What are the key components of an entrepreneurial ecosystem in a developing economy? A longitudinal empirical study on technology business incubators in China

Xiangfei Yuan, Haijing Hao, Chenghua Guan, Alex PentlandarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Since the 1980s, technology business incubators (TBIs) have become a cornerstone of global innovation policy, focusing on resource sharing, knowledge agglomeration, and accelerating startup growth. While research on TBIs has expanded significantly, most studies rely on Western-centric frameworks that often overlook the specific dynamics of developing economies. This study proposes a four-component entrepreneurial ecosystem framework—comprising People, Technology, Capital, and Infrastructure—to investigate the drivers of TBI performance. Using a unique three-year panel dataset of 857 national TBIs across 33 major Chinese cities (2015–2017), we employ factor analysis and panel regression to identify the variables that most significantly impact the number of graduated firms. Our findings highlight a critical synergy between technology and capital as the most consistent predictor of success across all regions.

Introduction: The "Atomic" Ecosystem

While "entrepreneurial ecosystems" is a ubiquitous term in management circles, it remains notoriously difficult to quantify due to "vague boundary" syndrome—the difficulty of defining where one ecosystem ends and another begins. This study addresses this challenge by proposing that a Technology Business Incubator (TBI) serves as the smallest "atomic" unit of an entrepreneurial ecosystem. Unlike broad regional studies, a TBI has clear boundaries, specific actors (entrepreneurs, mentors, investors), and measurable outcomes.

Furthermore, existing literature often focuses on social and institutional factors, frequently neglecting technology itself as a core component. In the context of a rapidly developing economy like China, understanding how these components interact is vital for both policy design and management strategy.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The research utilizes a framework consisting of four pillars:

  1. People: Staff quality, education levels, and the availability of mentors.
  2. Technology: Intellectual property (IP) applications and R&D investment within the incubator.
  3. Capital: Access to venture capital, financial subsidies, and IPO activity.
  4. Infrastructure: Regional economic factors, including city-level GDP and the density of universities.

To analyze the complexity of these interactions, the researchers employed a two-step statistical approach. First, Factor Analysis was used to compress 88 distinct variables into seven "unobserved factors" (e.g., the "People-Service Factor" or "Technology-Capital Factor"), which collectively explained 82.7% of the variance. Second, Panel Regression (using Fixed and Random Effects models) was applied to the longitudinal data to control for time-invariant variables and the unique, unmeasurable "vibe" or quality of specific incubators.

Key Findings

The Technology-Capital Synergy

The most significant discovery was that technology (IP applications and R&D) and capital (VC and IPOs) are statistically inseparable in their impact on performance. This "Technology-Capital Factor" was the only variable that remained statistically significant across the national model and all five regional models (Northeast, North, East, Central, and South). This suggests that in a modern tech-driven economy, R&D potency and financial liquidity must be integrated to drive firm graduation.

The Infrastructure Paradox

Counter-intuitively, at the national level, infrastructure factors—such as a city’s GDP per capita or industry diversity—were not statistically significant drivers of TBI performance. This "Infrastructure Paradox" suggests that high-performing incubators can thrive even in less-developed regions, provided they possess the right internal mix of human capital, technology, and funding. Success is driven more by the micro-ecosystem within the TBI than the macro-economic status of the host city.

Market Maturity and Regional Variation

The study also indicates a shift in China’s innovation landscape. Direct government subsidies did not emerge as a significant driver in the national model, suggesting that China’s ecosystem is transitioning from state-led mandates to a more mature, market-driven model.

Regional differences, however, remain stark:

  • People-Mentor Services: These were highly significant in the North and Central regions, where service markets are less developed and internal incubator support is critical.
  • The Specialization Effect: In South China, higher industry diversity and a higher density of universities actually had a negative correlation with TBI performance. This suggests that in highly developed markets, specialization and concentrated knowledge spillover between similar firms may be more effective than broad diversification.

Conclusion

This longitudinal study demonstrates that the success of technology business incubators in a developing economy depends less on regional wealth and more on the internal integration of technology and capital. For policymakers and TBI managers, the results suggest that focusing on IP generation and venture capital access is the most reliable path to scaling startups. Future research should expand this framework to smaller cities and other developing nations to determine if the "Infrastructure Paradox" holds true on a global scale.

Summary updated

Abstract

Since the 1980s, technology business incubators (TBIs), which focus on accelerating businesses through resource sharing, knowledge agglomeration, and technology innovation, have become a booming industry. As such, research on TBIs has gained international attention, most notably in the United States, Europe, Japan, and China. The present study proposes an entrepreneurial ecosystem framework with four key components, i.e., people, technology, capital, and infrastructure, to investigate which factors have an impact on the performance of TBIs. We also empirically examine this framework based on unique, three-year panel survey data from 857 national TBIs across China. We implemented factor analysis and panel regression models on dozens of variables from 857 national TBIs between 2015 and 2017 in all major cities in China and found that a number of factors associated with people, technology, capital, and infrastructure components have various statistically significant impacts on the performance of TBIs at either national model or regional models.
BibTeX
@misc{yuan2021what,
  author = {Xiangfei Yuan and Haijing Hao and Chenghua Guan and Alex Pentland},
  title = {{What are the key components of an entrepreneurial ecosystem in a developing economy? A longitudinal empirical study on technology business incubators in China}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2103.08131},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2103.08131},
}
Figure