What makes efficient circularly polarised luminescence in the condensed phase: aggregation-induced circular dichroism and light emission

Jianzhao Liu, Huimin Su, Luming Meng, Yihua Zhao, Chunmei Deng, Jason C. Y. Ng, Ping Lü, Faisal Mahtab, Jacky W. Y. Lam, Xuhui Huang, Hongkai Wu, Kam Sing Wong, Ben Zhong TangChemical 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel molecular design strategy that combines aggregation-induced emission (AIE) with chiral building blocks to create highly efficient circularly polarized luminescence (CPL) materials. By engineering molecules that are non-emissive in solution but become intensely fluorescent and CPL-active upon aggregation into helical structures, the researchers overcome the common issue of aggregation-caused quenching, achieving record-breaking performance in terms of emission efficiency and CPL dissymmetry.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Conventional organic luminescent materials often suffer from aggregation-caused quenching (ACQ), where their fluorescence intensity drastically decreases when molecules pack together in the solid state or aggregates. This is a major hurdle for applications requiring efficient light emission in condensed phases, such as organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs) and CPL-based sensors. Furthermore, achieving strong circularly polarized luminescence (CPL) from organic materials, which is crucial for applications like 3D displays, chiral sensing, and advanced optical devices, is challenging. While some chiral molecules exhibit CPL, their performance is often limited by low emission efficiency in the condensed phase and small dissymmetry factors (a measure of CPL intensity). This paper aims to address both ACQ and low CPL performance by developing a new class of organic materials that are specifically designed for efficient CPL in the solid state.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Molecular Design and Synthesis: They designed and synthesized a novel molecule (denoted as '1') that integrates an aggregation-induced emission (AIE)-active silole core with chiral sugar moieties. The AIE component is known to become highly fluorescent upon aggregation, counteracting ACQ. The chiral component is intended to induce specific helical arrangements in the aggregated state, leading to CPL. The synthesis involved a multi-step process including a click chemistry reaction.
  • Spectroscopic Characterization: Standard techniques like UV-Vis absorption, fluorescence spectroscopy, and circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy were used to study the electronic transitions and chirality of the molecule in solution and aggregated states.
  • Aggregation Studies: The formation of aggregates and their morphology were investigated using techniques like scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). X-ray diffraction (XRD) was used to analyze the crystalline structure of aggregates.
  • CPL Measurements: A custom-built CPL spectroscopy system was used to measure the differential emission of left- and right-handed circularly polarized light.
  • Time-Resolved Fluorescence: This technique was used to study the excited-state dynamics and understand the mechanism behind the AIE effect.
  • Theoretical Calculations: First-principles density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed to understand the molecular packing, intermolecular interactions, and the role of low-frequency motions in the AIE phenomenon.
  • Microfluidic Fabrication: A novel Teflon-based microfluidic technique was used to create patterned fluorescent structures, demonstrating precise control over the material's arrangement.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic AIE and Chirality: The core idea is that combining AIE-active units with chiral building blocks can lead to materials that are both highly fluorescent in the solid state and emit circularly polarized light. This is a significant departure from traditional approaches that often struggle with ACQ in chiral luminescent systems.
  • Aggregation-Induced CD (AICD) and Emission (AIE): The molecule exhibits a remarkable dual behavior: it's non-emissive and achiral in solution but becomes both fluorescent and circularly dichroic upon aggregation. This simultaneous "turn-on" of both properties is key to their success.
  • Helical Self-Assembly: The aggregation process leads to the formation of well-defined right-handed helical nanoribbons and superhelical ropes. This ordered supramolecular structure is crucial for generating efficient CPL.
  • Restriction of Intramolecular Motion (RIM) as the AIE Mechanism: Theoretical calculations and time-resolved studies strongly suggest that the suppression of low-frequency intramolecular motions (like torsions) in the aggregated state is responsible for the enhanced fluorescence, a well-established mechanism for AIE.
  • Microfluidics for Precise CPL Patterning: The demonstration of fabricating fluorescent patterns using microfluidics is a significant step towards practical applications, allowing for controlled spatial arrangement of CPL-emitting materials.

