What privacy concerns do parents have about children's mobile apps, and how can they stay SHARP?

Jun Zhao, Ulrik Lyngs, Nigel ShadboltarXiv 2018 · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper investigates parents' privacy concerns regarding their young children's (6-10 years old) use of mobile apps. It reveals a disconnect between parental privacy worries and their app selection criteria, with content appropriateness often taking precedence. The study proposes a "SHARP" framework to guide parents in making more informed app choices.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As children increasingly use mobile devices for education and entertainment, parents face the challenge of safeguarding their online privacy. While risks associated with social media are well-known, the privacy implications of mobile applications (apps) are less understood. Children, especially younger ones, are vulnerable to data collection by third-party marketing and advertising industries through apps, often disguised by appealing characters or free access. Existing research highlights parents' struggles in navigating this complex digital landscape and providing adequate support for their children's online safety. This paper aims to shed light on parents' specific privacy concerns and decision-making processes when choosing apps for their children, and to offer practical guidance.

Methods

The study employed an online survey of 220 parents with children aged 6-10. Participants were recruited through the Prolific Academic crowdsourcing platform. The survey questions were informed by previous qualitative interviews with parents and children, as well as existing literature. The survey aimed to understand:

  • How apps are installed and what technical restrictions parents use.
  • Parents' privacy concerns when choosing apps and their impact on app selection.
  • Parents' awareness and perceived effectiveness of privacy safeguarding tools on mobile devices.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Content Over Privacy: Despite expressing significant privacy concerns, parents' primary drivers for choosing or uninstalling apps are content appropriateness and cost, rather than the app's data collection practices. This suggests a potential gap in understanding or prioritizing privacy risks.
  • "SHARP" Framework: The paper introduces a mnemonic, "SHARP," to help parents remember key steps for managing app choices: Select apps carefully, Help children ask for help, Avoid providing sensitive information, Rate apps by age, and Privacy Permissions check.
  • Limited Awareness of App Stores: A majority of parents are unaware of dedicated "kids" or "family" sections within app stores, and those who are aware don't always find them significantly helpful in reducing privacy concerns.
  • Emotional Impact of App Removal: When parents remove apps due to privacy concerns, a substantial portion of children (48%) become very upset and struggle to understand the decision, highlighting the emotional challenges of digital parenting.
  • Passive vs. Proactive Protection: Parents of younger children (6-10) have a unique opportunity to transition from simply imposing passive protections to engaging in proactive mediation and open discussions about privacy with their children.

Key Results

  • App Installation: 71% of parents installed apps after their child asked for them. A notable 19% reported that their child might have installed apps themselves.
  • Password Protection: While 76% of families used password protection, 24% had no restrictions. Of those with passwords, 58% used them primarily to prevent paid app installations, suggesting financial rather than privacy motivations.
  • Installation Considerations: When installing apps, 86% of parents considered app content, 65% considered access to sensitive personal information, and 52% considered privacy permissions.
  • Refusal/Uninstallation Reasons: The primary reason for refusing or uninstalling an app was inappropriate content (57%). Access to unnecessary device features (33%) and excessive personal information access (26%) were also cited.
  • Favorite Apps: YouTube was the most frequently mentioned favorite app (55%), followed by Minecraft (16%) and Roblox (14%). 5 out of 14 popular apps had age ratings inappropriate for 6-10 year olds.
  • Privacy Concern Increase: Parents' concern about camera and location access significantly increased when presented with potential implications like stranger communication or data inference.
  • Privacy Permission Checks: 72% of parents had heard of app privacy permission settings. Nearly 1 in 4 checked them when a new app was installed, and 3 in 5 checked them regularly. 78% felt these settings reduced their privacy concerns.
  • Child's Reaction to App Removal: 48% of children were very upset when apps were removed, while 40% understood the decision.

Limitations and Future Work

The study acknowledges that its findings may be limited to the 6-10 age group, as these children are still closely connected to their parents, making active guidance more receptive. Future work should:

  • Investigate why parents' concerns about content appropriateness do not always translate into consistent app choices.
  • Further explore how to strengthen parents' technical competence and understanding of privacy implications.
  • Provide better support for parents in mediating children's app choices.
  • Deepen the understanding of the impact of third-party data tracking on children's development and well-being, which is crucial for informing policies and regulations.
  • Further investigate the actual effectiveness of "kids app stores" for safeguarding children's online safety and privacy.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{zhao2018what,
  author = {Jun Zhao and Ulrik Lyngs and Nigel Shadbolt},
  title = {{What privacy concerns do parents have about children's mobile apps, and how can they stay SHARP?}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1809.10841},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1809.10841},
}
Figure