What is duality?

Christian SchmidProceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical Sciences 1970 · DOI

Abstract

Duality provides a satisfying connection between two different areas of strong interaction physics: Regge poles at high energy and resonances at low energy. This interlocking gives powerful bootstrap conditions and, together with the assumption that certain channels do not contain resonances, imposes strong restrictions on the hadron spectrum. This paper clarifies the various forms of duality—including Finite-Energy Sum Rule (FESR) duality and local duality—and demonstrates why interference models, which attempt to add these two descriptions, are physically inconsistent.

Introduction

In the late 1960s, particle physics was grappling with a "zoo" of newly discovered hadrons. Physicists had two very different ways to describe how these particles scattered: one focused on low-energy "resonances" (temporary bound states) and another on high-energy "Regge poles" (exchanged particles). Christoph Schmid’s 1969 paper, "What is Duality?", serves as a foundational clarification of the revolutionary idea that these two descriptions are not separate pieces of a puzzle to be added together, but rather two different ways of looking at the same underlying reality.

The Duality Hypothesis

The core question Schmid tackles is whether resonances and Regge poles are distinct physical processes or the same thing viewed through different mathematical lenses. Duality posits that the scattering amplitude can be represented either as a sum of resonances in the direct channel ($s$-channel) or as a sum of Regge exchanges in the crossed channel ($t$-channel).

At low energies, the description by direct-channel resonances is simple and useful. The data show prominent peaks as a function of energy, and one may approximate the amplitude by resonance saturation, neglecting the non-resonating background.

Direct-channel resonance formation (N*) in pion-nucleon scattering.

In complete contrast, the "Interference Model" postulated that one must add the two descriptions. Schmid demonstrates that this leads to double-counting—like counting the same people twice because they changed clothes—and results in cross-sections much larger than those observed experimentally.

Mathematical Foundations: Finite-Energy Sum Rules (FESR)

Schmid utilizes Finite-Energy Sum Rules (FESR) to bridge the gap between low and high energy. Derived from Cauchy’s integral theorem and the principle of analyticity, FESR relates the integral of the low-energy scattering amplitude to the parameters of the high-energy Regge poles.

This mathematical link implies "average duality": on average, the smooth extrapolation of high-energy Regge formulas down to low energies perfectly matches the average of the jagged resonance peaks. Furthermore, Schmid discusses "local duality," where the Regge description produces "circles" on Argand diagrams even at specific intermediate energies, mimicking the signature of individual resonances.

Empirical Success and Exchange Degeneracy

The paper relies on established experimental data, specifically $\pi N$ (Pion-Nucleon) and $\bar{K}N$ (Kaon-Nucleon) scattering. One of the most significant results is the explanation of "exchange degeneracy." In channels where no resonances are present (so-called "exotic" channels), duality requires the corresponding Regge terms to cancel each other out. This implies that certain particles, like the $\rho$ and $A_2$ mesons, must have identical trajectories.

Using FESR and the masses/couplings of $Y^*$ baryons as input, Schmid successfully "computed" meson Regge trajectories, showing that the output matched experimental meson masses. This "building up" process shows that the existence of specific particles at low energy forces the existence of the Regge trajectory at high energy.

Limitations

Despite its power, duality as presented in 1969 had limitations. The "Pomeron"—a specific high-energy exchange responsible for constant total cross-sections—does not fit into the resonance-saturation scheme and must be treated as a separate, non-dual background. Additionally, the method struggles with "Regge cuts" (complex multi-particle exchanges), which were difficult to distinguish from simple poles with the data available at the time.

Conclusion

Schmid’s clarification of duality moved particle physics away from additive interference models toward a unified bootstrap approach. By showing that resonances and Regge poles are equivalent descriptions linked by analyticity, this work laid the groundwork for the Veneziano model and, ultimately, the birth of string theory.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Duality gives a satisfying connexion between two different areas of strong interaction physics, Regge poles at high energy and resonances at low energy. This interlocking gives powerful bootstrap conditions, and together with the assumption that certain channels do not contain resonances it gives strong restrictions on the hadron spectrum. Since there is some confusion about the term duality, we shall explain what is meant by the various forms of duality (f. e. s. r. (finite energy sum rules) duality, local duality), and what is meant by ‘building up’, and we shall show in what way antidual models (such as the generalized interference model) come into conflict with basic empirical facts. Duality expresses the relation between two descriptions of the hadronic scattering amplitude. At low energy (l. e.) the description by direct-channel resonances is simple and useful (see figure 1). At low energy the data show prominent peaks as a function of energy, and one may try the approximation of resonance saturation, i. e. of neglecting the non-resonating background. The second description is the exchange of Regge poles, and it is useful at high energies (h.e.), where typical features are forward peaks, energy dependence sα, and structure at fixed t (see figure 2). The two descriptions are very different; resonance formation corresponds to poles in the s channel, Regge exchange to poles in the t channel. Duality says that there are direct relations between these two descriptions, that they are equivalent in a certain sense. In complete contrast, the interference models postulate that one must add the two descriptions. (If lowest order perturbation theory was relevant to strong interactions, one would be led to adding the diagrams.)
BibTeX
@inproceedings{schmid1970what,
  author = {Christian Schmid},
  title = {{What is duality?}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical Sciences},
  year = {1970},
  doi = {10.1098/rspa.1970.0144},
}
Figure