What It Takes to Measure Reionization with Fast Radio Bursts

Stefan Heimersheim, Nina S. Sartorio, Anastasia Fialkov, D. R. LorimerThe Astrophysical Journal 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) are recently discovered extra-galactic radio transients which are now used as novel cosmological probes. We show how the Bursts' Dispersion Measure can model-independently probe the history of Hydrogen reionization. Using a FlexKnot free-form parameterization to reconstruct the reionization history we predict an 11% accuracy constraint on the CMB optical depth, and 4% accuracy on the midpoint of reionization, to be achieved with 100 FRBs originating from redshifts $z > 5$.

Introduction

The Epoch of Reionization (EoR) is a critical period in cosmic history, occurring approximately 13 billion years ago when the first stars and galaxies ionized the neutral hydrogen in the intergalactic medium (IGM). Mapping this transition is essential for understanding early structure formation. Currently, our knowledge of the EoR relies primarily on the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and observations of distant quasars. However, these methods often necessitate assuming a specific functional form for the ionization history—typically a simple "step function" or tanh model. Such rigid assumptions can introduce significant bias if the actual reionization process was complex or multi-staged.

Methodology: The FlexKnot Approach

To overcome the limitations of parametric models, we propose using Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) as a model-independent probe. As radio pulses from FRBs travel through the universe, they are dispersed by free electrons. The resulting Dispersion Measure (DM) provides an integrated record of the electron density along the line of sight, making it uniquely sensitive to the entire history of the IGM.

We employ the FlexKnot method for reconstruction. Instead of a fixed equation, the ionization fraction $x_i(z)$ is defined by a set of "knots" (data points) with interpolation between them. The number and position of these knots are determined using Bayesian marginalization. This approach calculates the "evidence" for varying levels of model complexity, naturally favoring the simplest model that adequately explains the data—a rigorous application of Occam’s Razor.

FlexKnot parameterization and Bayesian evidence selection for model complexity.

Forecasts and Results

This study presents a theoretical forecast based on future samples of high-redshift FRBs ($z > 5$), which are expected to be detected in large numbers by next-generation facilities like the Square Kilometre Array (SKA).

Our analysis demonstrates that even a modest sample of 100 FRBs can provide highly competitive cosmological constraints. Specifically, we find that the midpoint of reionization can be determined with 4% accuracy, while the CMB optical depth $\tau$ can be constrained to 11% accuracy. These results are comparable to or exceed current limits from quasar and CMB measurements.

Forecasted constraints on the optical depth $\tau$ using 100 and 1,000 FRBs compared to current Planck CMB limits.

As the sample size increases to 1,000 FRBs, the precision improves further, potentially resolving existing tensions in cosmological parameters and providing a clear window into the "pathological" or non-standard reionization scenarios that traditional models fail to capture.

Discussion and Future Outlook

While the potential of FRBs as cosmological probes is significant, several challenges remain. The primary hurdle is the detection of high-redshift bursts; current instruments lack the sensitivity and sky coverage required to find these rare, distant events. Furthermore, the DM signal is contaminated by the FRB host galaxy and the Milky Way, requiring sophisticated subtraction techniques.

The success of this model-independent approach depends on the operationalization of the SKA and other future radio observatories. Once these high-redshift populations are accessible, FRBs will likely become a cornerstone of observational cosmology, providing a definitive map of the universe's transition from darkness to light.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) are extragalactic radio transients that exhibit a distance-dependent dispersion of their signal, and thus can be used as cosmological probes. In this article we, for the first time, apply a model-independent approach to measure reionization from synthetic FRB data assuming these signals are detected beyond redshift 5. This method allows us to constrain the full shape of the reionization history as well as the CMB optical depth τ while avoiding the problems of commonly used model-based techniques. A total of 100 localized FRBs, originating from redshifts 5–15, could constrain (at 68% confidence level) the CMB optical depth to within 11%, and the midpoint of reionization to 4%, surpassing current state-of-the-art CMB bounds and quasar limits. Owing to the higher numbers of expected FRBs at lower redshifts, the τ constraints are asymmetric (+14%, −7%), providing a much stronger lower limit. Finally, we show that the independent constraints on reionization from FRBs will improve limits on other cosmological parameters, such as the amplitude of the power spectrum of primordial fluctuations.
BibTeX
@article{heimersheim2022what,
  author = {Stefan Heimersheim and Nina S. Sartorio and Anastasia Fialkov and D. R. Lorimer},
  title = {{What It Takes to Measure Reionization with Fast Radio Bursts}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/ac70c9},
}
Figure