What Makes Urban Communities More Resilient to COVID-19? A Systematic Review of Current Evidence

Peng Cui, Zhiyu Dong, Xin Yao, Yifei Cao, Yifan Sun, Feng LanInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This systematic review analyzes current research on social resilience in urban communities facing COVID-19. It reveals that while many policies are effective, factors like vulnerable populations, social assistance, and socioeconomic status significantly impact a community's ability to withstand and recover from pandemics. The paper proposes a framework for enhancing social resilience through coordinated external interventions and internal regulation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic has exposed significant vulnerabilities in traditional community governance and public health responses. While the concept of "resilience" has been increasingly applied to pandemic preparedness, there's a need for a consolidated understanding of what makes urban communities socially resilient to such crises. This paper addresses the fragmentation in existing research by systematically reviewing and synthesizing the literature on social resilience in the context of COVID-19, aiming to identify key influencing factors, effective policies, and actionable recommendations.

Methods

The study employed a systematic literature review following the PRISMA statement. Key methods included:

  • Database Searching: Articles were collected from Web of Science, Scopus, and Springer Link using keywords related to "social resilience," "epidemic," "pandemic," and "COVID-19."
  • VOSviewer Visualization: This software was used for knowledge mapping to visualize the research progress and thematic clusters within the social resilience literature from 2012-2022.
  • Content Analysis: A qualitative and quantitative analysis of the selected papers was conducted to categorize findings into policies, recommendations, and influencing factors of social resilience.
  • Framework Development: The research synthesized findings into a generalized dimension and a framework dividing research into four dimensions (Intervention Angle: Hard Strength, Soft Power; Internal Regulation: Natural Conditions, Human Conditions) and 20 indicators.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study is a systematic review of existing literature, not an empirical study using primary datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Resilience is Multifaceted: Social resilience isn't a single attribute but a complex interplay of factors, including external policies and internal community dynamics.
  • Vulnerable Groups are Critical: The disproportionate impact on vulnerable populations is a major driver of spatial heterogeneity in social resilience and a key area for intervention.
  • Policy Effectiveness Varies: While many policies are effective, their success depends on context, implementation, and consideration of social equity, with some having negative impacts if not long-term oriented.
  • Internal Regulation Matters: Beyond government interventions, community solidarity, trust, cultural norms, and individual psychological states play a crucial role in maintaining resilience.
  • The 4Rs of Resilience: The paper highlights robustness, redundancy, rapidity, and resourcefulness as key characteristics for enhancing social resilience.

Key Results

The review identified 70 relevant papers on social resilience to COVID-19. Key findings include:

  • Policy Analysis: 11 papers discussed policies related to social resilience, with mixed results. Positive impacts were seen in social distancing and national prevention policies, while negative impacts were noted for policies affecting disabled individuals and those with limited access to resources.
  • Recommendations: 29 papers offered recommendations for improving social resilience, such as establishing assessment frameworks, prioritizing vulnerable groups for vaccination, and enhancing technological access.
  • Influencing Factors: 30 papers identified key factors influencing social resilience, with "vulnerable groups" (33%) being the most prominent, followed by "spatial heterogeneity" (27%) and "social psychological factors" (13%). Socioeconomic status, social ties, and social capital also emerged as significant predictors.
  • Research Trends: VOSviewer analysis showed a conceptual exploration of social resilience from 2013-2015, followed by an analysis of influencing factors and assessment measures from 2015-2017. Research significantly increased after the COVID-19 outbreak in 2019.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Scope of Literature: The search was restricted to English-language articles in specific databases (Web of Science, Scopus, Springer). This may exclude valuable research from other languages or databases.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest expanding the literature search to include more databases and non-English papers to create a more robust study. They also emphasize the need for future research to explore more possibilities in this domain, particularly focusing on vulnerable groups and addressing the impact of pandemics to increase social resilience. The study highlights the opportunity presented by the COVID-19 pandemic to examine and strengthen resilience-oriented planning.

Summary updated

Abstract

It has been more than two years since the outbreak of the COVID-19 epidemic at the end of 2019. Many scholars have introduced the "resilience" concept into COVID-19 prevention and control to make up for the deficiencies in traditional community governance. This study analyzed the progress in research on social resilience, which is an important component of community resilience, focusing on the current literature on the impact of social resilience on COVID-19, and proposed a generalized dimension to integrated previous relevant literature. Then, VOSviewer was used to visualize and analyze the current progress of research on social resilience. The PRISMA method was used to collate studies on social resilience to the pandemic. The result showed that many current policies are effective in controlling COVID-19, but some key factors, such as vulnerable groups, social assistance, and socioeconomics, affect proper social functioning. Some scholars have proposed effective solutions to improve social resilience, such as establishing an assessment framework, identifying priority inoculation groups, and improving access to technology and cultural communication. Social resilience to COVID-19 can be enhanced by both external interventions and internal regulation. Social resilience requires these two aspects to be coordinated to strengthen community and urban pandemic resilience.
BibTeX
@article{cui2022what,
  author = {Peng Cui and Zhiyu Dong and Xin Yao and Yifei Cao and Yifan Sun and Feng Lan},
  title = {{What Makes Urban Communities More Resilient to COVID-19? A Systematic Review of Current Evidence}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph191710532},
}
Figure