What factors affect the development of public charging infrastructures? a study from the perspective of potential users

Xian-Peng Chen, Jiang Xiao, Xiao-Chen Yu, Hao Peng, Bai-Chen XieFrontiers in Energy Research 2024 · DOI

Abstract

The rapid development of the electric vehicle market has greatly stimulated the demand for public charging infrastructure (PCI) and made it a pertinent topic to improve its charging service quality in the industry. Data from perceived preference, PCI and electric vehicles cannot reflect the factors influencing potential users’ anxiety. This study designed a PCI development evaluation framework to investigate the impact of economic, technological, market, policy, and social environmental factors on PCI development from the perspective of potential users. We collected a dataset including 386 potential users in Tianjin, China, and employed structural equation model to survey the implementation of PCI. The following conclusions were drawn from this study: 1) Reducing operating costs will not significantly increase PCI charging user demand and improve use efficiency for potential users; 2) Technical factors cannot directly promote the development of PCI but will reverse lag the development of the market; 3) The growing market demand is the main impetus to the development of electric vehicle industry, and the incentive policy and social environment can indirectly incentivize PCI development. The policy implications suggest that the PCI industry can experience sustainable development by continuously innovating market-oriented business models, and improving policy systems and industry mechanisms.

Introduction: The Human Factor in Infrastructure

The global transition toward electric vehicles (EVs) is often framed as a technical or economic challenge. However, a persistent "chicken and egg" dilemma remains: consumers hesitate to adopt EVs without a robust public charging infrastructure (PCI), while investors are reluctant to expand PCI without a guaranteed user base. While previous research has focused on supply-side optimization—such as charger placement or grid load management—these models frequently overlook the perceptions of potential users.

This study shifts the focus to the "human factor," investigating how potential EV users (those who have not yet switched) perceive the development of charging networks. By understanding the gap between technical availability and user perception, policymakers can better address the anxieties that prevent widespread EV adoption.

Methodology and Evaluation Framework

The researchers developed an evaluation framework grounded in two key social science theories: the Theory of Public Goods (TPG), which views PCI as a service requiring government intervention, and the Diffusion of Innovation (DIT), which treats PCI as a new technology requiring specific cues for adoption.

To analyze these perceptions, the study utilized Structural Equation Modeling (SEM). This statistical technique allows for the testing of complex relationships between "latent variables"—abstract concepts like Policy Environment—and the observed "Development Status."

Theoretical framework of factors influencing PCI development.

The study operationalized these latent variables into 23 explicit variables, as detailed in the table below. These variables were measured using a 5-point Likert scale through an online survey.

Definitions of latent and explicit variables used in the study.

Data Collection

The primary dataset was collected in Tianjin, China, a key pilot city for new energy vehicles. The survey yielded 386 valid responses. The sample was notably young and highly educated, with 85.8% holding at least an undergraduate degree, providing a snapshot of the demographic most likely to be early "late followers" in the EV transition.

Results and Discussion

The SEM analysis revealed several counterintuitive findings regarding what truly drives the perceived development of PCI.

The Cost and Technology Paradox

One of the most striking results was the Cost Paradox. The path from the economic environment to development status was statistically insignificant (0.027, p > 0.05). For potential users, internal station economics—such as land prices or maintenance costs—are largely invisible and do not influence their perception of whether the infrastructure is "developing" well.

Furthermore, technical factors exhibited a significant negative correlation (-0.434) with development status. This suggests a "reverse lag": as technology becomes more complex or fails to meet high user expectations (e.g., confusing app interfaces or perceived slow charging speeds), it acts as a bottleneck rather than a catalyst.

Market Demand and Indirect Drivers

In contrast, Market Environment emerged as a primary direct driver (coefficient of 0.298). Potential users are most influenced by visible market activity—seeing more EVs on the road and active, well-maintained charging stations.

Policy and social environments, while not direct drivers of perceived development, were found to be essential "enablers." They showed strong positive relationships with the Market Environment (0.240 and 0.567, respectively), suggesting that subsidies and social norms create the necessary conditions for a healthy market to flourish.

Conclusion and Policy Implications

The study concludes that simply advancing technology or reducing operational costs is insufficient to drive the perceived development of PCI among potential users. Instead, the focus must shift toward market-oriented growth and user-centric design.

Key Policy Recommendations: 1. Innovate Business Models: Move beyond simple subsidies toward market-driven models that increase the visibility and accessibility of charging services. 2. Simplify the User Experience: Address the "technical lag" by standardizing charging interfaces and simplifying payment and information systems. 3. Leverage Social Influence: Use social and policy cues to build confidence in the market, which in turn drives the perceived reliability of the infrastructure.

By addressing these perceptual barriers, stakeholders can more effectively bridge the gap between current infrastructure and the future needs of a carbon-neutral transport sector.

Summary updated

Abstract

The rapid development of the electric vehicle market has greatly stimulated the demand for public charging infrastructure (PCI) and made it a pertinent topic to improve its charging service quality in the industry. Data from perceived preference, PCI and electric vehicles cannot reflect the factors influencing potential users’ anxiety. This study designed a PCI development evaluation framework to investigate the impact of economic, technological, market, policy, and social environmental factors on PCI development from the perspective of potential users. We collected a dataset including 386 potential users in Tianjin, China, and employed structural equation model to survey the implementation of PCI. The following conclusions were drawn from this study: 1) Reducing operating costs will not significantly increase PCI charging user demand and improve use efficiency for potential users; 2) Technical factors cannot directly promote the development of PCI but will reverse lag the development of the market; 3) The growing market demand is the main impetus to the development of electric vehicle industry, and the incentive policy and social environment can indirectly incentivize PCI development. The policy implications suggest that the PCI industry can experience sustainable development by continuously innovating market-oriented business models, and improving policy systems and industry mechanisms. This study provides analytical foundation and decision support for policymakers and pertinent industry participants, promotes the development of electric vehicle-related industries, and helps achieve the strategic goal of carbon neutrality.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2024what,
  author = {Xian-Peng Chen and Jiang Xiao and Xiao-Chen Yu and Hao Peng and Bai-Chen Xie},
  title = {{What factors affect the development of public charging infrastructures? a study from the perspective of potential users}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2024.1257121},
}
Figure