TL;DR
This paper systematically reviews Chinese academic literature from 1997-2016 to identify factors driving China's export growth. It reveals a strong focus on macro-level determinants, with a notable underrepresentation of firm-level and individual factors, suggesting a need for more granular research to fully understand China's export success.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
China's export growth has been a remarkable economic phenomenon, transforming it into a global trade powerhouse. However, understanding the precise drivers behind this growth, particularly from the perspective of Chinese academia, has been challenging for Western scholars due to language barriers and the sheer volume of research. This paper aims to bridge this gap by conducting a systematic review of Chinese-language literature to identify and categorize the factors that have influenced China's export performance between 1997 and 2016, providing a comprehensive overview and highlighting areas for future research.
Methods
The authors employed a systematic review protocol to ensure rigor and reproducibility. This involved a multi-round search strategy using Google Scholar, focusing on Chinese academic journal papers. The initial search used six key Chinese terms related to export growth. Subsequent rounds involved a "down-stream" approach, identifying papers that cited previously found articles, effectively tracing influential research streams. A crucial inclusion criterion was that papers must be included in the National Social Science Database (NSSD), a curated repository of high-quality Chinese academic journals, to ensure the reliability of the findings. The review process was designed to be transparent and repeatable for Western scholars.
Datasets
The study did not introduce new datasets but rather analyzed a database of 620 Chinese academic journal articles published between 1997 and 2016. These articles were sourced from 188 different Chinese academic journals, with the "Journal of International Trade" being the most prolific contributor.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Macro-Level Dominance: The overwhelming majority of research focuses on macro-level factors (international and domestic) influencing China's exports, with firm-level and individual-level factors being significantly under-researched. This suggests a potential blind spot in understanding the micro-dynamics of export success.
- "Hot" Topic, Late Start: While China's export growth is a popular research topic, the bulk of the literature (88%) emerged in the decade between 2007 and 2016, indicating a relatively recent surge in academic interest.
- Reliance on Secondary Data: Empirical studies heavily rely on secondary data, with only a tiny fraction (around 2%) collecting their own first-hand data. This highlights a potential limitation in the depth and specificity of some analyses.
- Broad Units of Analysis: Most studies adopt broad units of analysis, examining all types of exported products or broad geographical regions (e.g., the whole of China). This can obscure important variations and specificities within different sectors or regions.
Key Results
The systematic review identified a total of 269 factors influencing China's export growth. The most frequently studied factors, appearing at least 30 times, include:
- Inward Foreign Direct Investment (iFDI): Consistently found to have a positive impact on exports, though some studies note a lag effect.
- RMB Exchange Rate: Generally correlated negatively with China's export, with appreciation often hindering exports.
- Importer's Market Demand: Positively correlated with China's export, often analyzed using the Constant Market Share (CMS) model.
- Product Competitiveness: Identified as a critical driver of China's export growth by a significant number of studies.
- Barrier to Trade (BT): Primarily found to negatively influence exports, although some studies suggest TBT can have positive long-term effects due to improved productivity and technology.
- 2008 Financial Crisis: Consistently found to have decreased exports, though it also spurred innovation.
- Importer's GDP: Positively correlated with China's export.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that their database, while large, might not be exhaustive, and suggest that future reviews could employ an "up-stream" strategy (checking references of found papers) to further expand the database. A key limitation identified is the broad unit of analysis used in most studies, which may not adequately capture the nuances of regional or sectoral export dynamics.
The paper strongly recommends future research to adopt more narrow-down units of analysis, focusing on specific provinces, industries, or firm types (e.g., POEs vs. SOEs). Furthermore, the authors highlight the significant under-exploration of micro-level factors, particularly the decision-making processes of entrepreneurs and managers within Chinese firms. They propose that investigating how these individual-level choices influence export performance is a promising direction for gaining a more complete understanding of China's export success.
Summary updated