Key Results

  • Dramatic Fluorescence Enhancement: The fluorescence quantum efficiency (Φ<sub>F</sub>) of molecule 1 increased by a factor of 136, from ~0.6% in solution to ~81.3% in the solid state. This effectively overcomes ACQ.
  • High CPL Dissymmetry Factors (g<sub>em</sub>): The absolute values of g<sub>em</sub> ranged from 0.08 to 0.32, which is two orders of magnitude higher than commonly reported organic CPL materials.
  • Record-Breaking Performance: The study reports the best results among organic conjugated molecular systems in terms of emission efficiency, dissymmetry factor, and spectral stability.
  • Excellent Spectral Stability: The CPL performance remained stable for over half a year under ambient conditions.
  • Micropatterned CPL: The microfluidically fabricated patterns achieved the highest g<sub>em</sub> of -0.32, attributed to enhanced molecular ordering in confined environments.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mechanism of Intermolecular Interactions: While the paper proposes that a combination of weak hydrogen bonding (C-H…O, C-H…N) and π-π stacking drives the assembly, the exact concerted mechanism is still under investigation.
  • Broader Applicability: The study focuses on a single molecule. Future work could explore the generality of this design strategy with different AIE-active cores and chiral units.
  • Device Integration: While micropatterning is demonstrated, integrating these materials into functional devices (e.g., CPL-emitting displays or sensors) would be a logical next step.
  • Chirality Transfer Understanding: Further theoretical and experimental work could delve deeper into how the chirality of the sugar moieties is effectively transferred to the entire supramolecular assembly to induce CPL.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this contribution, we conceptually present a new avenue to construction of molecular functional materials with high performance of circularly polarised luminescence (CPL) in the condensed phase. A molecule (1) containing luminogenic silole and chiral sugar moieties was synthesized and thoroughly characterized. In a solution of 1, no circular dichroism (CD) and fluorescence emission are observed, but upon molecular aggregation, both the CD and fluorescence are simultaneously turned on, showing aggregation-induced CD (AICD) and emission (AIE) effects. The AICD effect is supported by the fact that the molecules readily assemble into right-handed helical nanoribbons and superhelical ropes when aggregated. The AIE effect boosts the fluorescence quantum efficiency (Φ <sub>F</sub>) by 136 fold (Φ <sub>F</sub>, ∼0.6% in the solution versus ∼81.3% in the solid state), which surmounts the serious limitations of aggregation-caused quenching effect encountered by conventional luminescent materials. Time-resolved fluorescence study and theoretical calculation from first principles conclude that restriction of the low-frequency intramolecular motions is responsible for the AIE effect. The helical assemblies of 1 prefer to emit right-handed circularly polarised light and display large CPL dissymmetry factors (g <sub>em</sub>), whose absolute values are in the range of 0.08-0.32 and are two orders of magnitude higher than those of commonly reported organic materials. We demonstrate for the first time the use of a Teflon-based microfluidic technique for fabrication of the fluorescent pattern. This shows the highest g <sub>em</sub> of -0.32 possibly due to the enhanced assembling order in the confined microchannel environment. The CPL performance was preserved after more than half year storage under ambient conditions, revealing the excellent spectral stability. Computational simulation was performed to interpret how the molecules in the aggregates interact with each other at the molecular level. Our designed molecule represents the desired molecular functional material for generating efficient CPL in the solid state, and the current study shows the best results among the reported organic conjugated molecular systems in terms of emission efficiency, dissymmetry factor, and spectral stability.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2012what,
  author = {Jianzhao Liu and Huimin Su and Luming Meng and Yihua Zhao and Chunmei Deng and Jason C. Y. Ng and Ping Lü and Faisal Mahtab and Jacky W. Y. Lam and Xuhui Huang and Hongkai Wu and Kam Sing Wong and Ben Zhong Tang},
  title = {{What makes efficient circularly polarised luminescence in the condensed phase: aggregation-induced circular dichroism and light emission}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1039/c2sc20382k},
}
Figure