Abstract
Hierarchical theories of structure formation predict that clusters of galaxies should be embedded in a web-like structure, with filaments emanating from them to large distances. The amount of mass contained within such filaments near a cluster can be comparable to the collapsed mass of the cluster itself. Diffuse infalling material also contains a large amount of mass. Both these components can contribute to the cluster weak lensing signal. This "projection bias" is maximized if a filament lies close to the line-of-sight to a cluster. Using large-scale numerical simulations of structure formation in a cosmological constant dominated cold dark matter model, we show that the projected mass typically exceeds the actual mass by several tens of percent. This effect is significant for attempts to estimate cluster masses through weak lensing observations and will affect weak lensing surveys aimed at constructing the cluster mass function.
Introduction
To understand the evolution of our universe, astronomers must accurately determine the masses of galaxy clusters. While traditional methods like X-ray observations or galaxy velocity dispersions are commonly used, they often rely on the assumption that the cluster is in dynamical equilibrium. Weak gravitational lensing—the measurement of subtle distortions in the shapes of background galaxies caused by a foreground cluster's gravity—has emerged as a powerful alternative because it is sensitive to the total mass regardless of its dynamical state.
However, lensing measures the total mass integrated along the line of sight. This study addresses a critical challenge: how much does the "cosmic web"—the filaments and diffuse matter surrounding a cluster—pollute the lensing signal and bias mass estimates?
Methodology
The researchers employed high-resolution numerical simulations of a $\Lambda$CDM universe using a particle-mesh N-body code with adaptive mesh refinement. Three distinct rich clusters were selected for detailed analysis. Each cluster was "observed" from 10,000 randomly chosen viewing angles to simulate various orientations relative to the surrounding large-scale structure.
For each orientation, a projected surface density map was created to calculate the "projected" $r_{200}$ and the corresponding mass. These values were then compared to the true 3D mass of the cluster to quantify the bias.
Key Results: The Impact of Projection Bias
The simulations demonstrate that the surrounding environment systematically inflates mass estimates. Because clusters are located at the intersections of massive filaments, a line of sight almost always intersects significant additional mass.
Key findings include:
- Systematic Overestimation: Projected mass estimates typically exceed the actual mass by several tens of percent.
- Extreme Cases: Depending on the orientation of filaments, mass overestimates can reach 80% or more.
- Mass Profile Variance: The study found that two different lines of sight for the same cluster could result in inferred masses differing by a factor of 1.7.
- Environmental Influence: The majority of this bias stems from material located outside the cluster's virial radius, rather than the cluster's own non-spherical shape.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The "projection bias" is a significant systematic effect in weak lensing studies. While massive clusters are relatively "cleaner," smaller clusters are more susceptible to being "drowned out" by their environment. These results represent a lower limit on the bias, as the simulations used a limited spherical volume. Future research with larger sample sizes is necessary to develop robust statistical corrections for observers, ensuring that cluster mass functions can be used accurately to constrain cosmological models.
Summary updated