When apology is sincere, cooperation evolves, even when mistakes occur frequently

Tom Lenaerts, The Anh Han, Luı́s Moniz Pereira, Luis A. Martínez-VaqueroTeesRep 2017

Abstract

Evolutionary psychologists have long posited that revenge, apology, and forgiveness are moral sentiments evolved to establish and maintain long-term mutually beneficial relationships. This is particularly critical in environments where misapprehensions—intentional or not—can occur. This paper provides analytical and numerical results demonstrating that these behaviors emerge spontaneously within the context of the Iterated Prisoner’s Dilemma (IPD). Our findings reveal that apology and forgiveness are highly efficient mechanisms for sustaining cooperation, even in high-noise environments. However, for apology to be evolutionarily stable, it must be sufficiently costly; otherwise, the system becomes vulnerable to exploitation by "dishonest apologizers" who defect and apologize repeatedly without sincere intent.

Introduction

In social dilemmas like the Prisoner’s Dilemma, the tension between individual gain and collective benefit often leads to suboptimal outcomes. While pre-game commitments can foster cooperation, they are highly sensitive to "noise"—errors where a player accidentally performs the opposite of their intended action. In a rigid system, a single mistake can trigger a permanent cycle of revenge. This research models how emotional sentiments like apology and forgiveness act as error-correction mechanisms that allow cooperative relationships to recover from accidental defections.

Methodology

We employ Evolutionary Game Theory (EGT) to analyze the IPD under varying conditions. The model incorporates a commitment phase where players can pay a small cost ($\epsilon$) to propose a contract. If the contract is broken, the defector pays compensation ($\delta$). We introduce a noise parameter ($\alpha$) representing the probability of execution error and an apology mechanism ($q$) where a player can choose to apologize by paying a cost ($\gamma$).

Population dynamics were simulated using a discrete imitation dynamic based on the Fermi probability function. We calculated fixation probabilities and stationary distributions to identify which strategies dominate the population over the long term across different noise levels ($\alpha = 0.01$ and $\alpha = 0.1$).

Results and Discussion

Our simulations demonstrate that strategies incorporating apology and forgiveness are remarkably resilient to noise. As shown in the figures below, the strategy $(P, C, AllD, q=1)$—proposing commitment, cooperating, but apologizing for mistakes—becomes the dominant strategy as the cost of apology ($\gamma$) increases.

Relative frequency of strategies vs. apology cost (γ) for noise levels α=0.01 (top) and α=0.1 (bottom).

The Necessity of Costly Apology

A critical finding is the "sweet spot" for apology costs. If $\gamma$ is too low, the population is easily invaded by exploiters who defect intentionally and use the cheap apology to avoid the consequences of a broken commitment. When $\gamma$ is sufficiently high (exceeding the cost of cooperation but remaining below the commitment penalty), it serves as a reliable signal of sincerity. In these conditions, the frequency of the apology strategy (solid blue line) significantly outperforms the non-apologizing commitment strategy (dashed blue line).

Resilience to Noise

Even with a 10% error rate ($\alpha = 0.1$), the apology-based strategy maintains a high stationary distribution. This suggests that the evolution of apology and forgiveness was a functional response to the inherent uncertainty of social interactions, allowing humans to maximize long-term payoffs despite imperfect execution.

Conclusion

This model provides an explicit evolutionary basis for the moral sentiments of apology and forgiveness. By transforming a potential cycle of revenge into a restorative process, these behaviors ensure lasting cooperation. The results underscore that the "sincerity" of an apology—quantified here as its cost—is the essential feature that prevents the collapse of cooperative systems in the face of noise and exploitation.

References

Lenaerts, T., Han, T. A., Pereira, L. M., & Martinez-Vaquero, L. A. "When apology is sincere, cooperation evolves, even when mistakes occur frequently." Scientific Reports, 2015.

Summary updated

Abstract

Evolutionary psychologists have argued that revenge,
\napology and forgiveness are moral sentiments that humans acquired
\nto establish and maintain long-term mutually beneficial relationships,
\nespecially since misapprehensions, intentional or not, can always occur
\nthat could lead to worse outcomes. Their argument assumes an
\nevolutionary advantage to such emotional thinking, for which no explicit
\nmodel was available. Using the iterated prisoners dilemma as
\ncontext, we provided analytical and numerical results that show that
\nthese three behaviours emerge spontaneously, ensuring lasting cooperation
\n[16]. Concretely our work revealed that apology and forgiveness
\nare efficient even in a very noisy environment. Yet in order
\nfor apology to work, it needs to be sufficiently costly as otherwise
\nexploiting the system by defecting and apologising is the most profitable
\nbehaviour.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lenaerts2017when,
  author = {Tom Lenaerts and The Anh Han and Luı́s Moniz Pereira and Luis A. Martínez-Vaquero},
  title = {{When apology is sincere, cooperation evolves, even when mistakes occur frequently}},
  booktitle = {TeesRep},
  year = {2017},
}
Figure