What’s in a Name? Grasping New Public Governance as a Political-Administrative System

Jacob Torfing, Peter TriantafillouInternational Review of Public Administration 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a conceptual framework, based on David Easton's political systems model, to analyze and categorize "New Public Governance" (NPG). It argues that NPG represents a significant shift in how public administration operates, moving towards more participatory and collaborative approaches, and explores the challenges and opportunities this presents for modern governance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of understanding and conceptualizing the evolving landscape of public governance in liberal democracies. Scholars have observed a shift towards more participatory, interactive, and less direct forms of governing, often termed "New Public Governance" (NPG). However, this concept is seen as underdeveloped, lacking a clear analytical framework for categorization and evaluation. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a robust analytical tool to grasp the scope and impact of these changes, distinguishing NPG from previous models like Classical Public Administration (CPA) and New Public Management (NPM). They also seek to identify the key challenges NPG poses for public management and policymaking in today's complex world.

Methods

The core methodological contribution of this paper is the application and adaptation of David Easton's classical political systems model. This model, which views political systems as processing inputs (demands, support) into outputs (policies, services) through a "withinput" (institutional shaping of decision-making), is used as an analytical lens. The authors modify Easton's model to specifically analyze the characteristics of NPG, comparing and contrasting them with CPA and NPM across four key functions: input, withinput, output, and feedback. They present a table (Figure 2) that summarizes these differences, providing a structured way to identify and analyze NPG reforms. The paper also draws on existing literature and case studies to support its arguments, rather than presenting new empirical data.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • NPG as a distinct governance paradigm: The paper argues that NPG is not just a minor tweak but a distinct shift from CPA and NPM, characterized by empowered participation, multi-actor collaboration, new governance tools, and multiple forms of accountability.
  • Easton's model as a unifying framework: Applying Easton's systems model provides a consistent and comprehensive way to analyze and compare different governance approaches, moving beyond empirical observations to a more analytical understanding.
  • The "withinput" is key to NPG: The core of NPG lies in how decision-making processes are shaped, moving from bureaucratic rules (CPA) or market-like competition (NPM) to collaborative negotiation and stakeholder engagement.
  • Challenges of unequal participation: While NPG aims for broader participation, it risks reinforcing existing inequalities if not carefully managed, as those with more resources and social capital may dominate.
  • Metagovernance as a necessary layer: To navigate the complexities of NPG, a "metagovernance" layer is proposed – a strategic and political mode of governance that steers and frames the interactive processes without resorting to traditional command and control.

Key Results

The paper doesn't present quantitative results in the traditional sense. Instead, its key "results" are conceptual and analytical:

  • A refined definition of NPG: NPG is defined by its emphasis on empowered participation, multi-actor collaboration, the use of new governance tools, and diverse accountability mechanisms.
  • A comparative framework: The paper provides a clear framework (Figure 2) to distinguish NPG from CPA and NPM across the input, withinput, output, and feedback stages of the political system.
  • Identification of key challenges: The paper outlines significant challenges for NPG, including:
  • Input challenges: Mobilizing unwilling or unable citizens and civil servants, and managing unequal participation.
  • Withinput challenges: Avoiding domination by powerful actors and navigating hierarchical responsibilities in collaborative settings.
  • Output challenges: Determining problems and desirable behaviors, and developing effective collaboration for problem-solving.
  • Feedback challenges: Agreeing on accountability standards and avoiding "government overload" from multiple accountability demands.
  • The necessity of metagovernance: The authors conclude that metagovernance is crucial for effectively steering and managing NPG processes to achieve desired outcomes.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their article does not provide systematic empirical evidence, relying instead on existing studies. They suggest several avenues for future research:

  • Empirical examination of NPG: More research is needed to understand the societal, political, and administrative forces driving NPG reforms.
  • Cross-national variability: Mapping and explaining variations in NPG reforms across different countries, considering institutional and structural path-dependencies.
  • Tensions and synergies: Evaluating the interplay between CPA, NPM, and NPG, and how political power and pragmatic concerns influence the choice of governing modes.
  • Effectiveness of metagovernance: Critically assessing whether NPG contributes to effective, democratic, and innovative solutions, and how metagovernance tools can help decision-makers tackle future challenges.

Summary updated

Abstract

New participatory, interactive, and less direct forms of governing seem currently to be unfolding in many liberal democracies. Some scholars have tried to conceptualize these forms of governing by using the notion of new public governance (NPG). While promising, the notion remains conceptually underdeveloped. This article first aims to develop NPG from an empirical to an analytical concept that enables categorization and evaluation of new forms of governing. In order to gauge the full scope of the current transformations we draw on David Easton’s system theoretical model to identify the constitutive elements of NPG and show how they differ from those elements underpinning classical public administration and new public management. The second aim of the article is to delineate the main challenges that NPG poses for public management and policymaking in a complex and fragmented world. We conclude by reflecting on the need for metagovernance in order to handle the challenges and bring out the positive impact of NPG on normative performance goals such as efficiency, democracy, and innovation.
BibTeX
@article{torfing2013whats,
  author = {Jacob Torfing and Peter Triantafillou},
  title = {{What’s in a Name? Grasping New Public Governance as a Political-Administrative System}},
  journal = {International Review of Public Administration},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1080/12294659.2013.10805250},
}
Figure