WHAT NEXT-GENERATION 21 cm POWER SPECTRUM MEASUREMENTS CAN TEACH US ABOUT THE EPOCH OF REIONIZATION

Jonathan C. Pober, Adrian Liu, Joshua S. Dillon, James Aguirre, Judd D. Bowman, Richard F. Bradley, C. L. Carilli, David R. DeBoer, Jacqueline N. Hewitt, Daniel Jacobs, Matthew McQuinn, M. F. Morales, Aaron R. Parsons, Max Tegmark, Dan WerthimerThe Astrophysical Journal 2014 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Next-generation 21 cm radio telescopes, like the proposed HERA with a 0.1 km² collecting area, will be sensitive enough to detect the Epoch of Reionization (EoR) power spectrum with high significance, even under pessimistic foreground removal assumptions. This sensitivity will enable crucial constraints on the astrophysics of reionization, moving beyond simple detection to detailed characterization of the process.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Epoch of Reionization (EoR) marks a pivotal period in cosmic history when the first stars and galaxies ionized the neutral hydrogen in the universe. Detecting the faint 21 cm signal from this era is a major goal of modern cosmology. However, current experiments, while making progress, have limited sensitivity. This prevents them from providing detailed information about the astrophysics driving reionization. This paper addresses this gap by exploring what kind of scientific insights a next-generation of larger 21 cm telescopes, specifically focusing on a ~0.1 km² collecting area instrument like the Hydrogen Epoch of Reionization Array (HERA), could provide. The challenge lies in disentangling the faint cosmological signal from overwhelming foregrounds and understanding how instrument capabilities translate into astrophysical parameter constraints.

Methods

The authors employ a modeling approach to simulate the capabilities of future 21 cm experiments. They use:

  • Instrument Model: A concept design for the Hydrogen Epoch of Reionization Array (HERA) with a ~0.1 km² collecting area, consisting of 547 zenith-pointing 14m dishes in a hexagonal configuration. Sensitivity calculations are based on standard interferometry techniques, accounting for uv coverage, system temperature, and integration time.
  • Foreground Emission Models: Three distinct models are used to represent uncertainties in foreground subtraction. These range from a "pessimistic" scenario (limiting coherent baselines and assuming a broad "wedge" of contamination in k-space) to an "optimistic" scenario (assuming a much narrower foreground wedge).
  • Reionization History Models: The publicly available 21cmFAST code is used to generate a range of reionization histories by varying key astrophysical parameters: the ionizing efficiency ($\zeta$), the minimum virial temperature of ionizing halos ($T_{vir}$), and the mean free path of ionizing photons ($R_{mfp}$).

The core of the analysis involves calculating the expected signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of the 21 cm power spectrum for various combinations of these models and exploring how well astrophysical parameters can be constrained using a Fisher matrix analysis.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical modeling and simulations rather than analyzing observational datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Collecting Area: The study strongly emphasizes that a significant increase in collecting area (to ~0.1 km²) is the primary driver for achieving high-significance detections and detailed astrophysical constraints.
  • Foregrounds are the Bottleneck, but Solvable: While foregrounds pose a significant challenge, the paper demonstrates that even with pessimistic assumptions about foreground removal, next-generation instruments can still achieve remarkable results. Improvements in foreground subtraction techniques (moving towards the "optimistic" model) dramatically boost sensitivity and allow access to larger scales.
  • Beyond Detection to Characterization: The paper moves beyond simply asking "can we detect the EoR signal?" to "what can we learn about the physics of reionization?". It highlights the ability to trace the evolution of the power spectrum with redshift and to constrain specific astrophysical parameters.
  • Redshift Diversity is Key: While lower redshifts offer less thermal noise, higher redshifts probe different astrophysical processes and are crucial for breaking degeneracies between model parameters. A wide range of observed redshifts is essential for robust parameter estimation.
  • Degeneracies are Real, but Breakable: The study identifies significant degeneracies between reionization parameters, especially when considering single redshift measurements. However, joint analysis across multiple redshifts, combined with improved foreground removal, can effectively break these degeneracies.

