“We’re Still Struggling a Bit to Actually Figure Out What That Means for Government”: An Exploration of the Policy Capacity Required to Oversee Robot Technologies in Australia and New Zealand Care Services

Helen Dickinson, Catherine Smith, Nicole Carey, Gemma CareyInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Governments in Australia and New Zealand are struggling to develop the policy capacity needed to effectively oversee the growing use of robotic technologies in care services. The key challenge isn't a lack of technical expertise, but rather a deficit in understanding the broader societal, ethical, and systemic impacts of these technologies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global "care crisis," characterized by rising demand for care services and a shrinking workforce, is leading to increased interest in robotic technologies as a potential solution. While robots offer benefits like efficiency and reduced infection risk, they also present challenges, including potential misuse and unintended consequences. Historically, disruptive technologies require robust policy frameworks to harness their benefits while mitigating harms. This paper investigates the specific policy capacity governments in Australia and New Zealand need to effectively govern the integration of robots into their care sectors, identifying gaps and proposing necessary capabilities.

Methods

The study employed a qualitative research approach using semi-structured interviews with 35 key stakeholders involved in the implementation of robots in Australian and New Zealand care services. Participants included academics, care providers, government officials, and technology suppliers. The interviews explored current uses, advantages, disadvantages, and future roles of robots, with a particular focus on the government's role in oversight. Data analysis involved a thematic approach, categorizing and sub-categorizing interview responses to identify overarching themes related to policy capacity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Care Crisis" as a Driver: The paper frames the increasing adoption of robots within the context of a significant societal challenge in providing adequate care.
  • Policy Capacity is Crucial, But Ill-Defined: While universally acknowledged as essential for successful policy implementation, "policy capacity" itself is often vaguely understood, making it difficult to measure or improve.
  • Beyond Technical Skills: The most significant policy capacity gaps identified were not in understanding the technical aspects of robotics, but in grasping their broader systemic impacts, ethical considerations, and societal implications.
  • Market-Led Adoption: The current trend sees technology manufacturers leading the adoption of robots, creating an information asymmetry where governments may lack the foresight to steer development effectively.
  • The Need for a Systems Approach: Overseeing robotic technologies in care is not merely about adopting new tools; it's about intervening in complex socio-technical systems with far-reaching consequences.

Key Results

  • Perceived Lack of Government Capacity: A consistent theme across interviews was the perception that governments in Australia and New Zealand lack sufficient policy capacity to effectively oversee robotic technologies in care services.
  • Gaps in Understanding Systemic Impacts: Respondents highlighted a deficit in understanding the ethical, privacy, data security, and equity implications of robots, rather than a lack of technical knowledge.
  • Individual Capabilities: Key individual capacities include the ability to differentiate between robot types, understand complex system impacts, strategic management, communication, and negotiation skills.
  • Organizational Capabilities: Essential organizational capacities involve specialist technological insight, understanding care models, developing regulatory frameworks, effective collaboration, and evidence analysis.
  • Systemic Capabilities: At the systemic level, crucial capabilities include horizon scanning, understanding complex systems, market stewardship, adequate fiscal systems, privacy and data sharing expertise, and robust infrastructure.
  • Emphasis on Collaboration and Foresight: The findings strongly suggest that effective oversight requires collaboration across diverse stakeholders and a proactive, forward-looking approach to anticipate and manage the consequences of these technologies.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their research is based on the perceptions of 35 stakeholders, and further quantitative research could provide a broader understanding of policy capacity. They also note that while the paper outlines the required policy capacity, the actual implementation and development of these capabilities remain a significant challenge, especially given the observed decline in public service policy capacity over recent decades. Future work could focus on developing concrete strategies and frameworks for building this capacity within government agencies, potentially through targeted training, inter-agency collaboration, and the establishment of dedicated oversight bodies. The paper also implicitly suggests a need for more research into the specific ethical frameworks and regulatory models best suited for overseeing AI-driven robotic systems in sensitive care environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Many countries are experiencing a "care crisis" driven by increasing demand for care services alongside difficulties in recruiting and retaining an appropriate care workforce. One of the solutions offered to this is the use of robotic technologies. While there are several positives produced by robots, they are not without challenges and have the potential to be misused. History shows disruptive technologies require appropriate policy capacity for these to be effectively stewarded so that we can secure the positive gains of these without encountering potential harms. In this paper, we explore the types of policy capacity needed to oversee robotic technologies. Drawing on interviews with 35 key stakeholders involved with the implementation of robots in Australian and New Zealand care services, we identify the capabilities required at the individual, organisational, and systemic levels across the analytical, operational, and political domains. We found the respondents perceived a lack of policy capacity to oversee robotics in the government. However, these gaps are less in respect to technological skills and abilities and more in respect to the system's impacts and effects of these technologies. We conclude by outlining a summary of the capabilities required to oversee robots in complex care systems.
BibTeX
@article{dickinson2022were,
  author = {Helen Dickinson and Catherine Smith and Nicole Carey and Gemma Carey},
  title = {{“We’re Still Struggling a Bit to Actually Figure Out What That Means for Government”: An Exploration of the Policy Capacity Required to Oversee Robot Technologies in Australia and New Zealand Care Services}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph19084696},
}
Figure