beyond physiology into deep psychological and social territories. Traditional research often relies on formal surveys, which can suffer from "social desirability bias"—the tendency for participants to underreport weight or mask insecurities. This study bypasses these limitations by analyzing "natural" data from anonymous internet queries on Yahoo Answers. The researchers sought to test the "normative" hypothesis: does living in a community where a higher body mass index (BMI) is the average provide a protective buffer against weight-related stigma and body image distortion?

Methods and Data

The researchers employed an automated approach to mine data from Yahoo Answers, focusing on users asking questions such as "Am I fat?" or "Am I obese?". The methodology involved:

  1. Extraction: Identifying users via term matching for weight-related inquiries.
  2. Data Mining: Extracting self-reported age, gender, height, and weight from post text to calculate actual BMI.
  3. Geospatial Linking: Connecting users to U.S. counties using anonymized zip code data.
  4. Longitudinal Tracking: Monitoring subsequent posts by the same users regarding bullying, diabetes, or mental health.

The primary dataset included 3,926 unique users with complete anthropomorphic data. This was supplemented by CDC county-level obesity data, 2000 US Census income data, and a larger subset of 43,219 questions explicitly mentioning "bullying."

Key Results

The Gender Perception Gap

Analysis revealed a massive disparity in weight perception between genders. Among those asking "Am I fat?", 68% of men met medical criteria for being overweight or obese, compared to only 40% of women. Most women inquiring about their weight were actually within a healthy BMI range.

Table showing the distribution of weight inquiries by gender and BMI category.

The "Normative" Buffer and Bullying

In counties with higher average BMIs, individuals demonstrated more accurate weight self-categorization. Normal-weight individuals in these areas were less likely to unnecessarily ask if they were fat, suggesting a higher local "weight ceiling" reduces body image distortion.

Social experiences also varied by local norms. Bullying risk followed a U-shaped curve: it was high in very thin counties, decreased as the county BMI reached a middle ground, and increased again in the highest-BMI counties. Regardless of location, individuals who were medically overweight or obese remained significantly more likely to post about being bullied than their thinner counterparts.

Likelihood of bullying relative to county-level obesity percentage.

Health Concerns and Psychological Stress

Weight perception served as a proxy for broader health anxieties. Healthy-weight individuals who perceived themselves as fat were significantly more likely to post about future health problems, including mental health issues and heart disease. For those medically classified as overweight or obese, specific health concerns were prevalent: women were more likely to post about infertility and parenting, while men were 4.6 times more likely to post about diabetes.

Discussion and Limitations

While the study suggests that a high-BMI environment may offer modest protective effects against certain types of stigma, obesity continues to carry significant health and social burdens. The findings are subject to several limitations, including a demographic bias toward younger Yahoo Answers users and the inherent self-selection of individuals already expressing weight-related insecurity. Furthermore, as an observational study, it establishes correlation rather than direct causality. Future research should explore whether these trends persist across other evolving social media platforms.

Summary updated

Abstract

Using a large social media database, Yahoo Answers, we explored postings to an online forum in which posters asked whether their height and weight qualify themselves as "skinny," "thin," "fat," or "obese" over time and across forum topics. We used these data to better understand whether a higher-than-average body mass index (BMI) in one's county might, in some ways, be protective for one's mental and physical health. For instance, we explored whether higher proportions of obese people in one's county predicts lower levels of bullying or "am I fat?" questions from those with a normal BMI relative to his/her actual BMI. Most women asking whether they were themselves fat/obese were not actually fat/obese. Both men and women who were actually overweight/obese were significantly more likely in the future to ask for advice about bullying than thinner individuals. Moreover, as mean county-level BMI increased, bullying decreased and then increased again (in a U-shape curve). Regardless of where they lived, posters who asked "am I fat?" who had a BMI in the healthy range were more likely than other posters to subsequently post on health problems, but the proportions of such posters also declined greatly as county-level BMI increased. Our findings suggest that obese people residing in counties with higher levels of BMI may have better physical and mental health than obese people living in counties with lower levels of BMI by some measures, but these improvements are modest.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kuebler2013when,
  author = {Meghan Kuebler and Elad Yom‐Tov and Dan Pelleg and Rebecca M. Puhl and Peter Muennig},
  title = {{When Overweight Is the Normal Weight: An Examination of Obesity Using a Social Media Internet Database}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0073479},
}
Figure