Key Results

  • High Significance Detection: A ~0.1 km² collecting area instrument like HERA is predicted to achieve a very high significance (≥30σ) detection of the EoR power spectrum, even in the most pessimistic foreground scenarios.
  • Astrophysical Parameter Constraints: The sensitivity of such an instrument will allow for significant constraints on reionization parameters ($\zeta$, $T_{vir}$, $R_{mfp}$). Under optimistic foreground conditions, constraints can reach ~1% uncertainty, while even pessimistic scenarios yield ~5% uncertainty.
  • Imaging Potential: The high sensitivity levels achieved may even enable direct imaging of the EoR on scales of ~0.1-0.25 hMpc⁻¹.
  • Redshift Evolution Tracing: The ability to measure the power spectrum across a range of redshifts will allow for tracing the evolution of reionization, providing insights into its timing and duration.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplification: The authors acknowledge that their models for the instrument, foregrounds, and reionization histories are simplified. While chosen for their ability to encompass a wide range of uncertainties, they may not perfectly capture all real-world complexities.
  • Theoretical Model Dependence: The accuracy of the astrophysical parameter constraints is dependent on the accuracy of the theoretical reionization model (21cmFAST). The paper notes that at the few-percent level of precision predicted, the scatter between different theoretical simulations could become a limiting factor.
  • Foreground Removal Nuances: While the paper explores different foreground models, the exact nature and extent of foreground contamination and the effectiveness of future removal techniques remain areas of active research.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future work could explore the impact of additional parameters on the power spectrum, investigate the effects of tracking scans versus drift-scanning, and delve deeper into the imaging capabilities of these instruments. They also highlight the need for continued theoretical development to match the precision of future observational data.

Summary updated

Abstract

A number of experiments are currently working towards a measurement of the 21 cm signal from the Epoch of Reionization. Whether or not these experiments deliver a detection of cosmological emission, their limited sensitivity will prevent them from providing detailed information about the astrophysics of reionization. In this work, we consider what types of measurements will be enabled by a next-generation of larger 21 cm EoR telescopes. To calculate the type of constraints that will be possible with such arrays, we use simple models for the instrument, foreground emission, and the reionization history. We focus primarily on an instrument modeled after the $\sim 0.1~\rm{km}^2$ collecting area Hydrogen Epoch of Reionization Array (HERA) concept design, and parameterize the uncertainties with regard to foreground emission by considering different limits to the recently described "wedge" footprint in k-space. Uncertainties in the reionization history are accounted for using a series of simulations which vary the ionizing efficiency and minimum virial temperature of the galaxies responsible for reionization, as well as the mean free path of ionizing photons through the IGM. Given various combinations of models, we consider the significance of the possible power spectrum detections, the ability to trace the power spectrum evolution versus redshift, the detectability of salient power spectrum features, and the achievable level of quantitative constraints on astrophysical parameters. Ultimately, we find that $0.1~\rm{km}^2$ of collecting area is enough to ensure a very high significance ($\gtrsim30\sigma$) detection of the reionization power spectrum in even the most pessimistic scenarios. This sensitivity should allow for meaningful constraints on the reionization history and astrophysical parameters, especially if foreground subtraction techniques can be improved and successfully implemented.
BibTeX
@article{pober2014what,
  author = {Jonathan C. Pober and Adrian Liu and Joshua S. Dillon and James Aguirre and Judd D. Bowman and Richard F. Bradley and C. L. Carilli and David R. DeBoer and Jacqueline N. Hewitt and Daniel Jacobs and Matthew McQuinn and M. F. Morales and Aaron R. Parsons and Max Tegmark and Dan Werthimer},
  title = {{WHAT NEXT-GENERATION 21 cm POWER SPECTRUM MEASUREMENTS CAN TEACH US ABOUT THE EPOCH OF REIONIZATION}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1088/0004-637x/782/2/66},
}
Figure