TL;DR
This study investigates the drivers of corporate tax rates across 113 countries during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic (2020–2021). The researchers found that higher levels of pandemic-related uncertainty and larger country populations are significantly associated with higher corporate tax rates, as governments sought to fund massive fiscal deficits and stimulus packages.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The COVID-19 pandemic forced governments worldwide to implement unprecedented fiscal measures, from business stimulus packages to household consumption support. These actions created significant "cash crunches" and fiscal deficits. While previous research has explored how uncertainties affect tax policy generally, there has been a lack of empirical evidence regarding what specifically determined corporate tax rates on a global scale during the 2020–2021 period.
The authors aim to fill this gap by identifying whether economic uncertainty, country size, or national income levels dictated how governments adjusted their corporate tax regimes to cope with the pandemic's economic fallout.
Methods
The authors employ a cross-sectional analysis of 113 advanced and developing economies. To ensure the results were not just artifacts of a specific mathematical model, they used two distinct econometric approaches:
- Ordinary Least Squares (OLS): A standard linear regression method to estimate the relationship between variables.
- Kernel-based Regularized Least Squares (KRLS): A more flexible machine learning-based estimator. KRLS is particularly useful here because it reduces "misspecification bias"—it doesn't assume a strictly linear relationship between variables and can better handle complex, non-linear interactions in the data.
The dependent variables were the corporate tax rates for 2020 and 2021, while the independent variables included per capita GDP, total population, and a specific index for pandemic uncertainty.
Datasets
The study draws from three primary data sources:
- Corporate Tax Rates: Sourced from KPMG’s annual tax rate tables for 2020 and 2021.
- Economic Indicators: Per capita GDP (PPP) and total population data were retrieved from the World Bank’s World Development Indicators.
- Uncertainty Measure: The World Pandemic Uncertainty Index (WPUI), developed by Ahir et al. This index quantifies uncertainty by counting the frequency of pandemic-related terms in Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) country reports.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Uncertainty as a Revenue Driver: The most striking finding is the positive correlation between the WPUI and tax rates. As pandemic-related uncertainty increased, so did corporate tax rates. The authors suggest that uncertainty shocks increased fiscal costs, prompting governments to raise corporate taxes to finance the gap.
- The "Large Country" Burden: Country size (population) was a consistent predictor of higher tax rates. The researchers hypothesize that larger countries faced higher "spread ratios" of the virus and consequently higher total economic costs, necessitating more aggressive tax collection.
- Income is Not Destiny: Interestingly, while per capita GDP showed a negative relationship with tax rates in OLS models (wealthier countries having lower rates), this result was not robust when tested with the KRLS machine learning estimator. This suggests that during a global crisis, a country's wealth is a less reliable predictor of tax policy than the immediate pressure of uncertainty and population size.
Key Results
- Uncertainty Impact: In the OLS models, a 1% increase in the World Pandemic Uncertainty Index was associated with a more than 1%-point increase in corporate tax rates.
- Population Impact: A 1% rise in total population yielded a more than 1%-point increase in corporate tax rates in the OLS model (though this was slightly less than 1% in the KRLS model).
- Model Consistency: Both 2020 and 2021 data showed similar trends, indicating that these drivers remained consistent throughout the different waves of the pandemic.
- Explanatory Power: The models accounted for roughly 15% to 28% of the variance in tax rates (R-squared), which is substantial given the myriad of political and local factors that usually influence tax legislation.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations that provide a roadmap for future research:
- Narrow Tax Focus: The study only looks at corporate tax rates. Future work should examine if these same drivers (uncertainty and population) apply to indirect taxes (like VAT) or individual income taxes.
- Resource Endowments: The paper suggests that future studies should categorize countries by natural resource abundance, as "resource-rich" vs. "resource-poor" status might significantly alter how a government responds to fiscal shocks.
- Long-term Effects: As this study focused on the "crisis mode" of 2020–2021, it remains to be seen if these tax increases will persist or revert in the post-COVID-19 era.
Summary updated