What Are the Disparities in Spatiotemporal Patterns Between Urban and Rural Well-Being? Evidence from a Rapidly Urbanizing Region in China

Yihan Zhou, Qun Ma, Yuxi Huang, Xiaohui Sun, Jiayi Dong, Naijie Zhang, Jun GaoSustainability 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies and analyzes the spatial and temporal patterns of urban and rural well-being in China's Yangtze River Delta (YRD) from 2000-2020 using the Human Development Index (HDI). It reveals significant improvements in both urban and rural well-being, with rural areas showing faster growth, narrowing the gap, though persistent inequalities in urban education and rural income remain.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Sustainable Development Goals emphasize enhancing human well-being, and understanding disparities between urban and rural populations is crucial for achieving social harmony and equitable development. While many studies focus on either urban or rural well-being, there's a critical gap in understanding their comparative spatiotemporal dynamics. This is particularly important in rapidly urbanizing regions like China's Yangtze River Delta (YRD), where imbalanced development can exacerbate social and environmental issues. Existing research often uses aggregated HDI data, masking crucial differences in how well-being evolves in urban versus rural settings. This study aims to fill this gap by specifically analyzing and comparing urban and rural HDI and its components across the YRD over two decades.

Methods

The study employs the Human Development Index (HDI) as its primary metric for quantifying well-being. The HDI is a composite index that integrates three key dimensions: income, health, and education. The authors adapted the standard HDI calculation methodology, using per capita disposable income (instead of GNI per capita) to better reflect regional income disparities, and average years of schooling and life expectancy for education and health, respectively.

To analyze spatiotemporal patterns, the researchers utilized:

  • Local Moran's I: This spatial autocorrelation statistic was used to identify clusters of high or low HDI values and understand their spatial distribution and evolution.
  • Gini Coefficient: This metric was employed to measure inequality within urban and rural populations separately for each HDI dimension (income, education, health) and for the overall HDI.
  • Urban-Rural HDI Ratio: This ratio was used to directly quantify the gap between urban and rural well-being.

The study also employed natural breaks classification to categorize HDI levels and urban-rural gap levels.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from various sources for the period 2000-2020, primarily focusing on the Yangtze River Delta urban agglomeration:

  • Statistical Yearbooks: Provincial-level statistical yearbooks (Shanghai, Zhejiang, Jiangsu, Anhui) provided data on per capita disposable income.
  • Census Yearbooks and Population Sample Surveys: Data from the 2000, 2010, and 2020 national censuses, along with 1% population sample surveys from 2005 and 2015, were used to derive average years of schooling and life expectancy. For Shanghai, linear regression was used to interpolate missing schooling data.
  • China Statistical Yearbooks (2001-2021): These were used to ensure data consistency, as yearbooks typically contain data from the preceding calendar year.

The study area encompasses Shanghai municipality and 25 prefecture-level cities across Jiangsu, Zhejiang, and Anhui provinces. Rural data was collected from 33 districts and cities, excluding those with negligible rural populations or data unavailability.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rural Catch-Up: The most striking insight is that while both urban and rural well-being improved, rural areas experienced a faster growth rate in HDI. This suggests that targeted development policies are effectively narrowing the urban-rural divide, a crucial step towards balanced regional development.
  • Persistent Inequality Hotspots: Despite overall improvements, the study highlights specific areas of persistent inequality: urban education and rural income. This indicates that simply increasing overall HDI doesn't automatically resolve deep-seated structural issues within these specific dimensions.
  • Shanghai's Radiating Effect: The study implicitly points to Shanghai's role as a core city, driving development through "polarization" and "radiation" effects, influencing both urban and rural well-being in surrounding areas. This highlights the importance of understanding inter-regional dynamics.
  • Health Disparity Nuances: Interestingly, the study found instances where rural health well-being in specific sub-regions (southern Zhejiang) actually surpassed urban levels during certain periods, challenging the common assumption of urban superiority in all well-being aspects.

Key Results

  • Overall HDI Improvement: Average urban HDI increased from 0.66 (2000) to 0.83 (2020), a 27.13% growth. Average rural HDI rose from 0.55 (2000) to 0.74 (2020), a more substantial 34.55% growth.
  • Income Growth Dominance: Both urban and rural income indices saw the most significant growth, with urban income up 49.12% and rural income up 66.3% from 2000-2020.
  • Education and Income Inequality: Urban education and rural income exhibited the most pronounced inequalities, with average Gini coefficients significantly higher than those for health.
  • Narrowing Urban-Rural Gap: The urban-rural HDI ratio indicated a narrowing gap, with the proportion of areas showing low or no disparity increasing significantly by 2020.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Subjective Well-being Omission: The study focused solely on objective well-being (HDI). Future research should incorporate subjective well-being measures (e.g., through surveys) for a more holistic understanding.
  • Geographical Scale: The analysis was conducted at the prefecture-level city scale. Future work could benefit from a finer-grained analysis at the county or even sub-district level to capture more nuanced disparities.

The authors suggest that future research should expand the geographical scope and refine the analysis to uncover more detailed differences and commonalities, providing a more precise basis for policy formulation. They also highlight the potential of digital inclusive finance as a key instrument for narrowing income disparities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Enhancing human well-being is a core priority of the Sustainable Development Goals. Understanding urban–rural well-being disparities is crucial for bridging gaps and improving social harmony. However, most existing studies focus on either urban or rural residents’ well-being, neglecting their disparities. This study quantified and compared the spatiotemporal patterns of the well-being of urban and rural residents in the Yangtze River Delta (YRD) urban agglomeration from 2000 to 2020 using the human development index (HDI). Results show the following: (1) Urban and rural well-being improved markedly from 2000 to 2020, with urban HDI increasing from 0.66 to 0.83 and rural HDI from 0.55 to 0.74. (2) Urban education and rural income inequalities were more pronounced, with the average Gini coefficients over 2000–2020 more than threefold and twofold those of urban and rural health, respectively. (3) Although disparities existed between urban and rural well-being, rural HDI had grown faster between 2000 and 2020, narrowing the urban–rural gap. From 2000 to 2020, the growth rate for rural HDI (34.55%) exceeded that for urban HDI (27.13%). To foster the shared urban and rural well-being, this study recommends diversifying rural industries, optimizing educational resources, and enhancing rural healthcare infrastructure in the YRD and beyond.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2025what,
  author = {Yihan Zhou and Qun Ma and Yuxi Huang and Xiaohui Sun and Jiayi Dong and Naijie Zhang and Jun Gao},
  title = {{What Are the Disparities in Spatiotemporal Patterns Between Urban and Rural Well-Being? Evidence from a Rapidly Urbanizing Region in China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/su17135682},
}
Figure