When Neuroscience ‘Touches’ Architecture: From Hapticity to a Supramodal Functioning of the Human Brain

Paolo Papale, Leonardo Chiesi, Alessandra Rampinini, Pietro Pietrini, Emiliano RicciardiFrontiers in Psychology 2016 · DOI

Abstract

In the last decades, the rapid growth of functional brain imaging methodologies allowed cognitive neuroscience to address open questions in philosophy and social sciences. At the same time, novel insights from cognitive neuroscience research have begun to influence various disciplines, leading to a turn to cognition and emotion in the fields of planning and architectural design. Since 2003, the Academy of Neuroscience for Architecture has been supporting 'neuro-architecture' as a way to connect neuroscience and the study of behavioral responses to the built environment. Among the many topics related to multisensory perceptual integration and embodiment, the concept of hapticity was recently introduced, suggesting a pivotal role of tactile perception and haptic imagery in architectural appraisal. Arguments have thus risen in favor of the existence of shared cognitive foundations between hapticity and the supramodal functional architecture of the human brain. Precisely, supramodality refers to the functional feature of defined brain regions to process and represent specific information content in a more abstract way, independently of the sensory modality conveying such information to the brain. Here, we highlight some commonalities and differences between the concepts of hapticity and supramodality according to the distinctive perspectives of architecture and cognitive neuroscience. This comparison and connection between these two different approaches may lead to novel observations in regard to people-environment relationships, and even provide empirical foundations for a renewed evidence-based design theory.

Introduction

This perspective paper bridges the gap between architectural theory and cognitive neuroscience by linking the concept of hapticity—the tactile-based appreciation of space—to the brain's supramodal functional architecture. It argues that our experience of buildings is inherently multisensory, with specific brain regions processing spatial and structural information regardless of whether that information is seen or felt.

The Challenge of Ocularcentrism

For decades, architecture has been criticized for being "ocularcentric," or overly focused on visual aesthetics at the expense of other senses. While theorists like Juhani Pallasmaa have long argued for "hapticity"—the idea that we "touch" buildings with our eyes through the integration of tactile and visual imagery—these ideas lacked a firm neurobiological foundation.

The challenge is to provide an empirical basis for "neuro-architecture." This involves explaining how the brain translates visual cues—such as the texture of a stone wall or the curve of a vaulted ceiling—into a rich, embodied experience that feels physical and emotional, rather than just a flat image.

Hapticity and the Supramodal Brain

The most critical insight is that the human brain is not a collection of isolated sensory boxes. Instead, it features a "supramodal" organization. For example, the lateral occipital complex (traditionally viewed as a visual area) activates when both sighted people see an object and blind people touch it. The brain prioritizes the content (the shape or texture) over the format (light vs. pressure).

Visual cues like textures and shapes (A) convey tactile information, which is central to the appreciation of complex architectural facades like the Casa Milà (B).

Hapticity serves as the architectural manifestation of this supramodal processing. When we look at a textured facade, our brain recruits tactile imagery to "feel" the surface, creating a deeper sense of presence. Studies on blind individuals prove that the brain's functional architecture for processing space and objects develops independently of visual experience. This suggests that "visual" areas are actually "information-processing" areas that are simply usually fed by the eyes in sighted people.

Implications for Evidence-Based Design

The paper provides a qualitative framework for a renewed evidence-based design theory by identifying specific brain regions (ventral temporo-occipital, middle temporal, and dorsal occipito-parietal) as the neural correlates of hapticity. These areas process object form, motion, and spatial representation supramodally.

Furthermore, haptic perception is often more effective than vision at determining a "sense of presence"—the feeling of being truly immersed in an environment. While vision provides a global view from a distance, touch (and haptic imagery) provides the intimacy required for emotional involvement. Moving toward "sensory intensification"—designing for multiple senses—can lead to a more humanized architecture that fosters a stronger emotional bond between people and their environment.

Limitations and Future Directions

While promising, the "neuro-turn" faces skepticism from those who fear it might lead to deterministic or stereotyped design. Additionally, terms like "hapticity" must be more precisely defined and tested to move beyond evocative labels toward rigorous scientific investigation. Future research should characterize which specific visual and haptic cues evoke similar neural patterns, allowing architects to intentionally design spaces that trigger specific supramodal responses.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the last decades, the rapid growth of functional brain imaging methodologies allowed cognitive neuroscience to address open questions in philosophy and social sciences. At the same time, novel insights from cognitive neuroscience research have begun to influence various disciplines, leading to a turn to cognition and emotion in the fields of planning and architectural design. Since 2003, the Academy of Neuroscience for Architecture has been supporting 'neuro-architecture' as a way to connect neuroscience and the study of behavioral responses to the built environment. Among the many topics related to multisensory perceptual integration and embodiment, the concept of hapticity was recently introduced, suggesting a pivotal role of tactile perception and haptic imagery in architectural appraisal. Arguments have thus risen in favor of the existence of shared cognitive foundations between hapticity and the supramodal functional architecture of the human brain. Precisely, supramodality refers to the functional feature of defined brain regions to process and represent specific information content in a more abstract way, independently of the sensory modality conveying such information to the brain. Here, we highlight some commonalities and differences between the concepts of hapticity and supramodality according to the distinctive perspectives of architecture and cognitive neuroscience. This comparison and connection between these two different approaches may lead to novel observations in regard to people-environment relationships, and even provide empirical foundations for a renewed evidence-based design theory.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{papale2016when,
  author = {Paolo Papale and Leonardo Chiesi and Alessandra Rampinini and Pietro Pietrini and Emiliano Ricciardi},
  title = {{When Neuroscience ‘Touches’ Architecture: From Hapticity to a Supramodal Functioning of the Human Brain}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00866},
}
Figure