What Attributes Make United States Plastic Surgery Programs Desirable? Perspectives from Medical Students and Residents.

Magnus Chun, Alisa O. Girard, Yichi Zhang, Abigail Meyers, Idean Roohani, Tracey Cook, Ping Song, Abigail E. ChaffinPubMed 2022

TL;DR

This study surveyed medical students and residents to understand what makes US plastic surgery residency programs desirable. The findings highlight that resident happiness/well-being and preferred geographical location are paramount, with virtual events like "meet-and-greets" gaining importance due to the pandemic. This research offers actionable insights for programs aiming to attract top talent and enhance the resident experience.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Plastic surgery is a highly competitive residency field, making it challenging for applicants to differentiate between programs. Traditionally, factors like away rotations and in-person interviews provided crucial subjective assessments. However, the COVID-19 pandemic significantly altered this landscape, limiting in-person interactions and increasing reliance on online resources. This paper addresses the need to understand how prospective and current trainees evaluate and rank plastic surgery residency programs in this evolving environment, particularly focusing on attributes that contribute to a program's desirability and the impact of pandemic-induced changes.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional analysis using a 7-question anonymous survey distributed via Qualtrics. The survey was designed to elicit desirable qualities of plastic surgery residency training programs and was reviewed by faculty, a statistician, and current medical students and residents. Participants used a 3-point Likert scale (undesirable, neutral, desirable) to rate various program attributes. The survey also collected demographic information and asked respondents to identify the most important program characteristics. Data analysis involved both qualitative and quantitative methods, including chi-square tests and z-tests for statistical significance.

Datasets

The study utilized data from a survey of 50 respondents, representing 28% of US plastic surgery residency programs. The respondents included medical students (third and fourth-year) and current plastic surgery residents (integrated and independent tracks). No new datasets were introduced; the study relied on self-reported survey responses.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Resident Well-being is King: The most consistently desirable attribute across the board was the happiness and well-being of current residents. This suggests that a positive and supportive training environment is a top priority for applicants.
  • Location, Location, Location: Preferred geographical location emerged as another highly desirable factor, underscoring the importance of personal life considerations in career decisions.
  • Pandemic-Driven Preferences: Virtual events, particularly "meet-and-greets" and resident happy hours, were highly valued during the COVID-19 pandemic, indicating a shift towards online engagement for assessing program culture.
  • Research: A Double-Edged Sword: While a strong research reputation was generally favored, a mandatory research year during residency was largely opposed, especially by current residents. This suggests a preference for flexibility and optionality in research involvement.
  • Social Media's Growing Role: Social media outreach was seen as an important tool for programs to showcase their personality and culture, though its influence on program choice was moderate.

Key Results

  • Top Desirable Qualities: Resident happiness and well-being (1.00 ± 0.00) and preferred geographical location (0.98 ± 0.02) were the most highly rated desirable qualities.
  • Research Opposition: 82% of respondents opposed mandatory research years (P = 0.002).
  • Virtual Event Preference: 70% of respondents rated virtual meet-and-greets and resident happy hours as most desirable in the context of COVID-19.
  • Social Media Outreach: 46% of respondents felt social media outreach was important.
  • Program Website vs. Social Media: Program website quality and social media outreach had similar, moderate desirability scores (0.58 ± 0.07 and 0.42 ± 0.08, respectively) with no significant difference in desirability.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size and Representation: The study's sample size may be limited, representing only 28% of plastic surgery residency programs.
  • Distribution Method: The survey relied on program directors to distribute it, which may introduce bias and limits the ability to determine the exact response rate.
  • Generalizability: Combining data from medical students and residents might obscure differences in their preferences, potentially affecting generalizability.
  • Recall Bias: The study is subject to recall bias.
  • Weighted Averages: The use of a 3-point Likert scale and weighted averages for ratings is a simplification.

Future work could involve re-distributing the survey to a larger and more diverse pool of programs and applicants. Further investigation into the specific geographical considerations that influence applicant decisions would also be beneficial. Additionally, exploring the potential shift in mindset regarding research involvement as trainees progress through their careers warrants further study.

Summary updated

Abstract

Resident happiness and well-being, followed by preferred geographical location, were the most favorable program attributes. Plastic surgery residency programs may seek to better integrate these preferences within their curricula, as well as showcase them on social media, to attract high-quality applicants and optimize the training experience for matched residents.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chun2022what,
  author = {Magnus Chun and Alisa O. Girard and Yichi Zhang and Abigail Meyers and Idean Roohani and Tracey Cook and Ping Song and Abigail E. Chaffin},
  title = {{What Attributes Make United States Plastic Surgery Programs Desirable? Perspectives from Medical Students and Residents.}},
  booktitle = {PubMed},
  year = {2022},
}
Figure